Okay, so I have Spearow, but Shuckle is a bit of weird case. I talked to him in both my games and he said something about true happiness. I think what happened is I did get it from him, but then talked to him again later with it and it had high enough happiness that he had me keep it. I do have a Shuckle on my HeartGold with the right nickname, but it has my OT and ID and is a higher level (Lv. 23 but seems UT). I can't find any info on this issue so I'm not sure what's up. Unfortunately I don't think I have time to dedicate to a new playthrough so I wouldn't be able to reset a game to get it for you. >> I could try it on my Japanese games but it seems you wouldn't be interested in that.