The main thing with pokeradar is I felt it wasn't equal because there is some amount of skill involved. Some people just can't get to the 1/200 chance, while others can easily.
Yes, there's still a random component to it, just like any other shiny hunting method. However, because there is SOME skill involved that can bring the odds down so significantly, I chose to not include it as a method for these types of hunts.
This is not to say that there will never be a time where pokeradar is included in the CHs. I do plan to have a pokeradar hunt at some point among the choices for the CH.
No matter what I do, some people won't be happy with the CH. This time was very broad, some hate it, others like it. Next time will likely be far more restricted, and the people who didn't like this hunt will be happier next time.
Yes, I am taking this as a personal attack, because I am having a really horrible day. I shouldn't, but I can't help it. It's one more thing on the pile of crap going wrong. So sorry if I'm snippy with you. I'm trying to mix up the hunts so that everyone gets something they enjoy at some point, rather than catering to a specific few.