Well, I'm looking at this from a neutral position, and you probably won't like what I say. Firstly, it seems that you are expecting a +2 for some reason, but you only have a +1 coming to you since your only booster for rolls was the suit which only ever gives +1 in a turn. As such, you should have gotten a 2. A 2 is a failure, so you would have failed to get in. Also, the belt only protects against magic. The web was not magic, so you were not protected against it. Also, as Digi pointed out, it was the final boss so you are rather lucky you only got a -2 after the shield absorbed the three damage. Literally the only thing I would have changed was that you would get to keep your angels. Sorry if this isn't what you expected, but that is what I think.
On a side-question, why go to me? I'm just the most active ref. Why not go to Med or Mug, his actual co-owners?