3-D Pokemon Better or Worse?

[Kabuto]

Is 3-D Pokemon Better or Worse than 2-D?

Here are some positives and negatives-

Positive-

1.Snagging is a new idea

2. No annoying wild pokemon stop you while walking through fields.

3. Better sets are available to purified pokemon

4. Nicer looking

Negative-

1. Limited Pokemon

2. Battles take three times as long from move animations.

3. No GYMS or Elite 4

Post more if you want

 

[Kijuna]

Positive -

1. Distracts those who want more plot in a game about friendly competition

Negative -

1. Snagging is a bad idea

2. No wild Pokémon for you to catch the old fashioned way

3. You have to re-snag over and over again to get a Pokémon with a good nature and IV's if you want that move, and you need to purify without saving

4. No sprites

5. Limited Pokémon

6. Battles take way longer from animations that aren't good in the first place.

7. No Gyms or Elite 4

8. Plots that make NO SENSE

9. Takes the pocket out of pocket monster. So really it's Mon XD.

 

[Zora]

PC had a plot that made no sense. XD had a plot that made some sense.

 

[pokemon master:Stranger]

some of you get it so wrong the plot is better then gba games witch never seem to change the core of the games on the gameboy are all the same snaging is stupid idea put in because its an easy way out of not making 3D wild pokemon the pokemon have not advanced in looks from stadium the attacks are okay but you still dont see the pokemon fighting so the 3d is pointless, colosseum/XD are games where if you sit down and think you start to notice the games are lazy and pointless but both games help gameboy players with rare pokemon and items but in other words the game is crap anyway evan if there are nice things for people that want to play it.

 

[Akerin]

I think the snagging idea is weird. Mind you I've never really played Colosseum or XD (at least not yet...I'm getting XD for xmas), but from what I've observed when my friend plays is that you just go around catching other people's Pokemon. You've gotta wonder how these people, even IF they're evil, can put up with a stranger taking away their Pokemon. I'd rather catch them in the wild than snag them. :/

I don't like Double Battles. It was a neat idea at first, but in Colosseum (I don't know about XD, but I assume it's the same) it seems like practically EVERY battle is double. There should be more 1 on 1 battles, like the good old days of Stadium.

The best thing about XD is being able to start with Eevee.
The best thing about Colosseum is being able to start with Umbreon and Espeon,
even though I do wish they weren't male 100% of the time. :/