1. We have moved to a new forum system. All your posts and data should have transferred over. Welcome, to the new Serebii Forums. Details here
    Dismiss Notice
  2. Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
    Dismiss Notice
  3. If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders
    Dismiss Notice

Advanceshipping General Discussion: Where Ash and May ADVANCE together ;D

Discussion in 'Shippers Community' started by Gazmof, Jun 29, 2008.

  1. Ðãmon Howe

    Ðãmon Howe Stop posting DH.

    ....well, I'm not so sure about that fanfic idea...personally, seems a little out there. But hey, if you can make it work by all means, go for it.

    As far as that scene is concerned, this is an idea I had for a fanfic about it but never got around to/had the heart to write.

    Ash is standing in the hall and everyone is gathered around, waiting as Ash is presented the Staff of Aaron (or whatever its called). As he is presented the staff and all the formalities, they begin the ball. But first, the "Guardian" gets to choose his "partner" and have the honorary first dance. Flustered, Ash chooses May...and the awkwardness begins. :)

    I also have a few alternatives; one, instead of choosing outright the Guardian (Ash) must go out and dance with every willing girl in the place to determine his partner (and since he's the Guardian of course, everyone wants him) and of course May is shoved to the back of the line so by the time he gets to dance with her he's thrilled...and since there's a few more in line she starts to get bumped off but he holds on and dances with her a little more....and a little more....etc

    ....but that's just my thoughts. So many options, so little time.
     
    Last edited: May 24, 2011
  2. Lord Zant

    Lord Zant Two jobs. ugh

    Wahoo, finals are over. Let summer begin! (for me :p)

    I love the fanfiction ideas, guys. (Also, I was going back to my roots a few days ago, and I realized May's Crush turns five on July 15th! Has it really been that long? :O We need to have a party or something.)

    I agree with Swampert - the best thing Lucario gave us was fan-art and the Brawl character.
     
  3. Gazmof

    Gazmof Zephyr Trainer

    I've just been rewatching the DP episodes where May appears, and one thing that always annoyed me was that Dawn and May were the ones on a tag battle team, not Ash and May. I've always wanted to see both of them compete as a team in a tag battle and it's never occurred in a big event. It could have been a great showing of their chemistry and teamwork, but oh well - I guess we'll have to rely on fanfiction to see something like that happen.

    Was I the only person to feel this way about the DP episodes?

    Also, I don't understand why Ash couldn't immediately recognize May's Beautifly - he's normally really good at telling the difference between Pokemon, and it's not like he wasn't expecting to see her when the boat arrived.
     
  4. Ðãmon Howe

    Ðãmon Howe Stop posting DH.

    Personally I think that after the Battle Frontier, Ash's anime intelligence went back down to Indigo League levels...idk, but in the Advance generation, he seemed to be the mentor to May but in DP he seemed less like a mentor and more like a companion/friendly rival.
     
  5. Lorde

    Lorde Banned

    I totally agree. I liked that May and Dawn bonded during the Wallace Cup and everything, but it would've made more sense for Ash and May to have teamed up for a tag battle. I remember there being an opening where Ash and May were shown battling against two trainers together, but that might not have been canon, so we really did need something solid in the anime. I just hope that it happens again when May reappears. I strongly believe that she will appear again in a future episode, so lets hope that she teams up with Ash for a tag battle.
     
  6. Gazmof

    Gazmof Zephyr Trainer

    100% agreed. That's actually one of the major reasons I disliked the DP anime, but that's a discussion for another place and time. Every time he would traditionally see a Pokemon he'd know right away which one it was if he had been around it long enough.

    Yep - Advanced Challenge intro. That was actually what first made me like the idea and I wanted to see it seriously acted upon in the anime but I was left disappointed. I remember when I first saw it I thought it was a clip from an actual episode and was constantly expecting to see it at some point in time.
     
  7. Lorde

    Lorde Banned

    Yeah, same here. I'm disappointed that the writers didn't have Ash and May team up for some serious tag battles. It's sort of ironic too, since Advanced Generation officially introduced two-on-two battles. Well, there's always the future to look forward to. I'm sure that Ash and May will team up for some serious battles later on. I'm almost positive that May will reappear when Contests are shown in the anime again. I think there's a good chance that we'll see Contests once again, so that means that May won't be too far behind :p
     
  8. Ðãmon Howe

    Ðãmon Howe Stop posting DH.

    I like that idea! Totally use it for a fic!

    As for Ash and May tag battling, yeah that was a little disappointing that they didn't do as much as they could've with it, but they did have a little of it in "The Bicker the Better" (I think that's the right episode).
    What I'm really disappointed about is the Kyogue v. Groudon mini-movie. Seriously, they could've done so much with that besides just have Pikachu and Archie duke it out until they both quit for some weird reason or another. It would've been REALLY interesting to have team Magma's/Aqua's plans completely backfire when Ash gets captured. Instead of Archie winding up with the Red Orb and Pikachu with the Blue, what if Ash and May were bonded to the Orbs? Hold it, think of the possibilities for a second...
     
    Last edited: Jun 1, 2011
  9. Midnightmoon6o2

    Midnightmoon6o2 "Tougher than you."

    Yeah, the irony is kinda funny. But they did have a tag battle once (and a million in fanfics. XD) I believe that contests aren't dead as well because the musicals are like contests in a way. just without the moves. And May was part of Ash's life as well so the writers can't just dump May like they did with Tracey. And AG is getting repeated in Japan the most so really the writers have no excuse to dump May.

    And also, a few anti-advanceshippers are bashing our ship again. what sad people.
     
  10. pokefandt

    pokefandt Well-Known Member

    Not too much into shipping, but my first major pokemon fiction in general was Trials of the Elite Four by Dryuu on FF.NET, and ADVshipping has been my favorite since I guess.

    Look up LuciferIX on the site as well, he's probably one of the best writers for that shipping on FF.NET
     
  11. swampert55

    swampert55 Well-Known Member

    It was also that tag battles were not available in single player until Emerald, so perhaps that had something to do with it. The focus seemed to be more on double battles. Anyway, I feels as though there should have been some sort of tag battle competition in the BF as additional filler, as the season focused on the Battle Frontier introduced in Emerald; introducing tag battles would have seemed logical as well.

    EDIT: It turns out that there are more dedicated Advanceshippers than we:

    [IMG139]http://imgsrc.baidu.com/forum/pic/item/dc0c647a5059f84b8882a161.jpg[/IMG139]
     
    Last edited: Jun 8, 2011
  12. pokefandt

    pokefandt Well-Known Member

    He deleted it, along with Trials. Dryuu has been having "issues" with members of FF.NET and keeps taking down and reuploading his stories. Trials of the E4 and sequal not included unfortunately.
     
  13. Midnightmoon6o2

    Midnightmoon6o2 "Tougher than you."

    Dryuu is such a great advanceshipping writer and is one of the classics. the sad thing is that he takes each review in a negative manner which starts a unfriendly conversation which soon Nina Lumos (His GF) comes in as well. I need my best friend Mat's (LuciferIX) help just to get him off my back after i reviewed on one of his fics. Even now he abuses people who just want to say what a great writer he is.

    I still reads his fics though after what i've been through with him. i still admire his writing style because i find it hard to find a good advanceshipping writer or fanfic these days.
     
    Last edited: Jun 14, 2011
  14. Ðãmon Howe

    Ðãmon Howe Stop posting DH.

    I know Dryuu was/is a good author....never reviewed his stories though for some reason. Guess that's a good thing, since I'm a critical reviewer.
     
  15. Lord Zant

    Lord Zant Two jobs. ugh

    Dryuu always had fantastic creativity and astounding drive, but I don't know if he was a native English speaker or not. I only reviewed a little - he wrote them too fast for me to review. But he certainly is a classic.
     
  16. Ðãmon Howe

    Ðãmon Howe Stop posting DH.

    Makes me wonder how many recognized "great" advanceshipping authors there are...both past ones and one's that are still around.
     
  17. pokefandt

    pokefandt Well-Known Member

    I've basically stopped reading his stories cause half the time they're taken down before I have much of a chance to get into them.

    You're friends with LuciferIX, have you read his most recent stuff? Its real good.

    On his FF.NEt profile it says he is from the Philippines so likely not.
     
  18. Lord Zant

    Lord Zant Two jobs. ugh

    Ah, okay. And yeah, I get notifications on my email-enabled phone every time he uploads a chapter - he'll sometimes delete and reupload the same fic several times in a week.

    LuciferIX is definitely one to look into. He's very skilled.
     
  19. Gaiash

    Gaiash Champion Scientist

  20. Hunter_RuLe

    Hunter_RuLe < Guess who's back?

    Hi everyone, good to see advanceshipping and this thread are still alive. Props to all you guys, especially the veterans like Gaz, Swamp and Gaiash that are still here after all those years.

    Now, let me also add something constructive. First I'll answer the last topic I could find, and what do you know it's actually quite a fresh original one at that!

    Do you think Contestshipping actually helped Advanceshipping to grow?

    Yes and No. At first I thought CS would be nothing but hostile towards the our favourite paring. More and more episodes containing contests and May - Drew dialogues seemed to take away screentime for moments between Ash and May. Moreover CS was the ‘new thing’and took away the thunder and some of the supporters of our shipping. I think I was afraid the writers would centralize the show to much around the rivalry, which would result in a downgrading of the moments the main characters build their relation upon.

    However, in retrospect I think we can actually be glad about the existence of CS. Two major rival shippings happening within the same anime seasons made things all the more interesting. Not only did it gave some new dynamics and new possibilities, like speculated jealousy, the inevitable comparison also gave us fan seven more reason to focus on the details of the interaction between Ash and May. It was only by that time, many of us noticed cute little things like May’s tendency to hold Ash’s arm, ect. Much like Gazmof stated, the introduction of CS more drama and arguably more appreciation of the shippy moments that we did getting. Most of all we should realize that most of us like advanceshipping because of the unique, indescribable chemistry between the two characters.

    To bring some more discussion in the thread, I would also like to add a new topic. It’s much like a classic Advanceshipping question, but a little twist.

    It’s common knowledge that the interaction between Ash and May has been based on a intimate friendship aswell as a good old student-mentor relationship. Both know each other very well, they seldom have had much arguments and I believe they have an ultimate trust in eachother. Although this is all very nice and may give us cute loving moments, it does not exactly give much excitement in the form of (sexual) tension , ect. Although Ash was new and existing for May at the start, he’s become a very comfortable, almost brother-like, friend which she could always fall back on.

    In the Advance Generation both trainers (and especially May) gained much from their friendship. Therefore they never may have wanted to put this at risk in a try to get their relation to another, less comfortable level (of passionate love). Do you think the time Ash and May have spend apart may affect this position? In other words, do you think the independent development of both characters may change the way they see eachother and thus the way they interact?

    And just like in the old days, I'd like to end my post with a fan art. This time it's an art by atharple.

    [img139]http://fc00.deviantart.net/fs71/i/2010/234/b/9/Because_the_sky_is_there_by_Atharple.jpg[/img139]

    Lift up your head and look at the future you're creating!
    The wind brushes your cheeks, I'm sure it'll say:
    "It's okay if you fall. You are you and that makes you wonderful!"
    Because the sky is there...
     

Share This Page