I know I always complain about him but... This Tomiyasu regime hasn't been that good.
It seems like he is only content with slice of life and anything that is not it, be it a serialized arc or something that's a corporate mandate, just falls flat. And to diminish that, he just resort to cheap marketing like pushing the popular starter and the overhyped Gen 8 mon as a dynamic duo, follow the Galar arc with a Mewtwo episode.... All those "hey look at me" that are all gimmicks at the end of the day.
Sure he's done a good service pointing a route for the anime to adapt itself to what a kids' show is supposed to be and play in the current era - even if I'd argue early Yokai Watch did it first - but he is failing on delivering anything that strays away from his preference.
Compare the Alola trip to the Mewtwo episode (he is done the storyboard for the later). Night and day. Sun and Moon (pun intended).
I know that people has issue with him and he is far from perfect, but there's no doubt Yuyama was a blessing for this show and I'd even go as far as to say he is one of the key responsibles for the anime to be so sucessful and enduring. I never felt he really "intruded" on what was going on other series and most of the time he allowed room for some change ups even when they were faced with what's clearly a mandate (like making BW be more like the first series). Also, I felt like he let the series' directors do their own thing.
Here I just feel like Maki Kodaira is just having things and mandates thrown at her to the point one could she is a glorified secretary. The Olleana to his Rose lol
Outside of appearances, Raboot in general aren't edgy. That is something the anime interpreted. Raboot looks like that because it so happens that's what soccer players in training wear.
The whole evolution line is literally a little kid (Scorbunny) who trains hard (Raboot) to become a professional soccer player (Cinderace). It's not a cheerful kid going emo but then ends up being a kiddy adult. That's...not how things work.
I agree with you here.
Also, I don't really buy the cheerful kid - rebel teenage - cheerful adult comparison because... It doesn't work that way.
Going from happy kid to tsundere emo teenage works specially in the context of WHEN Scorbunny evolved into Scorbunny (coming fresh of a misunderstanding with Goh). But from tsundere teenage to basically back to factory settings as a cheerful? I don't buy it. Going from teenage to adult usually means you grow up and get over that weird rebelious phase to become something else. Not the you from childhood but not the one from adolescence either. You can still have the edge of adolescence but still allow yourself to be the cheerful kid.
The only way that swift would work is if they had the transition smoother. And it doesn't even need much. Like, just a little scene from right after Goh beats the G-Garbordor, Raboot does the "foot-five" thing with him, signaling he is finally getting over being so moody and start displaying more of his great love towards his trainer. It would make him doing it post-evolution even more meaningful.
Really, it bothers me Goh didn't make a bigger deal of Cinderace basically a bigger Scorbunny. I mean, from giving him the cold shoulder as Raboot to suddenly being no embarassed of hugging and cuddling him as Cinderace is quite... Significant. Gee, even a line of "that's why you are greatest partner", "that's who we really are" or "that's the best, evolved version of ourselves" would have worked. Anything cliche would work, just make me feel fullfilled with the evolution. Make me FEEL, danm it.
And that's from someone who likes Goh's character and prefered Scorbunny over Raboot (even if I grew to like the later).