Do you actually think I care about something like " imo? " That's not what I'm talking about. Literally just see your first post in this thread where you make a bunch of claims about the XY " fanservice " and load your statements in doing so when every single one of those episodes had their controversy and major critiques. That's what I'm talking about. You literally did it in this thread in your first post, how blatant can it get?
Just replying to this portion coz a) it's still kinda in relation to what the discussion was originally happening here and people are already annoyed
b) the rest of the argument is just going in plain circles again, and one I'm not interested in having simply because I still believe you're blind if you think there has been absolutely no doom posting or cynical attitude just because at times people gave JN the benefit of the doubt which it might not have deserved.
Okay then, my bunch of claims are literally me stating what happened in the episodes. My post isn't to say these episodes are good guys, all the XY episodes have been excellent
It's to argue one and only one point going on in this thread for 5 pages: 'Tomiyasu hates XY and purposely wants to **** on it'
Let's go to my points:
1) I say Clemont and Bonnie returned to train Ash, and Drasna and Wikstrom had their roles and the honour of being Ash's first elite 4 battle on the 25th anniversary of the anime. These are objective facts, that's the plot of the episode. These being well handled or not is another debate, and you would recall I absolutely trashed the Drasna episode and hated how it was done, with the poor animation. But with my original point, if indeed Tomiyasu hates XY, why would be even attempt this? You could have Bruno be the first Elite four member Ash beats or something. Why make Clemont and bonnie return, Cilan didn't.
2) Serena was indeed a mentor to Chloe in that episode, admired Ash and used his quotes to help Chloe, and is reminiscent of when Aria mentored Serena. Now, was it handled good again is indeed a different topic, you know my opinion I know yours. But it's a fact, that this happened. Was it paralleled properly/Is it a good step ahead for Serena/her admiring Ash and that ending scene isn't enough or it implies a platonic relationship more than a loved one, sure we can argue about that. But if indeed Tomiyasu hates XY, he would never have attempted or given Serena the role of ending Chloe's arc. (Also let's not pretend it was controversial since atleast on serebiiforums, the majority of people here liked it with you being the few ones here who didn't. Idk about other sites, Twitter always likes everything and I don't really follow Pokemon elsewhere)
4) Greninja did clown Lucario, and was meant to be a mentor for it. Again, was it handled well? We can argue. But again, if Tomiyasu hated XY, he didn't need Greninja to return. Squirtle never did. Just have Riley return or give us M08 fanservice
My original post was never me forcing my opinions on someone that hey all the XY elements were handled great. Subjective. But if Tomiyasu hated XY and was malicious towards it, he would never have attempted this or done this. That's always been my original point and only point to all the posters going on that Tomiyasu hates XY (which btw, hey, is a cynical attitude towards Tomiyasu, assuming pure malice because they weren't competent enough in your eyes)
This has since blown into a full argument between me and you based on out of topic things and our prior history. Simply because you wanted to continue taking jabs at me and antagonising me, so Don't go ahead and pin it on me being the reason for this unecessary out of topic discussion when I was replying to the contents already being discussed here itself. Thank you