Ash vs Red

[ShinyMienshao]

Do you think if ash and red had an all out epic brawl who would win? I'm voting for red of course but I'm curious to see as to who would think otherwise.

EDIT: The Red from the second generation games.

 

[Grei]

Red is infinitely cooler than Ash, and always will be.

 

[TrainerJecht]

Definitely Red, without a doubt in my mind. Would love to see that battle though

 

[greatguy]

Red dismantled Team Rocket single-handedly.

Ash beat up two incompetent idiots.

Red stayed in Kanto and continued training.

Ash left and got a power reboot.

Red trained on top of Mount Silver in light clothes.

Ash slept in sleeping bags.

Red completed the Dex.

Ash used that data.

Who do YOU think will win?

 

[Serebii!]

Red, he is the strongest trainer and stays at Mt Silver. Red is much better than Ash

 

[ShinyMienshao]

All right so far no ash. Let's see if it stays that way.

 

[Not_A_Cyberbully]

I'd like to say Ash, but in a real battle, Red wins.

 

[★Midnight★]

Red would win of course.
He's stronger, and better than Ash. No offence..

 

[(P.O.K.E.M.O.N)]

Ash without a doubt

His infernape would wipe out red's team

 

[32er]

ash without a doubt

his infernape would wipe out red's team

lol .

 

[(·-·)(o_O)]

Red would win of course but the battle would really be epic!

 

[wιɴтerвreezeѕrυle]

Red, definately. He did so much... and he actually stuck with his orgional team, minus a few changes here and there. (Then again, I haven't read much of the Pokemon Adventures series as of late.)

But Red for sure.

 

[Cookiesandberries]

Red evolves his pokemon.
/thread.

 

[RedJirachi]

Red. If Ash actually focused on his training instead of being some sort of disorder(that, and the plot demands him to be stupid), he'd have a chance. Unfortunately for him, his series prints money!

 

[CliveKoopa]

Red is a better battler but I prefer Ash as a person.

 

[randomspot555]

Red evolves his pokemon.
/thread.

*facepalm*

 

[Aura Of Twilight]

Red. At least he doesn't continue to lose constantly and not learn from his mistakes.

 

[(P.O.K.E.M.O.N)]

lol .

It's true though, ash's infernape is a force to be reckon with

And red has
Pikachu
Blastoise
Venusaur
Lapras
Snorlax
Charazard

And if ash were to pick his best 6
Pikachu
Infernape
Sceptile
Charazard
Snorlax
Staraptor

Blastoise vs scepitle [ sceptile wins] ash 1- red 0
Sceptile vs charazard [charazard wins] ash 1 - red 1
Charazard vs Infernape [infernape wins] ash 2 - red 1
Infernape vs lapras [infernape wins] ash 3 - red 1
Infernape vs Snorlax [infernape wins] Ash 4 - red 1
Infernape vs Pikachu [Pikachu wins] ash 4 - red 2
Pikachu vs Sceptile [sceptile wins] ash 5 - red 2
Sceptile vs venusaur [venusaur wins] ash 5 - red 3
Charazard vs venusaur [charazard wins] ash wins

 

[RealRaymon]

It's true though, ash's infernape is a force to be reckon with
Blastoise vs scepitle [ sceptile wins] ash 1- red 0
Sceptile vs charazard [charazard wins] ash 1 - red 1
Charazard vs Infernape [infernape wins] ash 2 - red 1
Infernape vs lapras [infernape wins] ash 3 - red 1
Infernape vs Snorlax [infernape wins] Ash 4 - red 1
Infernape vs Pikachu [Pikachu wins] ash 4 - red 2
Pikachu vs Sceptile [sceptile wins] ash 5 - red 2
Sceptile vs venusaur [venusaur wins] ash 5 - red 3
Charazard vs venusaur [charazard wins] ash wins

You definitely like Infernape, don`t you?(=
But you forgot that Ash`s Infernape moves are Dig Flamethrower Flare Blitz and Mach Punch
So Red`s Charizard would win after one or two Air Slashes

And Ash`s six best are:
Charizard
Pikachu
Sceptile
Bulbasaur
Squirtle
Infernape(Snorlax)because he is strong when blaze activates only

 

[nandamaung]

Red will win without a doubt. Ash is no match for him.