dman_dustin
Well-Known Member
No it doesn't. Ash can battle anyone he wants, there's nothing stopping him from battling another trainer he meets instead. And Ash having a rival is getting boring in my opinion anyway because he (almost) always has one.
Yes it does, because having a rival, forces the writers to write battles, that ordinairly wouldn't exist.
Proof?
Hoenn.
Ash didn't have a rival, and he barely HAD ANY battles outside of Team Rocket and Gym Leaders, or as a result of training for a loss. The extra battles were so far between, there was no guarantee Ash was going to have a random battle.
So I'm not saying Ash won't have fluff battles, because he will.
What I'm saying is if he doesn't have a rival, those fluff battles, are going to be so far between, he might as well not have fluff battles anyway.