I think people as usual are being WAY too over critical of 5th Generation games
YER! I know that's as fans it's our job to be critical, the voice of the series but there's a limit!
Everywhere you look there's a nostalgic fan boy ala "gen wunner".
I won't even elaborate on that as it's self-explanatory.
If you're nostalgic, tough luck because chances are you're missing out on the big THINGS in Pokemon, how utterly sad!
I strongly feel that BW/BW2 especially BW2 are the best games we've had so far..yes you heard me..
Of course if your nostalgic then it's all about Kanto/Johto or Hoenn, there's always that boohaa regardless.
Linearity apparently kills the experience. BS! Sure linear structures aren't as fun but they're not that bad! SNM..
Apparently purple dirt and pokeballs are better designed mons then the ice cream cones.
Subjectivity. Bias & stupidity. Need I say more? People think that everything made in "Gen wun" was amazing.
Gen 5 however they're "apparently" running out of ideas.
Isshu was amazing, I liked the bridges in particular.
Great region slightly tainted by the linear progress.
Gamefreak held their own & I applaud them for that.
The greater emphasis on story driven plots was amazing much better then past games.
We got great character development, again much better then past games.
Music was above awesomeness in BW2.
The Pokemon were AWEsum :] I don't base my opinions over the scrawny gen wunners & their awesome Rattata's.
As posted earlier both games go hand in hand very well. Playing both gives you the full experience
but it's not a necessity just better that way.
BW1 were great introduction to Isshu, better then DP were for Sinnoh IMO..YEAH!
BW2 was a great sequel and major improvement over it's predecessor.
Actually I think putting it simply, BW2 are the best games we've had so far.
They had everything. Great music, decent storyline, HUGE dex, plenty of post-game, PWT & past characters, medal system & even the PokeStar studios which I enjoyed..& just so much more..