1. We have moved to a new forum system. All your posts and data should have transferred over. Welcome, to the new Serebii Forums. Details here
    Dismiss Notice
  2. Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
    Dismiss Notice
  3. If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders
    Dismiss Notice

Battle-Dazzling the Nimbasa Gym! (711)

Discussion in 'Pokémon Black & White - Rival Destinies' started by Serebii, Sep 29, 2011.

  1. In short, this episode can be described as follows:
    My sides are in orbit! :)

    I chuckled when Elesa said "Zebstrika, you look beautiful even when covered with mud!"

    "But I wanted to win the match with just you (Palpitoed)!"
    Well, you know what? Tough cheese! Life is unfair!

    Then wen he just runs out to get a different Pokemon, and no one stopped him, I was like "Wait, what is happening right now?!" I was that confused.

    And finally:
    "Doesn't Ash know Attract won't work between girls!?"
    Well, this is a kids show, so, of course it doesn't.

    I usually don't do this with episodes, but:

    10/10 would lel again. :)
     
  2. To be honest it's pretty stupid that Attract doesn't work for both genders at least IMO.

    Anyway... this gym battle was really bad. First Ash wants to win the entire battle with only Palpitoad, then he forgets Snivy is a girl, and then Pikachu stars in the gym once again when he really didn't need to. I don't know if this is an attempt to redeem him for losing against Excadrill or something, but it really made Snivy look bad.
     
  3. Champion Elik

    Champion Elik Member

    that tynamo was insanely.utterly and devastatingly awesome
     
    FullmetalJackie likes this.
  4. Altinator

    Altinator Standby for Battle!!

    This episode is an embarrassment to both Ash and gym battles. Ok lets beat all of her pokemon with only Palpitoad. Palpitoad is eliminated?!? Thats not good, I don't have any other pokemon with me. Trolololol. YOU IDIOT!!! Ash should have been DQ after that in my opinion. I feel so sorry for Elesa. She had to deal with a pretty pathetic "veteran" trainer like Ash.
     
    pokedigijedi and FullmetalJackie like this.
  5. Locormus

    Locormus Can we please get the old forum back?

    Or didn't he realize that Elesa's Emolga was a girl? Who knows.

    To me, this is when the entire series went sour.

    Consider the fact that the writers added Palpitoad to Ash's team specifically to get past Elesa, or to make this trainwreck situation happen. Why do I think that? Because Palpitoad only had three more appearances after this battle/episode. THREE: Vs. Roxie pt2, Vs. Stephan (yet another Zebstrika!) and at Oak's. Lets let Ash capture something, build it up for one thing, and than.. leave it to rot except for arbitrary appearances.

    In my eyes, I can't see this gym battle and not think that they had this mock-scenario in mind and for this to happen, they needed Ash with a capable Ground-type, hence the forced capture of Palpitoad and lack of subsequent appearances (and achievements: a loss and tie) afterwards.

    Not to mention the pacing going mad after Nimbasa as well.
     
    pokedigijedi likes this.
  6. Pikachu979

    Pikachu979 Sinnoh Champion

    I dislike the way Ash acted in this Gym battle. Bringing Palpitoad is smart for a electric gym so i can give him credit there.
     
  7. JudySpell

    JudySpell Banned

    So the lesson here was that when Ash uses his brain for Gym matches things go wrong & he should always improvise?? How inspirational. 4/10
     
  8. Mrs. Oreo

    Mrs. Oreo Banned

    I appreciated how Ash was shown strategizing the night before he challenged Elesa. I loved how Ash's new Palpitoad took down Zebstrika and Elesa's Tynamo was so quick and strong, which surprised me hee hee.
     
  9. Leonhart

    Leonhart Well-Known Member

    Finally, Satoshi was able to challenge Kamitsure at the Raimon Gym. Satoshi preparing so hard for the battle was different from the norm, and I thought that Tsutarja should've done better against Kamitsure's Emonga. The lesson here seemed to be that Satoshi does better when he doesn't plan ahead.
     
    FullmetalJackie likes this.
  10. Wednesdayz

    Wednesdayz Banned

    This was such a dumb episode. It didn't make sense that Ash was out of options to battle Emolga with, as he had Roggenrola. An entertaining and at times funny episode, but Gym battle victories should reward the better traits of his character, not glorify the lesser ones. :x
     
  11. Oh... well this battle was cringy. Bringing one Pokemon to a 3 vs 3 battle? Come on Ash. Then Pikachu basically 1HKO's two thirds of Elesa's team, making Elesa and the rest of Ash's Pokemon look really weak. Especially Elesa, with her best Pokemon being a Tynamo that only knows Tackle?

    And forgetting Snivy is female... just wow. It would be way more acceptable if Ash forgot Attract only works on the opposite sex, I'd buy that.
     
  12. Alloutℯ

    Alloutℯ Banned

    Ash's battle just made me cringe at how he prepared for this battle. I get the feeling that the writers really want to disconnect Ash from his past adventures, because surely by now he wouldn't have tried something like relying on one Pokémon for an important battle.
     
  13. Mrs. Oreo

    Mrs. Oreo Banned

    I dunno if that was the main point per say. I think this episode showed that when Ash thinks too strategically, he can overlook the simple things and that he needs to think outside the box alot. But him planning ahead isn't a bad thing in general.
     
  14. Wednesdayz

    Wednesdayz Banned

    Eh, it seemed like the fact that Ash started making a comeback against Elesa when he ditched his plans really was a case of him showing us that his random battling style trumps well thought out strategies, though.
     
  15. pokedigijedi

    pokedigijedi Saiyan Jedi

    It me a long time to come up for a post for this thread, why? because this is among my least liked episodes of the series, made worst when you realize I am not a fan of the show anymore, and I had to try and figure out a way to speak my mind without raging or bashing so here we go:


    Ash actually decided to come up with a strategy for this gym instead of just winging it as he goes along, but in the end he pulls a rookie move by only bringing in one Pokemon, and a bunch of other stuff I won't get into, it was very painful episode.

    I also don't like how they made Ash relying on his "making it up as I go along" tactic seem superior to making a strategy, it feels like a broken Aesop to me.

    There is more but I have no good way of mentioning without raging and/or bashing so I will stop now
     
  16. Leonhart

    Leonhart Well-Known Member

    I feel that the writers didn't take Satoshi versus Kamitsure seriously, for whatever reason. The lack of real tension in this Gym battle was noticeable, which was a first for the region since Satoshi's first three Isshu Gym matches had more tension than the Raimon Gym, in spite of the stakes being the same.
     
    FullmetalJackie likes this.
  17. Damn what a miserable Gym battle. I mean it was cool that Ash used his new Palpitoad, but running out to get another Pokemon because he thought Palpitoad would win him the whole thing? He should have been disqualified right there and then. I didn't like how they just let him slide like that. Ash has never been this stupid before.
     
    Jerimiyah and FlygontheRavager like this.
  18. Vulpicks

    Vulpicks Well-Known Member

    Wow that was absurdly horrible. It was more of a comedy routine than an actual battle. Really felt like I was watching an OS Gym battle. Now, there is nothing wrong with comedy during a battle, Ash vs. Conway for example had plenty of funny moments while remaining an engaging and interesting battle, but this battle just made no sense whatsoever.

    Ash was a complete and utter moron. So much so that it was absolutely painful to watch. He should've straight up been disqualified when he ran back to the center to get a new mon, wasting everyone's time.

    Attract continues to be extremely overused, and Snivy (best Unova mon) gets completely thrown away cause Ash is too freaking stupid to remember her basic type-match ups and even her bleepin' gender. Wasn't it stated that Snivys are notorious for leaving incompetent trainers?

    Also this episode was just straight up horribly written. Emolga shouldn't have been OHKOed, they could've at least had Snivy land a hit. Ash's """strategy""" at the end made zero freaking sense. What good does obliterating the terrain do when Tynamo levitates anyways? Literally nothing is stopping it from attacking from any direction it pleases.

    Furthermore, the only way they could give this incompetent moron the win was by having Elesa's Pokemon literally disobey her. Not only does that make her look incredibly incompetent as a Gym Leader, but it's a complete asspull as well.

    This episode also just insinuates terrible things. Ash notices Pikachu has been carrying him through Unova, decides to gives his other Pokemon a chance, they job, and Pikachu ends up carrying again as always. ...Seriously? Also the idea that preparation is apparently a bad thing to be avoided, while charging forward with brute force is the way to go.

    What about all those times in DP when Ash showed rather stunning forethought such as teaching Heracross Sleep Talk to counter Darkrai? This writing is bad, plain and simple. I understand what they were going for but they blew it big time, and Ash didn't deserve the badge at all.

    Honestly one of the worst Pokemon episodes I've ever had the misfortune of seeing. I feel really bad for the people that waited so long for this ep and were met with that garbage lmao. The only cool thing was that badass Tynamo.
     
    Last edited: Jul 17, 2018
  19. Leonhart

    Leonhart Well-Known Member

    Shibishirasu surprised me since it was not only powerful, but also bigger than I had anticipated. I always thought it'd be rather small.
     

Share This Page