• Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Butifly vs Dustox

Status
Not open for further replies.

Arokosaki

Contingency Planner
What benefits does each one have? Also, how do you determine the "personality value"? I assume this is based on their personality (rash, hasty, lax, etc.) but can't find a place that states which ones correspond to what value (or if this is somehow happiness related?). Help?
 

Dan©

Ace Pitcher #57
Personality value is random, to my knowledge you can't figure it out.... until it evolves at level 7

Beautifly-Higher attack+Spec. Attack
Dustox-More Defensive

I personally think Beautifly is better, but the movepool is limited. And neither of them are very good...
I took a beautifly to the E4 from the beginning of the game... knocked out against the 1st E4 member, but managed to Silver Wind a few dark types lol
 

PkmnBreederLuke

Zephyr Trainer
Well what do you mean by benefits?

I can tell you that they both have the same base HP and speed. Dustox's defensive stats are the same as Beautifly's attacking stats.

For example; Beautifly's Sp. Att = Dustox's Sp. Def

In my opinion though, both are pretty boring pokemon and they are nothing more than the mandatory bug pokemon evolution that we get in every version. If you have to pick one, Beautifly has the more attacking stats so capture something that adds to its Sp. Attack, as for Dustox go for Sp. Defence raising natures.

Personally I'd prefer a Dustox, they learn psychic attacks and also learns toxic by level up. Both learn Silver Wind which is meh, 5PP isn't anything much and after that you have Mega Drain which is also pretty boring in my eyes. 10PP for a 40 Base Power? You could always teach it Giga Drain I suppose, but even then thats only 5PP.

If you must get one, try for Dustox, but I can't say about personalty values because all the ones I've captured have been Beautifly and that's before I discovered EV's and IV's etc.

Just what I think anyways.
 

kh2_lover

Loving Longnecks
I would pick Dustox cause of its defensive attacks such as toxic and such and i would preffer him also cause he's not part flying(meh, beautifly couldnt use Fly anyways). You could always get in trouble during Glacia. But if you want a Beautifly theres also a good side on that, You could wipe out some of Sidney's dual grass-dark types with Silver Wind.
 

Arokosaki

Contingency Planner
Well, I now have one of each, and will be using whichever is better suited to the situation at the time (ex: Dustox + Confusion = fun vs Brawly). Thanks for the input, everyone! :)
 

Kodan

Master Breeder
i think all bug pokemon are useless, they faint to easily, But if i had to choose, It would be beatifly, Its not as ugly as a dustox.
 

Aquarelle

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Personally, I think Beautifly is better. Not like Beautifly/Dustox are good to start with anyway. Well anywho, Beautifly is prettier than the repulsive looking Dustox, and it has great sp. attack too. Dustox does have better defense and can stay alive longer than Fly, but it can't dish out any sort of damage...

I've used both Dustox and Beautifly, and I've gotta say that Beautifly did a better job on my team than Dustox did. Beautifly could actually kill things and usually survived if it got hit by a weak move, save all rock attacks. Dustox, I found, had major difficulties killing things before it got beaten itself, despite it being the one with the higher defenses.

If you want to know the benefits each one has...

Dustox:
~Higher defenses
~Bug/Poison, so it doesn't have a 4x weakness to rock like its counterpart does!
~Uh... it's a poison type so its immune to toxic! hehehe...
~I have a shiny one on Ruby!

Beautifly:
~Better at sweeping
~Flying type makes it immune to earthquake
~It's prettier than Dustox. :D
~It's better than Dustox. :p
 

Kodan

Master Breeder
I raised both of them to see how good they are, Got them to level 60 each (Took a while, Kept fainting..) And it still sucked.
 

cecil

Armed with a Mind
Don't use them much. But Dustox is useful when you want to pass Toxic to Shuckle via breeding. Well, never bother to think about them, but I'd choose Dustox...
 

Golden_Latias

#SlayQueenSlay
They're both pretty worthless. . .

90 base Special Attack isn't that bad for Beautifly, but it's OHKO'ed by pretty much anything with a Base Power over 60 and is not called Earthquake.

Dustox sucks. The end. Anything faster than him can kill him before he has time to do anything.

Heracross and Ninjask are much better choices, but if you absolutely have to use one of these, use Beautifly.
 

Liam-Kun

My precious!
beautifly: grass moves, +SP. atk & atk
dustox: psychic move, +SP. def & def

I prefer beautifly
 

WaterDragon trainer

Freak Like Me
I'd say Dustox. He's cooler and I like his attacks more than Beautifly.
 

Jasmine Lover

I wuv Jasmine
Well my Faverite has to be beautifly.
in my rom of emerald my beautifly was the first pokemon i caught and now it is stronger then my blazican.
It is true that it faints quikly but it still puts out a preety good fight.
And because it is my favorite pokemon
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top