Again, nobody from the Pokemon Gym association or whoever is in charge of regulating Gyms in Unova told Skyla to stop doing what she was doing. It's clear that in the eyes of those in charge of monitoring Gyms, Skyla was just doing things her way and it was fine with them. And as I've said many times, Skyla's method of using logic to predict the winner of a battle was actually quite efficient. She used the exact same methods that most of us use when playing the games. I don't know why people are making a federal case out of this. Many of us have given the facts, yet some people are still willing to beat a dead horse (at this point, all that's left of the horse are a few bones).
If im honest Kira all you seem to be doing is spamming the same argument you say we are beating a dead horse well I say your dog wont hunt!
1) You complain that nobody mentions Volkner.... several people have! (I think you should actually read threads instead of just searching for names as I actually spelt it wrong at first which is why it didnt show up)
On the subject of Volkner which was WAAAAAY back in DP... Ash actually complained more than he did with Skyla not to mention Flint from the Elite 4 and Paul.....
Volkner might have just been giving Badges away without battling but at least it wasn't for SELFISH reasons! He admited that he grew tired of battling and always winning so he put all his efforts into making Sunnyshore quite an advanced City..... Volkner built that City!!!!
What has Skyla done other than fly her plane for hours on end?
2) You play the sexism card A LOT!!
You complain people are bashing Skyla for being in your words a strong female character...
People are just as overly critical of male characters just look back at DP which you love bringing up when people complained about Pauls extreme catch and release program and the intense battle training he did
Its nothing to do with Skyla's Gender its to do with the fact she isnt doing the job she was assigned to do.... even her Grandfather the former Mistralton Gym Leader even said she was wrong!
I wonder if you would be so forgiving and on the defensive it was Cynthia the Champion of Sinnoh who was Air Battling..... even she who you claim to be holier than thou and stuck up gives younger weaker trainers a chance to prove themselves even Alder who I hate give younger weaker trainers the chance to battle him!
3) Skyla isnt using game logic (or any logic for that matter) shes just guessing...
By game logic Ash/Cylan should have been awarded a Badge without a battle! Skyla picks a type and if its weak to her says it looses even if its dual type is super effective against hers....
If Skyla is using game logic she has a problem iDENTifying dual types
In an Air Battle Cylan had a Grass, Bug/Rock and Electric/Ground.... Skyla saw Grass, Bug, Ground I saw Grass, Rock and Electric what did you see?
In an Air Battle Ash has Ground/Dark, Flying/Normal, Electric... Skyla saw Ground, Flying, Electric , I saw Dark, Flying and Electric what did you see?
She even contridicted herself by claiming Pikachu couldnt win because her Swanna a dual Water/Flying which is extremely weak to Electric knew a move to counter Electric attacks
who is to say her challengers Pokemon couldnt do the same?
Pokemon can learn moves from MANY MANY MANY varied types which could easily take down a Pokemon they were weak to! and the Anime itself has proven type matchups mean nothing!
but still she denys them the chance to prove themselves...
Take my Pokemon White Team in my Sig
If I used my Stunfisk, Heatmor and Emboar she would say I would loose...
My Stunfisk knows Toxic, Scald,
Discharge and Earth Power
My Heatmore knows Hone Claws, Fire Blast, Focus Blast and
Sucker Punch
My Emboar know Flame Charge, Flare Blitz,
Wild Charge and Superpower
She wouldnt know they knew these moves which actually give me a pretty good fighting chance with most of the other moves being neutral against her