Do You Feel - The Rocket Summer - Theneedleman
You're not letting people choose songs because they haven't been here very long? Yeah you're pathetic.
All The Small Things-Blink 182-Cryptozoologist
That was my first thought, but I tried it out and the list just looks cluttered that way. no, it works fine this way.Kimi ni negai wo - Miyavi - Sunkern
Just an idea, but you could switch the form around so that it goes artist-song title, that way people will be able to check if their song is taken a little easier?
Conquer All - Behemoth - SlipKnoT