MunchMunch
Well-Known Member
His Johto Team and BW teams at least did more then just be battle drones. Though I've always considered Ash's Unova Team to just be the starters and Scraggy.
and the writters/staff/people who decide about these things says and states that he is the best battler in the world, then people should just stop copeAsh won because the staff wanted him to win. It’s not that complicated. It’s been like this since storytelling was a thing.
All of his teams were handled better than his Journey team. You're only saying it was handled better because the writers decided they should be the ones to defeat Champions. Not because of organic growth, not because they have multiple training episodes like SM/DP and not because Ash has visibly shown himself injecting different training styles into his team that he's learned form his travels. What was handled better besides him only losing to two people this series which is already controversial?Also in all honesty some things of the previous teams like the Johto team and BW were handled a lot worst during their respective series.
Look could the Journeys team have been handled better? Yes, but at the end of the day they still did get development to some degree.All of his teams were handled better than his Journey team. You're only saying it was handled better because the writers decided they should be the ones to defeat Champions. Not because of organic growth, not because they have multiple training episodes like SM/DP and not because Ash has visibly shown himself injecting different training styles into his team that he's learned form his travels. What was handled better besides him only losing to two people this series which is already controversial?
Look could the Journeys team have been handled better? Yes, but at the end of the day they still did get development to some degree.
They each had moments where they got spotlight and got moments. They were most certainly not battle drones as almost all of them if not all had a personality. They also got each had gotten moments in the final battles of the current series which is more then most of the other regional teams get as most of the other regional teams have at least 1 or more members that get completely shafted.
Remember when the writers dedicated an entire episode to Goh's random ass Flabebe that no one cares about?The Pokemon they used isn't the problem, it's how rushed and barely any development the team received as they wanted to revolve episodes around Goh's captures that ended up not even getting used
No one's really singling out the JN team for being flawed when both the Johto & BW teams and their respective flaws have been pointed out
Even if the Jotho or BW team are also bad, they at least had the excuse of a team overload and the writers not being able to juggle them all.
Literally all the JN team bar pikachu (and i guess lucario with that one lucario and cinderace ep) only had ‘focus’ episodes directly relating to getting stronger for battle. Like all their ‘focus’ episode follow the same plot of ash taking them to someone with the express purpose of making them stronger and nothing more than that.
Sirfetch: Wikstrom and Clemont
Lucario: korrina and Greninja
Gengar: Allister
Dracovish: Clemont
Dragonite: The closest thing to a focus episode for her was the iris fight
This is in contrast to previous pokemons who get development in regards to non battle stuff, then growing stronger as a result of doing various stuff.
Even if the Jotho or BW team are also bad, they at least had the excuse of a team overload and the writers not being able to juggle them all. The JN team has no excuse. The writers choose to make them battle bots who have no real relevance or role when it doesn’t involve ash battling. Which is why most of them dissapeared for long stretches in the middle until the back end of the series where they rushed all of the battles.
That's different from saying the JN team is the only one with flaws. Bringing up past series when the current one is being discussed is just redirecting criticisms. If I say one team wasn't handled well that doesn't mean I think others were perfect or even better.well making excuses for them to try and make them seem better than the JN team doesn't help like the following sentance.
regardless I wonder if we'll ever see a team done "right" by our eyes.
That's different from saying the JN team is the only one with flaws. Bringing up past series when the current one is being discussed is just redirecting criticisms. If I say one team wasn't handled well that doesn't mean I think others were perfect or even better.
And? You could cherry-pick any of Ash's Pokémon and say that their focus episodes are all about them getting stronger. There were episodes where Ash's JN Pokémon are not doing battling, like Dragonite in an eating contest or Lucario and Cinderace going through antics trying to save Pikachu or Dracovish trying to compete in a water competition despite being completely unsuited for it.
Focus episodes of them getting stronger are better remembered because it was building up to their strength as a team against the toughest of toughest. We remember Chimchar-Monfereno-Infernape focused episodes to be about getting stronger and mastering Blaze to prove Paul wrong, but does anyone recall any focus episode that wasn't about that? What about Greninja? The focus episodes it had were all about getting stronger and mastering Ash-Greninja, but I don't recall any non-battle focus episodes. Charizard? Disobedience challenges and then being left to train in Charrific Valley just to get stronger, that's what we remember. But what are Charizard episodes in the original series that weren't about battling?
regardless I wonder if we'll ever see a team done "right" by our eyes.
100% agreed. It was especially jarring after Sun & Moon, where every Pokemon almost appeared in every episode.The reason why JN mons are seen as "battle bots" and other series mons arent despite all of the focus episodes being focused on getting stronger is that the latter still got "organic screentime"
A major flaw of the starting year of JN's team handling is how if a mon wasnt in focus he wont appear. Organic screentime thrown out in the window, its mostly either they appear in their focus episodes or we got lucky and they made a brief appearance in a filler episode
It was hard to get attached with them too much because we barely got time with them
We had Ash's full team ready by ep60, yet still we didnt get to spend time with them
What sucks is that its the THIRD year of JN that finally makes you appreciate and love the JN team because you see them more, you see their personalities more, it is endearing. Where was this before after ep60?
The Journeys team EACH have great indiviualistic personalities and arcs, but they NEVER coincided with each other to the point they cohesively felt like a team, and their personalities despite being much better than some previous mons never became as endearing simply because we never saw them much
99 percent of Ash's JN team's problems would be solved if they got more organic screentime earlier in the series to endear their personalities to us and allow us to view them as a proper team before Year 3
Excellent take. I'm glad I can still find good stuff in this sea of weird fanfiction and shipping nonsense.The reason why JN mons are seen as "battle bots" and other series mons arent despite all of the focus episodes being focused on getting stronger is that the latter still got "organic screentime"
A major flaw of the starting year of JN's team handling is how if a mon wasnt in focus he wont appear. Organic screentime thrown out in the window, its mostly either they appear in their focus episodes or we got lucky and they made a brief appearance in a filler episode
It was hard to get attached with them too much because we barely got time with them
We had Ash's full team ready by ep60, yet still we didnt get to spend time with them
What sucks is that its the THIRD year of JN that finally makes you appreciate and love the JN team because you see them more, you see their personalities more, it is endearing. Where was this before after ep60?
The Journeys team EACH have great indiviualistic personalities and arcs, but they NEVER coincided with each other to the point they cohesively felt like a team, and their personalities despite being much better than some previous mons never became as endearing simply because we never saw them much
99 percent of Ash's JN team's problems would be solved if they got more organic screentime earlier in the series to endear their personalities to us and allow us to view them as a proper team before Year 3
Well said. Lucario and Sirfetch'd were basically BattleDrone 1 and BattleDrone 2 for the majority of the series. Dragonite was the only one that actually interacted with other Pokemon prior to the final year of Journeys, and by then, I already quit watching the show consistently.The reason why JN mons are seen as "battle bots" and other series mons arent despite all of the focus episodes being focused on getting stronger is that the latter still got "organic screentime"
A major flaw of the starting year of JN's team handling is how if a mon wasnt in focus he wont appear. Organic screentime thrown out in the window, its mostly either they appear in their focus episodes or we got lucky and they made a brief appearance in a filler episode
It was hard to get attached with them too much because we barely got time with them
We had Ash's full team ready by ep60, yet still we didnt get to spend time with them
What sucks is that its the THIRD year of JN that finally makes you appreciate and love the JN team because you see them more, you see their personalities more, it is endearing. Where was this before after ep60?
The Journeys team EACH have great indiviualistic personalities and arcs, but they NEVER coincided with each other to the point they cohesively felt like a team, and their personalities despite being much better than some previous mons never became as endearing simply because we never saw them much
99 percent of Ash's JN team's problems would be solved if they got more organic screentime earlier in the series to endear their personalities to us and allow us to view them as a proper team before Year 3
Thank you. You put into words what I've been trying to figure with my feelings for the PM2019 team. Much appreciated! <3The reason why JN mons are seen as "battle bots" and other series mons arent despite all of the focus episodes being focused on getting stronger is that the latter still got "organic screentime"
A major flaw of the starting year of JN's team handling is how if a mon wasnt in focus he wont appear. Organic screentime thrown out in the window, its mostly either they appear in their focus episodes or we got lucky and they made a brief appearance in a filler episode
It was hard to get attached with them too much because we barely got time with them
We had Ash's full team ready by ep60, yet still we didnt get to spend time with them
What sucks is that its the THIRD year of JN that finally makes you appreciate and love the JN team because you see them more, you see their personalities more, it is endearing. Where was this before after ep60?
The Journeys team EACH have great indiviualistic personalities and arcs, but they NEVER coincided with each other to the point they cohesively felt like a team, and their personalities despite being much better than some previous mons never became as endearing simply because we never saw them much
99 percent of Ash's JN team's problems would be solved if they got more organic screentime earlier in the series to endear their personalities to us and allow us to view them as a proper team before Year 3
And there is absolutely nothing about 135