Cutlerine
Gone. Not coming back.
How does the dream world thing work?
Don't worry. It'll become clearer with time... possibly.
Thank you for reading!
F.A.B.
How does the dream world thing work?
Oh nono, if anything you should consider your winning so many fic awards a sign of that. I’m just your friendly neighbourhood reviewer. :>...
Psychic...?
...
Wow. Seems I'm moving up in the world.
With every new Pokemon game comes the bandwagon of fics based off it. So I saw a fair number of newbie fics that had this scene during passing glances.Has that scene been used a lot? I really haven't read many B/W fics, I'm afraid. It seemed like a fairly important point to me, so I included it.
As for the Green Party, well. That just seemed like a fun idea, like most of the things I put in my stories.
Even your posts are all flowery! Do you treat all your reviewers this way? *fans self*Well, as I see it, the vaguely-described regions represented in the games are to a fanfiction author like pure white Carrara marble to a Renaissance sculptor. They're a perfect canvas: everyone knows the boring stuff about them, which leaves you free to go off on wild tangents and build the interesting bits of the world.
An excellent point that rarely gets brought up, and one I certainly haven’t given much thought to. Especially since you rarely see Fakemon being mentioned but not shown – I’m glad they’re not a big focal point here.As I see it, there have to be Fakemon and animals in the world for two reasons. One is that the six hundred-odd official species of Pokémon (some very odd) are barely enough to create a believable ecosystem in a single country as it is, and the other is that humans are definitely not Pokémon, which begs the question of where they came from if there are no animals.
Thinking about the lore, I'm pretty sure that there's at least a little truth in it, given that Odin turned up running a hotel in Pastoria City in my last story.
More flowery language~ But all right, I see what you mean, and I can’t fault you for it. I did bet they were products of their worlds, after all, and I appreciated that aspect of it.It wasn't intentional. You see, I always start from canon, and in this case my starting point was that the male character is Black and the female one is White. So Jared had to be male, and Lauren had to be female; there was no choice there. Their characters developed purely as a result of the world they live in; I forge stories like chainmail, with one link following on from the next, rather than based on any pre-existing stereotypes.
I did think it might conflict with Cheren and Bianca's dynamic, but I thought I might enjoy flicking between different perspectives on their situation, so I didn't bother to change it.
Halley... is different. She has no counterpart within the games and is therefore a pure and unalloyed product of my diseased wit - but more of her anon.
Ah, sorry about that. I just Ctrl+F’d it, and it was in Chapter Four, here:Yes, I know - but where's the wrong one? You've not quoted it.
All valid points, and noted.
Not where I live. Here, 'OK' is 'OK'. The 'throw' thing is right, though.
“Annie.... that's Anastasia, right?”
Hm, an interesting idea, though that isn’t quite the idea I was getting. I think part of it is that there is a difference between being serious vs professional.No, it doesn't, but that's kind of the point: Harmonia trades on not being a proper politician - on not acting as others of his station do, on possessing the ability to not take himself or his campaign seriously (or to appear that way, at least). Evidently I didn't make that point clearly enough; I'll take another look at this, and probably expand on it in further chapters.
And it is a strange place to make an announcement. Very strange indeed. I wonder what Game Freak were thinking, placing the speech scene thereso Cutlerine can avoid the blame for a misplaced event.
I wouldn’t necessarily bump it up if there is indeed such a low number of trainers, but presenting the data as a percentage could better help showcase it. Like “twenty percent of trainers are attacked by their own Pokemon” or what have you. The number has a lot more meaning that way, even without the reader knowing how many trainers there are and how many attacks there are precisely, while still having an idea of the ratio.I thought it was a small number, but I'd kind of already limited the figure, since I said Unova's Training industry was lacklustre earlier on. Eh, I could probably bump it up a bit higher and not seem like I'm contradicting myself, I guess.
I’m happy to have helped, and I intend to continue doing so! It’s not often I’m this captivated by a story, and it’s been a pleasure hearing back from you as well.Thank you. It means a lot to have a proper review, with both positive and negative parts to it, and when it comes from one of the more prominent members of the community, that really does sweeten the deal.
F.A.B.
Not sure if it should be “a mere ballast” on this one – if you did it for the style it works.It was, after all, mere ballast, there only to keep it anchored to the mortal realm – and it was difficult to drag it through the dark paths, where spirit flowed freely and flesh dragged like stone.
Repetition of “reality” – I’d say either replace/remove the first one, or perhaps for the latter one say “into that reality” or “into said reality.”ran on down the path, searching for the crack in reality that would show it the way back into reality.
The two adverbs seem a little odd together here. Maybe change “desperately” to “with desperation in his voice.”“In my defence, that boy is a lot younger and stronger than I am,” replied Smythe faintly desperately.
Should be “might have been” since the story is written in past tense.He might be a minor civil servant at the moment, but that was only the latest chapter in what had been something of a chequered past.
Wouldn’t capitalize “trails” – even if “Route 2” is capitalized, it’s because it’s a proper noun, being the name of the road, while “trail” isn’t the proper name of anything.defeated, I shook my head and sat down with the others on a log bench placed thoughtfully at the roadside by the Trail's constructors.
Oh nono, if anything you should consider your winning so many fic awards a sign of that. I’m just your friendly neighbourhood reviewer. :>
With every new Pokemon game comes the bandwagon of fics based off it. So I saw a fair number of newbie fics that had this scene during passing glances.
Good reason. I’m certainly curious to see where you take it and how they’ll differ from in-game Plasma. Though I did just realize that Teiresias referred to them as their evil team name, so I suppose that hasn’t disappeared altogether.
Even your posts are all flowery! Do you treat all your reviewers this way? *fans self*
An excellent point that rarely gets brought up, and one I certainly haven’t given much thought to. Especially since you rarely see Fakemon being mentioned but not shown – I’m glad they’re not a big focal point here.
That is a very amusing thought. I wonder if we’ll see any more of that.
More flowery language~ But all right, I see what you mean, and I can’t fault you for it. I did bet they were products of their worlds, after all, and I appreciated that aspect of it.
I’m certainly interested in seeing how Lauren gets along with Cheren and Bianca, though I imagine a chunk of it will be Cheren being slightly annoyed with her as he is with Bianca. I’m quite curious on that one. That certainly is true about Halley – a diseased wit is rather fun, after all. I was referring more specifically to how she fits (or rather doesn’t fit) into the general gender dynamic going on, but either way.
Ah, sorry about that. I just Ctrl+F’d it, and it was in Chapter Four, here:
Huh, interesting, I haven’t heard of not spelling out “okay,” but I’ll take your word on that one.
Hm, an interesting idea, though that isn’t quite the idea I was getting. I think part of it is that there is a difference between being serious vs professional.
Tomake it look like it was done on purposeamend that, I would frame it as partly being a press conference in itself in a way. Perhaps a statement was issued stating that he was be making an important announcement in X city on X date, and that “hey media people, you should probably be there to cover it, we’ll even reserve you some seats.”
I wouldn’t necessarily bump it up if there is indeed such a low number of trainers, but presenting the data as a percentage could better help showcase it. Like “twenty percent of trainers are attacked by their own Pokemon” or what have you. The number has a lot more meaning that way, even without the reader knowing how many trainers there are and how many attacks there are precisely, while still having an idea of the ratio.
I’m happy to have helped, and I intend to continue doing so! It’s not often I’m this captivated by a story, and it’s been a pleasure hearing back from you as well.
On to Chapter Six!
Again, I like the atmosphere of the city you set up here at the beginning. It’s not often you hear of the bars or specific boroughs of established cities in the Pokeworld, and it sets a nice tone. Your take on the first meeting with N was also interesting – instead of merely speaking to the Pokemon, he actually assesses its physical condition. Interesting.
I love the Pokedex (“Pokemon Index,” never thought of that!) project, especially with it now being a phone app! Really love that touch. Again, it incorporates the idea/potential for of Fakemon nice and smoothly without placing too much emphasis on it. Though I wasn’t sure why you put it to 1992 – at first I assumed that that was when the first games were released, but that was 1996. The only result I got from “Pokemon 1992” on Google was this urban dictionary reference, which is also wrong. Is there a reference here I’m not getting?
Seeing Teiresias’s travel and musings has sparked more questions, but it was certainly fascinating. I also really liked the last scene. Gave some interesting insight into the dynamic between these characters, and it was a juicy interaction.
Now nitpicking again~
Not sure if it should be “a mere ballast” on this one – if you did it for the style it works.
Repetition of “reality” – I’d say either replace/remove the first one, or perhaps for the latter one say “into that reality” or “into said reality.”
The two adverbs seem a little odd together here. Maybe change “desperately” to “with desperation in his voice.”
Should be “might have been” since the story is written in past tense.
Wouldn’t capitalize “trails” – even if “Route 2” is capitalized, it’s because it’s a proper noun, being the name of the road, while “trail” isn’t the proper name of anything.
Sorry I didn't have quite as much to say this time around, but I really enjoyed this chapter. I've been very eager to see what happens next, so I was excited to see an update so quickly. Your writing is on the higher end of what I've seen on this forum, and it's been wonderful getting to just sit back, relax and enjoy without feeling like it needs a ton of improvement. And the story is one I've been thinking about and trying to piece together in my spare time, so you know you have my attention. ;]
~Psychic
Saw this 10+ days ago, didn't have any time to respond before, let alone read.
I wonder if what N said about Candy was true or not, simply because the things he described have yet to be of relevance and seem to be there for the sake of being there. I dunno, maybe I missed a scene with a shivering, wheezing Archen.
Well so much for the test of friendship via battle, at least the dialogue was similar.
I wonder as to what the demon is going to possess next, as another Liepard would be what the Main characters party would be expecting to see if he shows up again.
Ah, midnight, I was kind of expecting something similiar to the Dark Hour in Persona 3 where time stands still for most and ungodly things roam the area. I wonder if other people notice the stutter-in-time.
Keep up the good work and look forward to another chapter.
The only sorrow was that you didn't turn it into terisas didn't keep trying to do that, lacking in humor but not in plot.
I enjoyed this segment myself, but like Rotom said, lacking in humor, however, I feel this did not detract from the story at all, so no worries there.
I don't have many things to say besides some of the descriptions you used were well done. Like a sigh of the oppressed or looking at someone with so much didain that they could be confused as being blind.
Keep up the good work.
EPIC AWESOME SAUCE!
It looks like White would be a good trainer... She has a pokemon.
Wow, that would have been gruesome if that Purrloin wasn't meant to be caught, pretty awesome though.
Also, endangering your pets via proxy and saving them = best loyalty gain ever. Keep it up Cheren and soon all the pokemon in the group will respect and listen to you without a second thought.
I wonder if that Caitlin is the same one in the Elite 4...
Anyway, that was a pretty sweet chapter though not much happened in anyones POV besides getting a new pokemon. Looking forward to the next one and am quite surprised at the speed this one showed up.
Now you wouldn't be using Dungeons and Dragons for names, source material, and terms would you? I read mind-flayer at the end there and immediately thought of that.
Anyway, a pretty neat chapter, and an interesting take on the dreamyard. I look forward to another chapter.
I like how you got the feel of Black City. It really comes alive in your story.
I liked your comment on no Cordelias being "normal". It makes me laugh because it reminds me of my toy dinosaur Cordelia, who is supposed to have a few screws loose.