AmericanPi
Write on
Hey contest judges! Since it's November 30, what's the status on the judging? Will the results be posted here later today?
Personally I think the judging system is fine as it is. No need to over-complicate things. But that's just my personal viewpoint.
I totally understand why the results aren't being posted yet - there was that deadline extension. Quick question, can we realistically expect results to be posted by December 7? I'm actually itching to see the results - what other people wrote, what kinds of comments the judges had, and how everyone placed.
Keep up the good work, judges!
*goes back to waiting impatiently for the results*
Yeah, I'm definitely on track to finish before that - that was a deliberately pessimistic estimate. I've almost finished my seventh review now (out of nine); I expect I'll be able to finish that and put together the remaining two in the next few days unless I run into trouble pinning down something I want to talk about regarding those entries or something comes up, but even if that happens, I should be completely free next weekend, so I'll have plenty of time to hammer out whatever remains then (and hopefully give all the entries one last read-over).American--Pi said:Quick question, can we realistically expect results to be posted by December 7?
*checks the date* It's December 7 now here in California. Just wondering, what's the current status on the reviews and when can we realistically expect the results to be posted?
Using the phrase ”things like that” makes it seem that you as the narrator are uncertain of what they were doing, . Mind you, this is a nitpick more than anything, but given it’s at the story’s beginning it was perhaps more noticeable. Also, early on was this unfinished sentence:He was surrounded by a few aides, recording transcripts, handling calls, and things like that.
There was a bit too much telling as opposed to showing for my liking, and sometimes repetition of facts as well. The idea of grunts getting to catch their own Pokemon as I said before was neat, but I felt that particular point was repeated too often – Zinzolin explained how it would work, such as how they would keep track of who caught what, and then soon after the grunts were told that they had to have their Pokemon caught reported to higher ups, which... was fairly similar information.Zinzolin was listening as the members of the Shadow Triad talked to him, but his face
Here there was a lack of urgency created. They’re escaping this factory, but we don’t get as much fear or uncertainty from them as I would have liked, just that these two people walked in front, Kirlia carrying it in the back, then they walked, then Kirlia carried the rare candies back. Showing more on what they do while they travel back, some mention of detail such as maybe constantly looking about, or having quicker, shallower breaths, would give us a better sense that they are doing something risky and.Schwarz and Weiss walked out in front of of everyone else, and then Barrett was behind them. Barrett’s Kirlia was in the back, carrying the crate of rare candies. They all walked back the way they came, and no guards were encountered. At the entrance to the sewers, Schwarz and Weiss waited behind as Barrett and his Kirlia went through with the Rare Candies.
and instead of any.“Now, it’s time to go any try again for world domination.”
’OK’ or ‘Okay’, rather than Ok. This happened a few other times as well.“Ok, sounds like a plan,” Baret said.
The full stop after ‘before’ should become a comma, and I would word it as ‘with a tone of finality’.“That move has been useful before.” Barrett said, with tone of finality.
“Yes,” said ---.”Just make sure to record which pokemon you catch with me.”
These two lines are from what should be very different characters, yet without the speech tag to identify them I've found no way to tell the speakers apart. A mark of well-written dialogue is that you can identify which character any given line goes with simply by looking at what is said and how they say it. Without those distinguishing markers, you're forced to rely on constant speech tags to keep clarity, which clutters your prose and makes extended dialogues read very repetitive because you need to keep finding ways to say 'character x said another thing'. In general, you should not need to make reference to any given speaker 's name in a conversation more than once unless you need to mark a change in their expression or tone and ideally you should be able to understand who is speaking after a while even when there are no dialogue tags to fall back on. For future proofreading, I'd recommend that you make a version of your text with all the character names blanked out and try to see if you can still keep track of conversations. If you can't, that's a good indication that you need to vary up your character voices more.“Yes,” said ---. “Also, this rare candy manufacturing facility is owned by Silph Co., which my intelligence claims is secretly owned by Team Rocket. This way, we get lots of extra resources, and our rivals get severely hindered.”
“No! Ghetsis had such fire burning inside of him. And you are telling me it just went out, like that,” said Zinzolin.
But to be honest, the major issues here are what I'd recommend focusing on. Establish characters, establish what those characters want, establish what's preventing them from getting what they want, and then show us what both sides do about it and how that affects them and give us detail on that. What makes stories and characters interesting isn't where they start or even where they end up but rather all the ups and downs in the middle, and it's just bad storytelling form to skip over all the juicy parts.“Yes, sir!” said the secretary, before running off to fulfill the command he was given.
But his face what?Across from him at the table were the Shadow Triad. Zinzolin was listening as the members of the Shadow Triad talked to him, but his face
It took a few moments to get because they traveled under speed limit to avoid gathering suspicion,
It was filled with people, more than there had been at the restaurant ever since it opened after remodeling to handle the old Casteliacone stand being too crowded.
Now, go on, I need time to think alone.
Those personally loyal to me have ten days off to go get whatever pokemon they wish to train, more powerful the pokemon and the more you catch, the better.
Those who are personally loyal to us, that is to say, Lord Ghetsis and I, will remain stronger than those whose loyalty is for personal gain or to any underling of ours,
Pokémon species' names are their own plurals, like moose and squid. So "zubats and trubbishes" would become "zubat and trubbish".Quite quickly, the Team Plasma grunts had left to go catch their own pokemon, pokemon that they wanted to catch instead of all the Zubats and Trubbishes that they had been forced to catch previously.
It looks as though there's a missing line break between those two paragraphs, seeing as that was another scene change.“Ok, sounds like a plan,” Baret said. “I’ll go tell everyone else what is happening and we should be at the Castelia Sewers by sunset.”
At sunset, a group of Team Plasma members converged at Thumb Pier.
"Reassured" is a transitive verb; it needs an object, such as "them".“We’ll take care of them,” Schwarz reassured.
world rather than World, and unless this is different from the real world in the story it seems odd for this Pokemon character to refer to her world as that.It was his stupid idea to take over the Pokemon World.
This – and other instances of such time skips – are something I would advise again. They can work at times, but it’s a fairly overused trick and the problem with it is that it interrupts the flow or pacing of the story. That break can be used to your advantage, but it’s tricky and I don’t think the joke (the interviewer actually going off to get the stuff) is funnier because of the way you indicated a time skip. Say if the main character had a pause and then remarked about roughly how long it took (or maybe she timed him?), or having her ramble to herself while his gone, would be a more natural way to pass the time.-One minute later-
Unfortunately, at that time Team Losers didn't take my suggestion of using their original motto with special effects.
These two bits got me a bit confused. Part of that is because from what I recall of the anime I saw, Team Rocket always had special effects when performing the motto... unless M here was talking about before the anime starts?)Anyways, before Team Losers traveled through the Kanto Battle Frontier, I had to write a new motto for them. And they insisted on special effects too
With the explanation that followed, this turns into “that’s a your problem, not an my problem”, which doesn’t quite work out."That's a Y.P., not an M.P.," I said.
These sentences felt somewhat incomplete and affected the pacing. I noticed this more in the beginning on the story so maybe I got used to it or it simply happened less often, but it did disrupt how I read the story initially. This line in particular confused me a bit too – what was a performance, exactly?While he was normally content to have the laws of nature to confide in, he certainly didn't
Even if it was largely a performance.
I feel this should be Zager’s Apartment, especially when you later refer to, say, Zager’s Office.Zager Apartment
Kanto
There should be a third dot after ‘he just knew it’. Also, nitpicky but the possibilities didn’t seem all that endless to me – maybe a promotion, maybe just a raise, maybe just a nod of approval, maybe nothing. =pThis proposal was going to go well and Zager was going to be so proud of him, he just knew it.. maybe he'd get a promotion... the possibilities were endless.
This sentence was a run-on and may be better reworded as separate sentences.Matori, his ever-sarcastic secretary and loyal assistant, was most certainly in, she had brought him coffee this morning, like always, so theory number two was right out.
Change that comma to a full stop.“Are you sure you have everything today?” Mondo asked,
Three dots rather than three again, and there should be a space between it and ‘I have’ as well.“Doctor..I have even better news.”
Ironic? Nah. Strange, sure, but not ironic.Snooze, this time with greater force- ironic coming out of a man who was otherwise dead to the world.
I think the bolded part would benefit from being set off with em dashes/double hyphens rather than commas. It makes it easier to tell what the "precisely to avoid wasting her energy being troubled by such questions" is actually modifying.Matori, a woman who believed in clearly labeling every last thing, precisely to avoid wasting her energy being troubled with such questions, pointed out exactly where he could put the mail.
’and little noise’ sounded a bit odd to me in the sentence and took a bit away from what was otherwise a really good sentence to have near the beginning.Then came the sound of a finger flick and the chair bent back a bit, with just the precision and little noise enough to indicate a move practised, perfected, enjoyed.
I feel this would read better if split into a second sentence around ‘...asked to, even...’. And:The subjects did everything that was requested of them at any time of the day they were asked to, even if they had just been conquered and were untrained, they would obey.
Here I would split each sentence into two again, or at least reword them.The human looked around, there were barely any people this time of the night. The feline listened around too, all of the birds were sleeping or occupying themselves watching over the humans in the busy streets with unsatisfiable curiosity.
But those are minor matters a decent spell/grammar checker should pick up upon.They are simply weaker than my human, thus they are bound to serve me, the Persian thought, letting his fangs show, they just have to accept it.
Not so sure about that use of "erudite". Either it's an adjective in noun's clothing or else there was supposed to be a noun after it that just didn't get typed.The humans left around a scent not unlike that of stressed and cornered prey and the Persian noticed in the dim light that their hands seemed sweaty and would twist and momentarily turn into fists for each possible route of escape that their erudite preemptively refuted.