Siddhar
Transcend
I loved both, the story a bit more, like most of the people here. But coming to the gameplay, I loved it as well! It was a fun pastime for me, so I didn't find it that bad, as long as I was totally occupied with it. Another reason for me to play was the beautiful music, which I liked more than the core games. But it seems that a lot of us love turning into Pokemon, that's the reason PMD is such a hit.