• Hey all, due to some issues ith some false DMCAs, we've had to censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience
  • Hey all. Due to some disgustingly high bot activity, we've had to lock the forum access behind registration for the time being, to try and discourage them.

    I know this is very annoying but we're running out of options to deal with tis
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

does the pokemon fandom attract too many idiots?

Status
Not open for further replies.

PDL

disenchanted
I'm being serious here.

Why is it that, for every intelligent poster, there's 20 or so morons who fill any pokemon forum on the net with it's own brand of garbage?

and is there any way that the fandom can present itself as a smarter fandom? (although that is an oxymoron in a sense, since all fandoms are filled with idiots)

Discuss.
 
Out of all the fandoms I’ve seen on the internet, the Myst fandom is really the only one that doesn’t seem to be filled with childish idiots. On the other hand, because Myst fans tend to be more intelligent and grownup, they overanalyze and argue over every single little detail... *shivers at the thought of the debates that went on just a few months ago*

The ones that seem to be the most idiot filled though, IMO, are the Counter Strike (and generally any FPS fandom) and Pokémon fandoms...
 
I'm afraid so. Pokémon, though it has a very competitive and indepth aspect to it, is a little too simple. All you really have to do is pick up a GBA, a cartridge, and follow the game's lead. In 10-140 hours, you've beaten the E4 just by using elementary logic. It doesn't take a mastermind to beat the game. And thus, idiots will come.

An intelligent franchise would be one that older fans play, one where strategy is absolutely necessary to succeed. Idiots don't comprehend strategy very well =/

~*CB*~
The 8th Champion​
 
Unfortunately that is pretty true... T_T
In fact, me and some other people (you, ~*CB*~) are like the only ones that actually correct there errors. >_<
In fact I always go back and correct something if I mess it up when I type fast.
*sigh*I wish more people would do that, it would make half the posts much more easy to understand.

~nightcat ;197;
 
Pokemon is a franchise aimed at kids, so of course you're going to get a lot of people saying stuff that doesn't really make sense.
 
Definitely not as much when it came out in America.

Back then, even the tough kids with mohawks played Pokemon. Then they just go about with the cards. Ugh, annoying!

However, it has relatively mellowed down, but there will always be the less intelligent people following the fad.

That's what I like about Pokemon being less popular than the beginning.
 
its funny that you mention that. You'd be surprised how many people actually read now a days. Its like 2/10 people read!! Its ridicilous! pick up a book.
 
with anything that collects any form of fandom, massive amounts, almost disproportionate amounts of idiots are also attracted. unfortunately its just the law of the fandom world.
 
mm... it appears that we all seem to have a different ideas as to what consistutes as an "idiot" here.

just pointing this out... it's somewhat interesting once I look at it...
 
Being an Idiot myself, I take offense to that!

Personally, I find it has a lot to do with age. More people are getting into this past time when they should be out building up their life skills more.
 
V Faction said:
Personally, I find it has a lot to do with age. More people are getting into this past time when they should be out building up their life skills more.

Me: my life and social skills suck. Everything attracts idiots, but it's "who is an idiot and who is not" that decides whether it's too many or not.
 
Pokemon was not actually meant to be as competitve as it is now. It only had the formulas and stuff to make Pokemon more exciting and versatile. For example, we weren't meant to find out what EVs and IVs were. People (mainly the people who mess with games to get Gameshark and Action Replay codes for cheating) randomly found it out. Today we are basically split into 2 tiers. The competitive ones who seem to play Netbattle all the time (I may fit into this category) and the ones who play the gameboy games, and since they are so easy, they dont really understand the full complexity of the game. This causes disputes between the people of both tiers as is vividly clear in the RMT sections.
 
SHUCKLE MAN said:
Pokemon was not actually meant to be as competitve as it is now. It only had the formulas and stuff to make Pokemon more exciting and versatile. For example, we weren't meant to find out what EVs and IVs were. People (mainly the people who mess with games to get Gameshark and Action Replay codes for cheating) randomly found it out. Today we are basically split into 2 tiers. The competitive ones who seem to play Netbattle all the time (I may fit into this category) and the ones who play the gameboy games, and since they are so easy, they dont really understand the full complexity of the game. This causes disputes between the people of both tiers as is vividly clear in the RMT sections.
Not being bothered about copetetive battling dosn't make you an idiot, it just makes you someone who prefers to concentrate on having fun and using there favourites rather than devicing long-winded strategies.
On topic; yes, the frannchise does absorb alot of idiots, but alot of those idiots are shallow bandwagon jumpers who only care about Pokemon because it's popular and fashionable. Now that it's gone out of fashion, there are alot less idiots.
 
Komedic Konservationist said:
Not being bothered about copetetive battling dosn't make you an idiot, it just makes you someone who prefers to concentrate on having fun and using there favourites rather than devicing long-winded strategies.
On topic; yes, the frannchise does absorb alot of idiots, but alot of those idiots are shallow bandwagon jumpers who only care about Pokemon because it's popular and fashionable. Now that it's gone out of fashion, there are alot less idiots.

Exactly. You put it a lot better than I did. :)

Pokemon was not meant to be so competitve, but now it is.

In forums such as the Harry Potter forums which I really do enjoy, there is no flaming or name calling, no discrimination between members and the thread go on for ever (literally). Although rumours spread like mad due to the fact that there is so much to talk about and so many people realizing possible links between the previous 2000 pages of Harry Potter and the next book, the forums are a rather nice place to be in, and everyone's ideas are accepted, as, at the end of the day, JKRowling is about as unpredictable as Gengar.
 
I actually agree with Latios somewhat. Have you ever *been* to a TheSims2 Forum? Any of you? Trust me, you don't want to.

The problem is that Pokemon is franchise aimed at kids-preteens, and you can't that's one of the factors. However, you'll see that pokemon is actually quite smart compared to the other franchises similar to it. Like I said, TS2. And then there are much more, like nintendo forums and such. The Sonic community is also quite stupid, really.

It kinda pisses me off when people complain about SPPf. Seriously, if you think SPPf's retarded, I take this is the only forum you go... unless the other ones are adult debate forums and such.
 
PDL said:
and is there any way that the fandom can present itself as a smarter fandom? (although that is an oxymoron in a sense, since all fandoms are filled with idiots)
Well, I'm not sure if this is relevant or not here considering this is the Serebii forums......

But, anyway, to answer your question PDL, I believe that Bulbagarden forums has DEFINITELY represented itself as the most "mature" Pokemon forums out there (I've even heard it been called that many times). And that has a lot to do with the fact that most of the members on BMGf are 18 and up (lol). ^^
 
Compared to Neopets, we're all geniuses. :D
Anyhoo, idiot is as idiot does. So the label idiot is entirely subjective.
Oh, and the reason many gamers despise the NetBattlers is because they always talk about Pokemon in terms of NetBattle, which is why In-Game RMT is an oxymoron.
Oh, and if you want to know where the real idiocy is, the Halo fanbase is pretty darn stupid.
For me, Pokemon is about fun, not competition. Anyway, I don't have the attention span to EV train, breed for Natures or moves, or anything like that.
Many of the fans of Pokemon just happen to have really short attention spans, like me. Pokemon was designed with those kind of people in mind.

Really, the internet attracts idiots like a light attracts flies.
People who are forced to spell well and write with good grammar aren't required to here. Bad ideas are given praise.
Also, it's silly to compare levels of stupidity. All fandoms are stupid to a degree. Live with it.
 
That sounded like a pesimists view on it! :P
Just thought i'd say that.
And that I think most people do it for fun, but winning all your battles make it even more fun!
I only have bread for natures and moves twice.... no wait 3 times.

~nightcat ;197;
 
Like someone else said, it isn't just the Pokemon fandom. The society (especially younger people) has depraved, alot.

I really do not want to go into a long winded post, but I've noticed that as of late, alot of those people have joined the SPP forums. Sad really when most of their posts are filled up with 'txt spk' or un-informed BS, or even the simple 'lol i agre'.

Speaking of which I recently done a talk in English about how the youth society today has gone downhill. Highest mark in the class for it, but there you go.

Thing is, I use to come to these forums more than I do now. It's not because I have other things to do, but it's because you could regularly see a well-informed answer to a well-informed topic. Good forums today are rare, and unfortunately it seems, the more popular they get - the worse they get (user wise).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top