SBaby
Dungeon Master
1. Legendaries in a region are inevitable. Are you going to tell me when it comes to uber tier we should have no new creatures in my regional roster? Will any story characters catch them? No, but these legs caries make for good movie spinoff stories.
Legendary Pokemon are fine in a fanfic, as long as the Trainer doesn't catch all of them them. That's the point I was trying to drive home. I don't mind when Fakemon are Legendary; I use them. But I normally don't just let the Trainer catch them.
If you absolutely MUST have a Trainer catch a Legendary Pokemon, there should at least be a really good reason for it. I will admit, it's not as cut and dry as it looks re-reading what I've posted, but I've seen many authors fall into the trap where the Trainer suddenly has a bunch of Legendaries, even though by realistic logic it should be impossible to do that, and there's nothing that can challenge him or her. That's when the character becomes a Mary-Sue or a Gary-Stu.
Not to mention according to some canons, catching Legendary Pokemon outright can have really bad effects on the environment. This is one of the reasons I made that rant about the Battle Frontier in the Anime.
2. Besides which a major issue arises if there isn't a new region. Namely where did five new species come from all of a sudden and why on yr ewe five.
I'll address this point, too. As the Anime has shown us, you don't necessarily need to go to an entirely new Region to introduce a new Pokemon. A character could encounter it deep in a forest, where nobody ventures. Or maybe an evil Team brought it from an undisclosed part of the world. The point is, there's ways to introduce them without journeying to a whole new Region (and yes I have to admit, that also includes Legendary Pokemon).
I'm not saying that you're a bad author if you make a new Region with a new 'Generation' for your Fic. I'm just saying that not many people can do it well. And therefore if you're inexperienced, you should avoid it (at least for the time being).
3. Not sure how to answer this one. It sounds objective and a tad insulting to make such a bold claim in front of many talented authors but what do I know?
In all fairness, this last one is mainly for newer authors. I wasn't necessarily aiming this one (or really any of my post) at the veterans. But it's true. Alot of people don't put in enough description for their fan Pokemon. I see it all the time. And I'm sure the mods of the forum do too.
Honestly, I'm not sure why you got mad about this. It wasn't even being directed at you. I posted this to answer the topic in general.