Yep, for all two of her lines.
When a voice sucks, it simply sucks. Doesn't matter how short a duration a time it was. I completely agree with StickerStarYoshi.
They have had 7 years to get it right. Like it or not, there's no excuse for crappy performances at this point.
My thoughts:
Ash- Good, but lacked emotion. Taylor was better because she was more natural and less forced, and for the emotion she put into the role.
Brock- Bad at first, good, then bad again. Stuart was better because his voice is higher pitched and fits his age better, but Bill was tolerable.
Misty- No contest. Lillis was FAR better. She sounds like Iris now. :/
Damian- Can go either way, really, but Blaustein won this one solely because of nostalgia.
Koga- Horrible. Stuart Zagnit was better.
Professor Oak- Nightmarishly bad. Stuart Zagnit was better. The worst by far.
Squirtle- Nearly dead on ringer for Eric's. Excellent.
Bulbasaur- Good enough impression of Tara Jayne. Good job.
All Other Pokémon- Simply pathetic. Poor job.
I felt kind of awkward watching the flashbacks in his new voice. the flashback scenes seemed forced. sarah portrays ash so differently.
Yeah, the voice itself is pretty close, but it sounds SO strained and forced. Taylor was far more natural.