As for the Black background with White text. Studies have actually proven that it's better for the eyes than white background with black text.
Not according to my professor in Color Studies, or my own aching eyes after staring at the screen.
And while I cannot recall the exact source, I have reason to believe that certain people's eyes become excessively strained when viewing white text on a black background. This also happens to include myself.
Possibly it could be better in some situations, however there is a very real population of people who are hurt by it, which is why I always stay away from it for body copy.
Just looking at such text for, say, 30 seconds, is extremely stressful, whereas it doesn't bother me in the slightest to simply read dark text on a lighter background.
This is part of why I don't go to certain websites anymore, since they changed their only layout to white on black. Despite the fact that a site's content is great, if they layout kills my vision, then I just can't go there anymore.
I'm glad Serebii forums still has the green theme - it's much more aesthetically pleasing, and much much more readable.
Jeez I hope you're not a designer, cause your idea is even worse. The BW theme is amazing and the better of the three currently available. You don't like it? Don't use it. Wait for the other themes to come out. And FYI, they were trying to be minimalistic. Apparently that concept was lost on you.
I'm not criticizing the layout itself. I'm criticizing the fact that it's used on a website that is a forum, which contains mostly body copy. Like I said, if it was mostly images posted, and not text, it wouldn't be an issue at all. Minimalism or not is irrelevant. I appreciate minimalism but that's completely and utterly BESIDE the point.
Er... speaking as a designer, white on black is terrible for those with sensitive eyes, especially now that the font is a little smaller. There is a HUGE difference between that and what black on white would look like. Most sites tend to use a light color for the background and dark color for text. It's waaaay easier on your eyes when reading for extended amounts of time. Black on a slight grey is even better. Think about all the books you read. Black on white. Not the other way around.
QFT. =)
---
I feel like I need to clear up two things:
First, when I said to put it on a white background on the black page background, I was just saying that because otherwise a lot of you would probably think it's too plain and not enough black for the "black and white" theme. But honestly, I'd rather see an off-white or gray background with black text. Basically, it was more like, if you must keep a black background, at least put the text on something not black.
And umm... Second, err... I'm a girl. =P (A lot of you were referring to me as "he" so umm yeah, I wanted to say that. LOL)