• We're currently experiencing a minor issue with our email system preventing emails for new registrations and verifications going out. We're currently working to fix this
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Graphics Club Userbar Contest

Which userbar should win?


  • Total voters
    16
  • Poll closed .

~Light

Well-Known Member
Welcome to this userbar contest of the Graphics Club!

Theme: Movies
Medium: Userbar

Results:
The voting's over! Here are the results:

Entry Number 1: -Sarah
Entry Number 2: DarkEmerl123
Entry Number 3: maz2468
Entry Number 4: meowth_city

First Place

-Sarah

http://i40.*******.com/14b0yfp.png

Second Place

meowth_city

http://i43.*******.com/20t1734.png

Third Place

DarkEmerl123

http://i41.*******.com/fup9ur.png

Entry Number 1:

http://i40.*******.com/14b0yfp.png

Entry Number 2:

http://i41.*******.com/fup9ur.png

Entry Number 3:

http://i41.*******.com/2vnevc4.png

Entry Number 4:

http://i43.*******.com/20t1734.png


When you vote please say why you voted for that userbar. If you vote for yourself your entry will be disqualified. Voting will last 3 days!

Good luck !
 
Last edited:

Fenyxfyr

Got a problem?
Ohhh, first post. (My first, as a first).
I voted for userbar #2. Why? No real reason. I liked the design.
The others, well Lion king is...old, Wall-E is...old, and Iron Man is...well, I've been saturated by Iron Man paraphanalia and I really can't look at any more Iron Man stuff, no insult intended.
 

millarc3005

Born a legend!
I thought I'd vote for a change so here are my comments:

#1 - I think the lighting in the userbar is perfect as well as logo and render positioning. The background also suits the image perfectly.

#2 - I think the userbal is very nicely set out and The render is in a suitable place to be noticed. Just one thing I notice, you could have sharpened the logo a bit cause it looks a bit blurry.

#3 - This userbar is very simple. I like the background lighting but you could have added a bit of effect like maybe some texch brushes because hes a robot. I think you might get what I mean. It also needs a border.

#4 - This userbar definatley has a lot of effects on it. I think it might be a bit Fiery to be suited with the lion king but it looks good whaterer else. You could have used maybe the logo or font on the banner. But I think this is great.

This was definately a fight between 1 and 4 for me. But after a hard decision, I chose

#1
 

DarkEmerl123

Railgun~
I voted for the first one, because I thought that it looked the best, and just appealed to me more.

Sorry that it's not a very good reason...
 

GloomyHaruka

They/She
Voted for entry #4.
Now I'm not a huge fan of the Lion King, but I must say I love this banner the most.
I like it because the colours are so well blended together. And I like the textures that were used.~
 

Northern Lights

[BritishSarcasm]
I really don't like the red outline on #1 it clashes with the main colours present in the userbar
The text on the #3 is far too big and the background is pretty bland, love the little plant and WALL-E sprites though and the fact that only yours has the highlight at the top (<3 WALL-E)

Between #2 and #4 for me...
#2 is fairly dark, could have done with some better contrast to make it more discernible
#4 is nice and bright, catching your eye [which is a userbars purpose really, advertise] the lack of scan line make it unique out of the four, but, call me old fashioned, I rather like the scan lines on the userbars

Voted for #2

 

Gelatino95

Not a tool
I voted for #1. First of all, I loved both Iron Man movies. In addition, however, the design and text contrast very well with the background (as opposed to number #2, which had text that was hard to read because of the lack of contrast). In addition, the contrasting colors go well together. It certainly helped that the maker didn't use the standard userbar font, either. All in all a good design.
 

~Kurou

to see you smile
I vote for the lion king one. Why? because The Lion King is my all time favourite movie
 

Zhanton

le quant-à-soi
I'll start with #3. It's relatively simple and I absolutely adore Wall-E, but the text looks too large and blocky and it's simplicity sort of kills it in the end. :x

#4 is really bright and the colours work well together. My only qualm is that the red is a bit too overpowering and there's isn't much contrast. It's well made though.

As for #2, I felt that the scanlines were too dark and they sort of obscured the render, and the text was really difficult to read. There wasn't enough contrast imo either.

I really like the lighting in #1 though, like NL, I feel that the red outline was definitely not the right choice. That said, I feel that the colours work quite well together and it looks great overall.

It's a tough choice given the quality of all four entries (as evident by the fact that the poll is so close at the moment). And I'm going to make it even closer by voting for #1.
 

Kelz

____________
I can't beleive I tried so hard at getting the club to agree in a userbar contest, and I forgot to enter. -___-

Anyways, I chose Entry 1. It appealed to me the most, I guess. I don't really have a specific reason as to why I chose it.
 

Victini01

♫Be Fearless♫
I vote for Entry 1 because it is very clear to see the images (if you know what I mean).
 

Novan_Hero

omnomnomnom
Bear in mind that I am using the Pichu Brothers Serebii theme, so something might stand out to me that don't to you, or vice versa XD

#1:Text and Render work together, reason being that the Text is from the actual movie (XD!!!) meaning, pretty much all you did was just get a render of each image, get/make a Sky Background and add them unto the finished Userbar Base, if that isn't the case, you did a good job replicating it, but lack of text originality (yes, I'm being nitpicky, sorry). That aside, it's a good Userbar and it's simplicity is what makes it a cool overall Userbar. (IDK, I'm trying to find a bad thing about each userbar >.< so that I can do a Pro and Con)

#2:Once I actually stopped slouching and looked at it better, I could actually read the text! But that aside, maybe you should make the BG and the Text more contrasting or maybe add a border to the text to make the text stand out more as really, it kind of blends into the BG. Otherwise, the overall userbar looks GREAT! Render is cool too.

#3:As much as I love Wall-E this Userbar is just TOO simple and the text is a bit big, XD I have a pretty mean joke so I won't say it... But, props on being the only example to use a semicircle highlight on your Userbar, because without the basics, any advanced stuff you do is pretty useless.

#4:Okay, I'll try to be as unbiased as possible because, I've grown up with The Lion King so Nostalgia glasses are a pretty good call for my opinion >.<... Anyway, the Userbar is overbrushed/has too much effect, so much so, that I didn't realize it was Lion King until I read the text and I didn't see the render until I stopped slouching. Other than that, cool colour scheme (cuz I fail at colour schemes ;_;) and TY for making such a Nostalgic Userbar!!!!

So reason being that I kind of had to be so nit picky to find one fault, I voted for #1.
 

~Light

Well-Known Member
The voting's over! Here are the results:

Entry Number 1: -Sarah
Entry Number 2: DarkEmerl123
Entry Number 3: maz2468
Entry Number 4: meowth_city

First Place

-Sarah

http://i40.*******.com/14b0yfp.png

Second Place

meowth_city

http://i43.*******.com/20t1734.png

Third Place

DarkEmerl123

http://i41.*******.com/fup9ur.png
 
Top