GWSC- Week 89 Poll

[noobiess]

ANYONE CAN VOTE
This week's challenge was to make a revamp of a GSC trainer sprite!

Everyone has 1 vote to use!
The votes will be tallied on Monday and the winner will be announced in Week #91.

Note that this week you can give 1 vote!!

Bert - Gary

,Ex - Beauty

Master Aboody - Jasmine

noobiess - Pryce

Skarm(Tm) - Lance

ZKE - Fisherman

Happy voting!

​

 

[Bakphoon™]

Voting for Bert. The sprite is well made and I love it.

 

[ZKE]

Bert - Gary. I really like the choices made with this one the most this week.

 

[Bert]

My vote has to go to noobiess, without question. He changed the size, proportions, colors, shading, etc... and the result looks spot-on imo. I loved the white socks, although I wouldn't really consider those a "fashion update" at all.
I'm not saying there wasn't any competition, though. In fact, all of the others look surprisingly great to me as well. That's kinda weird, when you think about it, since revamps are pretty hard and all that.

,Ex: The thing I've always liked most about all your sprites (including this one), is the extravagant shading style. It's unique, it generally looks great, but I'm not sure it works 100% with trainer sprites. In any case, the risk of such a unique style is that people will love it or hate it. Either way, great sprite!

Master Aboody: You did really well here, and I honestly think this is one of your best GWSC entries yet. The custom shading is properly done, and the only thing I can point out is that you could have touched up on the outline in some places (a little too much black on the hands, and the feet look kinda brittle).

Skarm™: Like I said before, great job in general, and superb one for a first revamp. I really like how you added the stuff from Lance's modern uniform to the old sprite. The shading is well done, but not really that noticeable since (imo) the lightest shade of the uniform is too dark, so you have to really look close to see it.

ZKE: Again, great shading. The sprite is very detailed (I love the way you revamped the fishing line) yet still packs that retro GSC feel.

I have one remark on every revamp besides noobiess' and ,Ex's though, and it's that none of the others dared to change the outline and the proportions. GSC trainer sprites generally have oversized heads, so when revamping I'd suggest extending the legs and torso a bit to make the sprites bigger and fixing the proportions at the same time. That's where noobiess stood out, imo.

 

[Master Aboody]

Voting for noobiess, because he made everything seem excellent in his sprite.
My revamp is not the best, but it received 2 votes.

 

[Miss Alexis]

I am voting for ,Ex - Beauty

 

[HM02gon]

My vote goes to Ex. The shading is amazing.

 

[Lorde]

All of the entries are good, but I gotta vote for Master Aboody - Jasmine. I think it's the best-looking sprite revamp.

 

[General Nonsense]

Voting for Master Aboody, looks really nice.

 

[Ex Extreme]

Great sprites this week, huh.
But I'm voting ZKE - Fisherman

 

[Prince Umbreon]

I'll vote for noobiess - Pryce. The socks and sandals are a neat little touch, and the slight shading on his face somehow gives him that "elderly but still imposing" feel.

 

[Pink Harzard]

I think that Gary made by Bert looks very good. It also resembles the anime Gary pretty well.

 

[Enjolras]

My vote goes to noobiess - Pryce. I like the sandal socks.

 

[noobiess]

To me Bert's en ,Ex's entry really stood out to me. The proportion are just right with both.
It ws a difficult choice but since I liked the shading on Bert's sprite more, I'm going to vote for him.

 

[Mew The Gato]

Voting for noobiess. For the reasons Bert mentioned, Pryce looks as if he could pass for a modern sprite.

 

[burnt_lucario]

My vote is for noobiess, for the same reasons mentioned in previous votes.