F
Flora Leader
Guest
Should Gyarados learn Aeroblast and/ or Sky Attack for his flying type move
Chaos Emerald said:Neither. Aero Blast is Lugia's signature attack, and Sky Attack doesn't make sense for it. I don't think it should be a Flying type at all.
Flora Leader said:True for Aero Blast...but Sky Attack can make sense...Gyarados can fly up in the sky just like the anime. and just fly down to attack. Sky attack doesnt involve wings so maybe. And yea thats true it should be part dragon but its not gonna change. unless they decide to change it like they did the magnets
Yamato-san said:OK, 1) there's a reason the magnets changed types: it's because the Steel-type didn't even exist yet, and GSC was the only generation to add new types. Now, you could say that if it were Water/Dragon, it'd have been broken in RGBY due to not having a weakness (only Dragon-type move being Dragon Rage), but if they wanted to change it, they would've done so by now. Also, I don't know how many times I have to say this, but Koiking and Gyarados are actually based off a Chinese myth which involves a carp climbing to the top of a waterfall, and as a reward for its endurance, it transforms into a flying serpent. This is why it's water/flying. Now, Gyarados is constantly portrayed in the anime, as well as the manga until recently, to be a serpent that simply crawls on land. I don't know why it has this portrayal, especially considering the Japanese should be more familiar with oriental myths than we are, but that's their fault, in any case. There's nothing wrong with Gyarados's type.
2) Sky Attack is not simply a matter of flying in the sky, and while it doesn't seem to involve wings, it does seem to involve a bird-like figure nontheless. For those unaware, Sky Attack is called "God Bird" in the Japanese version. Even if you didn't know that, nearly all animations of the attack depict the Pokemon glowing like a phoenix before charging into the enemy. Gyarados's long, serpent-like body wouldn't be able to fit that.
As you can see, I don't think it should have Sky Attack. It shouldn't have Aeroblast, neither, since it's Lugia's exclusive move. Aerial Ace would make a lot of sense, though, considering nearly every other Pokemon with fangs or claws is capable of learning it.
Wong Agung said:I think Gyarados itself isn't suitable to be a flying type (Uh, no wing, no beak..), so almost no flying move is suitable for it..anyways the flying moves that suitable for it, I think is Gust, Aerial Ace and Aeroblast.
Flora Leader said:Its only considered a flying poke. because it has tha ability to fly in the anime
jellsprout said:Wrong! It has the ability to fly in the Anime because it's a Flying type, not vice versa. The games and Gyarados came ages before the Anime. Like Yamato-san said, it is a Flying type because of the myth it was based on.
And Wong Agung, what the hell does that have to do with being a Flying type? Being a Flying type means that that Pokémon is able to fly, not that it is a bird. And does Rayquaza have a beak or wings? No!
I think that it should learn either Aerial Ace or a new blast type Flying attack. An example I thought up myself was Huricane Blast.