• Hi all. We have had reports of member's signatures being edited to include malicious content. You can rest assured this wasn't done by staff and we can find no indication that the forums themselves have been compromised.

    However, remember to keep your passwords secure. If you use similar logins on multiple sites, people and even bots may be able to access your account.

    We always recommend using unique passwords and enable two-factor authentication if possible. Make sure you are secure.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Harry Potter: Unanswered Questions

acetrainerbob

has written:
Hello! This story is about the unanswered questions of Harry Potter. An example is, "How did Mad-Eye Moody get his magical eye?" The answers will be written in the form of a novel, but catagorized like a document. Some chapters will be labeled B.H.P.B. This stands for Before Harry Potter was Born. Other chapters will be labeled with numbers 1-17. This means that the event happened while Harry Potter was a certain age (the ones listed above). There will be some chapters that have the abbreviation A.V.D. labeling them. This translates into After Voldemort Died. I have a few questions I am about to answer while others I haven't even thought of. If you would like me to answer a question, please post or PM me a question.

NOTE: this story is PG for some blood, violence, and language

B.H.P.B 1: Why did Wormtail betray his friends?

"I need you to tell me where they are. My spy told me the prophecy, and I know the prophecy spoke of the Potter's son. I will give you great power, but I need to know where the Potters are hiding Wormtail." Voldemort coaxed.

It was pitch-black. There was no moon out tonight, which was essestinal to Voldemort's plan. Tonight was a full moon. He didn't need Remus Lupin to sniff them out. Remus Lupin was a werewolf who used to go to Hogwarts. To keep normal citizens safe, he traveled to the Forbidden Forest. He was usually trapped in the forest for the whole time.

Why was Voldemort in the Forbidden Forest if it was so close to school grounds? Because barely anyone came there. But unfourtunately, Wormtail and Voldemorthad to travel deep into the Forbidden Forest. A half-giant named Rubeus Hagrid lived in a hut in front of the entrance. Hagrid had been expelled form Hogwarts due to Voldemort manipulating the whole school. Albus Dumbledore, a Transfiguration teacher at the time, conivnced Hogwarts to let Hagrid live in the hut, only after the Ministry of Magic broke Hagrid's wand. Voldemort wasn't worried about Hagrid seeing them, he was woried about Hagrid's mutt, Fang, smelling them.

"I know the prophecy spoke of the Potter's son, and Lilly is due in two months. I will give you unspeakable powers and riches. You will become the best servant I ever had. The most loyal, the strongest Death Eater at my disposal." Voldemort persuaded.

"I-I-I can b-b-become the Secret K-keep-p-per." Wormtail volunteered. "They might not appoint the position for a while, but I can convince James to let me become the Secret Keeper. Then I'll just wait another year or so. The baby won't cry as much and we can sneak in the entrance and kill the baby."

"Wormtail, I'll consider that plan. But you need to at least give me their location and the details of the house so I can form a plan around the structure. I'll know the place inside and out, and I can kill them all!"

I'll need to kill everyone including the baby as Wormtail knows. Then the boy and the Potter family will be out of my way once and for all! Voldemort triumphantly thought.

"Wormtail, you need to become Secret Keeper as soon as possible. Now I mmust give you the Dark Mark in front of the other Death Eaters, but not now. It will draw too much attention. Go to the Potters' house and await my instructions for next morning. An owl will send you a message.
 
Last edited:

acetrainerbob

has written:
Chapter 2

1 Year Old: 1

"So you need me to fix your eye with a charm Alastor Moody?" Professor Flitwick asked. "Well I'm afraid I'm not much help. But if you go through surgical procedures for an artifical eye, I might be able to charm it so that you can see everything around you. Besides, I don't have a charm to help you."

Mad-Eye Moody was standing in front of Professor Flitwick's desk in the classroom for Charms class. Alastor Moody had come in requesting an eye to replace the one that he had lost in a battle against Wormtail. He slammed his free hand on the desk. Papers scattered everywhere as he yelled, "I need help!"

"Well why don't you visit our infirmary? Our new nurse might be able to help your eyesight." Flitwick suggested.

"I already asked her for help, but her potion made it worse! Her potion was really a batch of posion that affected my eye and made it worse! I had to kill her because she was a Death Eater! People are inflitrating Hogwarts and I thought your charms could counter the curse Wormtail inflicted on me!"

"What happened?" Flitwick inquired.

"Wormtail shot a Conjunctivitis curse at me. I failed to block it and it hit my eye. The bloody rat." Moody replied.

"Go back to the infirmary and see if Madam Poppy can help you. You'll probably want to go to St. Mungo's though and get an eye transplant or an artificial eye. If you gat an artifical one, I can charm it for better efficiency than a normal eye." Flitwick said. "Now out!"

Moody walked out of the classroom, still clutching his eye. Blood dripped down his hand as memories flooded back to him.

"I'll kill you! I've already revealed the Potter's location to Voldemort! He will be so proud of me. I'll kill you right now and in two days, no one will be able to stop him from killing Harry Potter!" Wormtail bragged.

Moody and Wormtail snatched their wands from their pockets, each in a fighting stance.

"Petrificus Totalus!" Wormtail announced.

"Finite Incantatum!" Moody yelled back.

Both of them moved their wands in special motions and they each cast their spell. Moody could sense the spell coming towards him. A huge protective forcefield spread out and defended a huge area. Wormtail's spell suddenly stopped and disappeared. The forcefield vanished while Wormtail was already making his next move.

Wormtail moved his wand in a different motion than last time. Before Moody could flick his wand to the side, his vision became blurry. He could barely see anything.

"Advada-" Wormtail began as he pulled back his wand.

Moody disapperead, he Apparated away. He arrived at the first place his mind pictured: Hogwarts.

Back in the present, Moody couldn't see anything at all out of his right eye. The eye was burning, and the world was a blurr of colors. After a while, darkness began to take over his eyesight. It was getting harder and harder to see, but thankfully only one of his eyes were affected. He could see crystal clear out of one eye while the other eye could barely see anything at all.

Outside of Hogwarts protections, Moody Apparated to St. Mungo's. He opened the door and walked through the entrance. He stopped at the counter, and a nurse walked towards the counter as well.

"Welcome to St. Mungo's. What ails you today?" she asked. She looked down and noticed his bloody hand.

"My eyesight is at risk of failing in my right eye." Moody replied.

The nurse bent down and opened a drawer. She pulled a peice of paper out of it and placed it on the counter.

"I know you're eyesight is failing, but you'll need to fill out this form the best you can." she said.

Moody snatched the pen resting on its stand and filled out the form carefully, answering each question honestly and to the best of his knowledge.

The nurse, who had left the counter, returned with a bottle of a perculiar potion.

She gave the brown bottle to Moody and said, "Don't worry, it's a Draught of Peace. We use this on all of our patients."

Moody sat down in an adjacent chair and sniffed the potion.

What does she think she's doing? Moody thought. I sniffed the potion just in case because of my last run-in with healing potions at Hogwarts, and sure enough, she thinks I'm stupid.

Moody aimed his wand at the nurse and yelled, "Petrificus Totalus!" The nurse suddenly became erieely still and her body dropped to the floor.

"Try to poison me, eh?" Moody yelled. "Ya think I'm stupid?" Just then, Moody dropped to the ground.



Moody woke up in the Hogwarts infirmary. He looked around, but he felt sluggish. He noticed that he could see all around with his right eye. And not omly that, but it was crystal clear!

Poppy walked over to Moody and asked, "How does your new eye feel? We got word that St. Mungo's was inflitrated by Death Eaters. A group of wizards and witches took care of them and noticed you on the ground uncouncious. They put you in the infirmary and told me to give you a new eye. So I gave you an artificial eye and I had Flitwick come in and charm it, just like you wanted. Oh, we also cleaned up your hand." she said as she noticed that Moody was staring at his blood-free hands.

"I feel great!" Moody shouted.

"Now you're going to have to wait in here for a few days. Dumbledore will come visit you later and tell you the bad news." Poppy ordered.

"Bad news, tell me." Moody said in his gravely voice.

"James and Lilly Potter are dead." Dumbledore announced as he walked into the room.
 

acetrainerbob

has written:
The first document we've found about Moody's death is here

A.V.D 1

Some of us have been wondering how Mad-eye Moody really died and why nobody could find his body. J.K.Rowling didn't go into very much detail into these incidents, so this is the question for today.



"This is outrageous!" a man boomed as he threw a newspaper down on his brown coffee table. "It's been a year since Moody died and just now you announced it to the public! I didn't even know about Moody's death untill I picked up today's copy of the Daily Prophet!" The elderly man stood up from the his black leather recliner and slammed a fist down on the coffee table. As if a shockwave was sent throughout the table, the table was jarred and the old man's coffee cup was knocked on the floor spilling coffe everywhere on his fuzzy carpet.

"Daxdaleuis, you know that the Daily Prophet is queer." another man remarked as Daxdaleuis snatched his wand out of his pocket. Daxdaleuis muttered a few words and waved his wand around in three sharp circles. The coffee cup zoomed back onto the table along with the scalding black caffinated liquid that poured itself into the cup.

"You drink coffee?" the other man asked.

Daxdaleuis shook his head. "You can't fool me with that trick! How long have you known?" he yelled.

"Known what?"

"About Moody... Minister?"

"How long have you known?" the Minister asked.

"They announced it in the newspaper two days ago."

"They weren't supposed to announce that untill tommorrow!" the Minister cried.

"Thank you Rita Skeeter." Daxdaleuis whispered. He sat back down continued to read the newspaper, flipping pages untill he found something interesting.

"How Moody really died." Daxdaleuis read aloud.

He continued to read in his head and slammed the newspaper down on the coffee table once more.

"Moody died from a Death Eater attack?" Daxdaleuis yelled.

"You see," the Minister began, "Moody died the night that Potter was escorted to the Burrow. It was a windy night, and Moody was one of the escorts. He was protecting Mungdungus Fletcher, who was disguisedas Potter himself. After fighting off a huge wave of Death Eaters, Voldemort himself appeared. Flecther fled, and Voldemort tried to kill Moody. They continued to fight, each spell besting the last. After a while, Moody hit Voldemort with a Stunning spell. Moody sped and and fled the scene.

A little while later Voldemort caught up again and cast a Killing Curse. Unaware that Voldemort was near him, Moody was killed as he fell off of his broom. His body somehow survived the fall, and the Ministry retrieved Moody's body. Corrupted by Voldemort at the time, the Ministry kept the secret under wraps, and buried Moody's body deep in the earth, underneath the Ministry itself. Before burying him though, the Minstry wanted to add a final insult to Moody. Umbridge gouged out Moody's magical eye and used it to replace her peeping hole. Eventually, they took the eye and buried it with Moody, and left him there to rest in peace. They couldn't move his body, but they built a memorial for Moody right on top of where he was buried. They just finished it a few months ago."

"Well thank you for satisfying my questions. Now you may leave as my dentures are about to-"

As the Minister left the house, Daxdaleuis' dentures popped out of his mouth. He grabbed them, walked into his room, andshut the door, not knowing how many tidbits that the Minister had left out of his story.
 

acetrainerbob

has written:
I will only be able to update every one or two weekends because of school, so even if i'm online on the weekdays, i probably don't have enough time to update. I just wanted to let you know
 

acetrainerbob

has written:
I'm sorry for the long wait, but I'll have my chapter up in the next two weeks (as I have to keep up with a few other stories and fics).
 

Charizardfan900

Charizard King!
Hmmmm...

Hello again.

Well, this is a very interesting view on the Harry Potter universe. But be warned.

Many people, including me, would find this rather... unloyal to the books and HP universe. Such as the fact the new minister of magic would of announced all the deaths straight away. Because the new Minster of Magic was Kingsly.

Also make them a bit longer.

i guess you never read the books.

Also Moody wouldn't of lost his eye to Wormtail because Wormtail was undercover and wasn't realized as a double agent until book three

However, you caught Moodys character rather well.
 
Last edited:

FireTypeLover

Mr. Soul Stealer
Hmmmm...

Hello again.

Well, this is a very interesting view on the Harry Potter universe. But be warned.

Many people, including me, would find this rather... unloyal to the books and HP universe. Such as the fact the new minister of magic would of announced all the deaths straight away. Because the new Minster of Magic was Kingsly.

Also make them a bit longer.

i guess you never read the books.

Also Moody wouldn't of lost his eye to Wormtail because Wormtail was undercover and wasn't realized as a double agent until book three

However, you caught Moodys character rather well.

I agree with this post about it being unloyal, particularily the part about Kingsley. Though the fic is kind of interesting, there's many errors that prevent it from being a very good fic. Like the fact that the Minister is Kingsley and he would've told everyone about Moody's death...

Some errors to note is you spelled Lily's name wrong, you really don't need to explain about Remus and Ruebus that way because it detracts from the story of the first one-shot, you misspelled poison, Wormtail's betrayal wasn't known until Prisoner of Azkaban, you spelled Avada Kedavra wrong, and, if I remember correctly, there's protections which makes Apparating or Disapparating to or from Hogwarts impossible, so Moody Apparating there would theoretically be impossible.
 
Last edited:

acetrainerbob

has written:
ehh... sorry. You're right, it's not loyal to the books (and I probably butchered the characters) and I don't have a lot of time to update it so I'll probably close the thread. I also probably forgot to mention, but A.V.D stands for After Voldemort Died, so Wormtail's would've already been known by then
 
Last edited:

Charizardfan900

Charizard King!
ehh... sorry. You're right, it's not loyal to the books (and I probably butchered the characters) and I don't have a lot of time to update it so I'll probably close the thread. I also probably forgot to mention, but A.V.D stands for After Voldemort Died, so Wormtail's would've already been known by then

Theres no mention o Wormtail in any of the A.V.D
 

acetrainerbob

has written:
okay, im dropping this fic unfourtuntely. maybe I'll start a new and updated version another time, 'cuz I'm working on a bunch of other writing peices whether they're for fun or for school, so I am constantly writing (althoug I haven't updated anything on here for quite some time). See ya later. Also, if anyone wants to continue this fic or rewrite it, go ahead. You don't have to give any credit to me, and it's officialy yours.
 
Top