• Hi all. We have had reports of member's signatures being edited to include malicious content. You can rest assured this wasn't done by staff and we can find no indication that the forums themselves have been compromised.

    However, remember to keep your passwords secure. If you use similar logins on multiple sites, people and even bots may be able to access your account.

    We always recommend using unique passwords and enable two-factor authentication if possible. Make sure you are secure.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Have Brock's chances of a cameo in BW dwindled?

Status
Not open for further replies.

BlueVapor

Well-Known Member
Hmm, I was honestly thinking this too... Living in my own delusional world, I was hoping he along with Misty and May would all appear in BW at some point, but that's not going to happen. His only chance is the final episode of BW when Ash returns there, like what Gary did in AG....

I do wonder though, every series we get an opening with a shot of all of Ash's past travelling friends. We haven't yet for BW. I mean, if there is a new opening starting with the N stuff then maybe, but that doesn't fit. Oh well :/
 

CyberCubed

Yeah, ok!
I do wonder though, every series we get an opening with a shot of all of Ash's past travelling friends. We haven't yet for BW. I mean, if there is a new opening starting with the N stuff then maybe, but that doesn't fit. Oh well :/

Maybe they stopped doing that because it tricks people into thinking those characters will appear. Misty was actually in a lot of the AG openings too including the two Battle Frontier ones, but she didn't actually appear in any of those BF episodes after Ash left Pallet. And of course in DP, neither Misty, Max nor Tracey appeared despite being in the second opening.

Openings are misleading.
 

Blessed

Well-Known Member
Well, seeing him in Dawn's flashbacks wasn t enough. I wish there was there a new opening with the old characters.
 

Yankees4life

RONALDO!!!
yep, very unfortunate tho. Dawn gets like 10 eppys along with that penguin but the legend can barely get one!!
 

KibaLG8

Well-Known Member since the DP Series.
Due to how Brock wanted devote his time to studying to become a doctor, it meant he wasn't going to go traveling. They gave Brock a reason to stay behind this time, pretty sure they planned to not give him an in-person cameo. Be happy with what you got.
 

An00bis

Wicked Witch
Considering how poorly they handled Dawn's cameo do we even want him back to suffer through that? Brock's a character that's very easily overshadowed by another. It wouldn't do much for that to happen to him. It happened to Dawn and she was one of the most predominate friends ever.

I thought the way they handled Brock in Best Wishes 2 was enough. As long as they continue acknowledging he existed I can live with him not appearing in the flesh.
 

WaterShuriken

"I..I..Iron Tail, Pikachu."
He can still get episodes if they focus on Castelia City and their medical schools. He could appear in a town and travel with them until then. Participate in a tourney for fun maybe. I doubt all 30 or so episodes will focus on Team Plasma.
 
Last edited:

CyberCubed

Yeah, ok!
He cans till get episodes if they focus on Castelia City and their medical schools. He could appear in a town and travel with them until then. Participate in a tourney for fun maybe. I doubt all 30 or so episodes will focus on Team Plasma.

There's probably going to be some last tournament for Ash before this gen ends. I can't see them ending a generation without Ash's pokemon team doing one last big battle. Whether its against league opponents or Brock appears remains to be seen.
 

pokemon fan 132

Well-Known Member
Theoretically there is still chance for Brock to make cameo appearance since new generation at least wont begin until end of 2013. Not to mention his flashbacks in Dawn cameo could serve as foreplay announcing his return in person eventually.

I would like to see some update on his character, pokemon and how is doctor career progressing and i believe his similarities with Cilan create foundations for some worthy, interesting interactions. Meeting between two older make sidekicks who are like older brother to group and cook contest to determine who is better chef could besar some fruits on table imo.
It would be interesting to see him doing field work and research on pokemon outside of center along with learning about new ways of curing from first hand by meeting other specialists not only relying on books making sense serving as way to enrich his knowledge which could help him when passing test and examiners in future trying to become doctor.

And seeing him battle for old time sake would be appreciated too. With such impressive pokemon arsenal like Steelix, Croagunk, Foretress, Marshtamp, Crobat, Sudowoodo its real shame we never saw him battle much.

The better question is: Do people even care enough about Brock to warrant him a cameo?

If you ask me such way of thinking only further encourage having anime imbued with lower quality which suffers from intermittent connections with past, very little continuity and lack of cohesive and stable storyline. Which is anything but good with constant cast cycling not contributing much in long term to ensure appeal and loyalty among fandom to broad show popularity.

Even if we get sick of certain character that doesn't mean he couldn't restore in future appeal he used to have making us appreciate him again. Or create different spin to him/her adding new interesting dimension to it.
Instead of stopping to care altogether turning blind eye to problem, avoiding to directly face with it.

Personally yes i miss Brock, and many other people out there miss him too having fond memories of character wanting to see him again. Granted there are other characters which i would rather have return who haven't been seen for years like Misty, but i still appreciate Brock contribution to anime and all positive things he did deserving some recognition. No one deserves to end up abandoned and erased from face of existence.

Yeah, like, a couple?

Admittedly demand for Brock isn't so prevalent around here but judging by youtube, deviantart, pokecommuntity or tumblr Brock still has respectively big following with number being counted in thousands. Not even counting those who either don't come on internet or don't post on pokesites .

When it comes to Brock, I see a lot of people talk about how stale and annoying he ended up becoming. I see little fanart and fanfiction for him. People rarely state he's a favorite of theirs.

Fanart and fanfiction isn't credible indication through which we can base someone popularity though, because not every character which is popular has lot of appeal for shipping or invention of fanon stories about himself.

Needless to say just because you see sizable portion claiming Brock got "stale" doesn't mean something is true.

For instance "many like junk food, but that doesn't make it fine cuisine".

It's weird because aside from a couple of COTDs, I really don't care much for the other main characters like Misty and Brock, probably because they degenerated so much.

I presume your speaking for yourself, because i didn't found Misty character stale at all with most of her highlights coming from Orange Islands and Johto. On contrary just when writers finally started to do more with her story exploring on water master dream with Whirl Cup making things become interesting which was fresh breath of air after usual supporting role character was put in, she got replaced.
Being followed with some notable growth in chronicles and AG cameos earning sisters respect, taming Gsarados, releasing Togetic etc.

Value of character shouldn't be determined by how much focus he gets, but by how much he contributes to anime appeal and Misty definitely managed to add tension and vibrant dynamic in cast, helped Ash grow as trainer, often contributed to resolution of plots in episodes and got some intriguing growth herself too.

Granted writers made slip with her in mid Johto being often on sidelines, but way i see it with Master Quest and onwards character was successfully brought back on right track managing to keep appeal.

Same applies to Brock until DP where he got shafted too much for my taste i thought he was handled pretty good especially in AG saga. I enjoyed in his interactions with AG cast still having his moments, addition of Max helped his character by having someone to who he could relate to and his breeding career got some notable focus too often helping to resolve alarming situations regarding wild or endured pokemon, took care of suck characters like nurse Joy etc.
Likewise he was more active than i can say for Johto too having some notable moments like battling May in contest, battling TR with Ash in tag match to save Pewter gym, learn about new ways to prepare food and keep pokemon in top shape(like pokeblocks etc).

I just don't care much for them and neither do a lot of fans.

Any proof to back this up? Because i can assure you how internet is full of people who like Misty character with demands for return for cameo or even return to cast still being respectively big. Even after such long time being equally popular to other girls (arguably even more).
 
Last edited:

PokemonMasters

Axiomatic Trainer
Brock's finished! He decided to become a pokemon doctor and left the series! His chances of coming back are absolutely zero. But i'll never forget his long appearance in the anime. Nobody who replaces him would be better than him! Not Cilan, not anyone!
 

1rkhachatryan

Call me Robert guys
Brock's finished! He decided to become a pokemon doctor and left the series! His chances of coming back are absolutely zero. But i'll never forget his long appearance in the anime. Nobody who replaces him would be better than him! Not Cilan, not anyone!

He means as a cameo -_-.
 

Hilda

Well-Known Member
The better question is: Do people even care enough about Brock to warrant him a cameo?

Of course, Brock has a lot of fans. He is from the original cast, he has way more weight than dawn, may...etc

*sees an angry mob of newgenners behind*

I expected this.
 

pokemon fan 132

Well-Known Member
Brock's finished! He decided to become a pokemon doctor and left the series! His chances of coming back are absolutely zero. But i'll never forget his long appearance in the anime. Nobody who replaces him would be better than him! Not Cilan, not anyone!

To be fair every character has chance to come back again if writers find his return could help advance current story or contribute to its plot. People thought Brock was finished when staying with prof. Ivy to advance breeder career but writers still managed to find way to reintroduce him back.

Not to mention doctors sometimes travel too to go on conventions, research about new pokemon and new ways of healing so its not like we couldn't see him catch up with Ash at some point. A least for appearance that is.

Of course, Brock has a lot of fans. He is from the original cast, he has way more weight than dawn, may...etc

Quoted for truth.
 

CyberCubed

Yeah, ok!
Of course, Brock has a lot of fans. He is from the original cast, he has way more weight than dawn, may...etc

*sees an angry mob of newgenners behind*

I expected this.

Brock has always been slightly less popular than all 3 of the main girls of the anime before BW. And I'm saying this without bias.

Even when the show first started it always seemed like Misty was slightly more popular than Brock. And the main story of AG and DP focused on May and Dawn.
 
Last edited:

Platinum fan.

RetiredPokemonMaster
Considering how poorly they handled Dawn's cameo do we even want him back to suffer through that? Brock's a character that's very easily overshadowed by another. It wouldn't do much for that to happen to him. It happened to Dawn and she was one of the most predominate friends ever.

I thought the way they handled Brock in Best Wishes 2 was enough. As long as they continue acknowledging he existed I can live with him not appearing in the flesh.

This. If I want to see Brock I don't want it to be in Best Wishes. We have so many main characters they aren't all going to get cameos anymore. This is why I keep saying we need Chronicles. I know we aren't getting one but still, if we had one it wouldn't make a difference if characters cameoed in Ash's current region or not.
 

Super-Staff

Turnabout Pokemon
Any proof to back this up? Because i can assure you how internet is full of people who like Misty character with demands for return for cameo or even return to cast still being respectively big. Even after such long time being equally popular to other girls (arguably even more).

The internet does have more people who want Misty (and any of the girls) to return than Brock. Of course I can't provide 100% fullproof evidence, that's ridiculous. I say this based on observation from years of being in the Pokemon fandom. Brock has fans, just not numbering in the millions. Sorry, but that's ridiculous, to claim that he's super popular.
 

JennaJayfeather

Gangrenous Creature
o_O I'm surprised by the number of people thinking/wanting Brock will/to return (as in travel) for Gen 6. He's a doctor now and he'll have to study hard for that. That was the reason why he switched most likely, so they could take him off the show. /that was a bit of a rant but now on topic/

I think Brock could get a cameo. Not in Unova now, that'd just be crazy IMO. However, he easily could say hi if Ash drops back in Kanto like Misty did, or he could have a cameo in Gen 6 maybe.
 

Bluelatios*

Well-Known Member
The internet does have more people who want Misty (and any of the girls) to return than Brock. Of course I can't provide 100% fullproof evidence, that's ridiculous. I say this based on observation from years of being in the Pokemon fandom. Brock has fans, just not numbering in the millions. Sorry, but that's ridiculous, to claim that he's super popular.

Ah, but sometimes it takes a character's absence to prompt his/her fans to discuss the merits of that character. Correct me if I'm wrong, but female anime characters are generally talked about more than males except for main starring males. To top it off, Brock as a character has had fluctuations in his role and popularity, much like Ash due to their lengthy time spend on the show combined with fluctuations in the show's writing. Indeed its a daunting task to try and measure his popularity through anything but personal observations. I won't deny DP as being a bit of a bump for him and many of his fans. Despite that, the popularity of OS, AG to a fine extent, and characters with whom Brock was closest to are indicators that he is in good standing overall. Thus he is an excellent candidate for either a cameo or a full return. TPC is becoming less predictable as of late (which is good), so the question of if and when is honestly more difficult than determining whether he's popular.
 
Last edited:

Cresselia92

SM Ash = New Ash
Chances are very thin, but who knows? We may see him one last time when/if Ash returns home and get ready to go to the 6th region. I'd like to see him again once more, but I won't hold my breath.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top