1. We have moved to a new forum system. All your posts and data should have transferred over. Welcome, to the new Serebii Forums. Details here
    Dismiss Notice
  2. Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
    Dismiss Notice
  3. If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders
    Dismiss Notice

Hoenn Starters vs Kanto Starters?

Discussion in 'Past Pokémon Generations Discussion' started by ((JAWS)), Mar 24, 2013.


Kanto Starters vs Hoenn Starters

  1. Hoenn Starters (Treeko, Mudkip, Torchic)

    150 vote(s)
  2. Kanto Starters (Bulbasaur, Charmander, Squirtle)

    96 vote(s)
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. ((JAWS))

    ((JAWS)) Johto Trainer

    The title is kind of stating it right here. Lets compare and contrast.

    A note before you post here:
    Remember that this forum is for discussion of older gens, so please keep references to gen 5 and 6 additions to the starters minimal. Your post should NOT be about how one starter is better than the other because of its Hidden Ability or Mega Evolution!
    A simple mention is okay ("Also, I like Mega ___"), but don't make it the focus of your comparison.

    Also, explain your reasoning a bit. Only posting something like "Charizard > Blaziken" is spam

    Blastoise and Swampert
    This is a tough one and I know many of you will say Swampert. Unfortunately for Kanto it will be Swampert and for me it is Swampert. No one uses Grass types really so it makes Swampert practically invincible in all the regions. Plus ice beam.

    Sceptile and Venusaur
    I've used both plenty of times and this one definitely is also tough. My Sceptile was really meh at the begining but once I migrated it to future generations it became a boss. My bulbusaur however was easy to train, and became strong very quickly if you knew what you were doing. For me hands down Venusaur, for the simple reason it learns cooler grass moves than sceptile. Sceptile does not learn Giga Drain at all. (disappointing)

    Blaziken and Charizard
    This is the hardest choice of my life right here it's like choosing between my kids haha. Blaziken is amazing but so is Charizard. When it comes right down to it they are evenly matched. Charizard is weak to Rock, Electricity and Water while Blaziken is weak to Flying, Rock, Ground, Water, and Psychic. Blaziken has a huge disadvantage there on weaknesses. Charizard could use an easy aerial ace and KO Blaziken dead. Blaziken really can't avoid that either which is disappointing.. Blaziken could use rock slide but so could Charizard. In the end Charizard won here. Blaziken isn't as amazing as hyped to be... Charizard could KO it anyday.
    Last edited by a moderator: Nov 1, 2014
  2. Icarus©

    Icarus© Full on PASBLer

    Swampert over Blastiose.
    I've never really liked Blastiose persay, and while a great rapid spinner, Swampert does his job as a bulky water way better.
    And his design looks amazing.

    Sceptile over Venasaur.
    Out of all of these, this was the hardest one.
    Sceptile has a great look to him, not to mention his unburden flying gem acrobatics set is amazing.
    I have great memories of playing through LG with him, but his lack of immediate power was... dissapointing.

    Blaziken over Charizard.
    I hate charizard.
    And Blaziken can defeat Charizard very easily.

    Turn 1.
    Blaziken Used protect!
    Charizard uses Aerial ace, whatever flying type move you want.
    Blaziken protected its self!
    Blaziken's speed rose with Speed boost!

    Blaziken used Rock slide/Stone edge!
    Its super effective! Charizard fainted!
  3. *PKMN Trainer Paddy*

    *PKMN Trainer Paddy* #HORSEPOWER

    Blastoise vs. Swampert
    They are both good Pokemon in their own rights. Blastoise is defensive and swampert is a bit more offensive. Both are good in terms of design BUT overall i think i can pick a winner. I choose Swampert as hes easier to use in my opinion and hes ground type also.

    Venusaur vs. Sceptile
    I used them both and i love them both, that much i have them in shiny form. But in battling terms i really dont think their equal. While Venusaur has good special stats and looks quite cool. But Sceptile has great sp.atk and is alot faster and is VERY 'cool' looking. But while i like Venusaur more, I must say Sceptile is a better battler.

    Charizard vs. Blaziken
    The first fire/fighting starter vs. the first fire starter. While Blaziken is a good pokemon and adored by many fans of pokemon, in my opinion Blaziken just comes up short with Charizard. Because Charizard is good, not excellent but good. Almost everybody loves him and to be honest hes my favorite Pokemon outside the Turtwig line. And flying beats fighting too....
  4. Squiddly Dee

    Squiddly Dee ∈ (⊙ ⊖ ⊙) ∋

    Venusaur VS. Sceptile

    Though I love the Treecko family, Bulbasaur just has to win this one for me. Bulbasaur was my first Pokemon EVER, and despite what the rest of you may have said, Venusaur has greater overall capabilities. Under sun, Chlorophyll Venusaur is a monster. And with its Poison typing, it could easily beat Sceptile in a fight. Plus, you've gotta admit it, Sceptile doesn't exactly have the greatest level-up movepool in the world. While I will agree that Sceptile is really cool, Venusaur just has to win this. It's my third favorite Pokemon and second favorite Grass-type for a reason.

    Charizard VS. Blaziken

    Sorry for more bias, but I just can't stand Charizard. Just... ugh. Genwunners have ruined my opinion of it forever. And either way, Blaziken is stronger, faster, and has a far cooler design. I used one in an Emerald nuzlocke, and he's gotten me out of more tough spots than you could ever imagine. Blaziken wins this hands down.

    Swampert VS. Blastoise

    I really like both of these lines in terms of design - A giant tortoise with artillery cannons on its back? AWESOME. An overgrown axolotl that can shake the very earth? AWESOME. But Swampert just barely wins this one for me due to its better stats. Though Blastoise's defenses are pretty good, its offensive stats are rather lackluster. And I've always just preferred offensive/balanced Pokemon as a whole. So, though its pretty close, I'd have to go with Swmapert.
  5. Plus side down side

    Plus side down side Lass Trainer

    Venasaur Vs. Sceptile
    To me, its Venasaur hands down. It works very well with its poison type, and it's bulky. It also has dream world chlorophyll, which makes it even stronger. It's also one of my favorite lines in general, so I'm biased.

    Swampert Vs. Blastoise
    Going to have to go with Swampert. Blastoise just doesn't have a whole lot of unique qualities. It can rapid spin, but other than that... it's just another plain water type. Swampert is unique among all the ground/water types. It has pretty nice stats and a good movepool, and it's just a fun Pokemon to use. I also prefer Swampert's design overall.

    Blaziken Vs. Charizard.
    I've always loved the Blaziken line. It has an awesome movepool, awesome design, and it's just a Pokemon with possibilities. Charizard just doesn't quite compete. It has a 4x weakness to rock, and it just doesn't have anything that makes it that great. It's stats aren't that great either, it's just kind of... there. I know a lot of people hate/love Charizard, but I'm honestly very indifferent to it in-game. It was cool in the anime, but I've never had any real need to train one. Even as a child, I just wasn't impressed. Blaziken is just... superior even if it has a type disadvantage.
  6. Nyarlathotep

    Nyarlathotep Eldritch Abomination

    I choose the Hoenn starters, mostly because:

    1.) the Treecko line is awesome and Swampert is decent.
    2.) Kanto has Venusaur who happens to be a cool Pokémon, but it also has Charizard and I heavily dislike it.

    To be honest, I don't like neither of these "starter packs" that much, Johto and Sinnoh had much better starters.
  7. Canada

    Canada Banned

    Accidentally voted for the Kanto starters. >__> I meant to vote Hoenn.

    Though I prefer the starters from Johto, Sinnoh and Unova over both of them.
  8. Royal_Qeca

    Royal_Qeca Pokémon Blue

    Since I prefer the Kanto starters I voted Hoenn as if it was you doing it. :p
  9. Placa

    Placa Aspiring Trainer

    I love Hoenn so much, but I have to say, I'm not crazy about Torchic's second or final evolution so it has to go the Kanto starters. I literally can't flaw a single one of them, visually. And that's usually what I go for, so yeah.
  10. mjunior3

    mjunior3 Link Jokers!

    i like charmander the most, but charizard is in a close second with blaziken
  11. Shadow XD001

    Shadow XD001 Silver Soul

    I like the Hoenn starters better overall compared to the Kanto starters. My favorite is probably a tie between Torchic and Treecko, but, for gyms, it's hard to raise Treecko. :( Sceptile has an amazing moveset in later generations though. Blaziken just looks cool and has a good typing, despite the fact that the next 2 fire type starters have a fighting type.... *cough*iffennekinisfire/fighting.....*cough*
  12. mjunior3

    mjunior3 Link Jokers!

    HAHAHA! dude, thats funny. i actually dont mind it, but they need to do another fire/flying, like charizard.
  13. pokesimmo

    pokesimmo Well-Known Member

    The Kanto and Hoenn are probably both my favourite starter Pokemon out of all the regions. Both Mudkip and Charizard are in my dream team, however I do pick the Kanto starters over the Hoenn, simply because I'm not a fan of the evolved forms of the Hoenn starters, and I think it was easier to raise each of the Kanto starters than the Hoenn ones. I found that the Kanto ones were stronger too.
  14. I prefer Hoenn because since I was 7 or 8 I loved it because it seemed soooo..colorful and just felt like Summer everyday to me ;)

    Besides that i prefer May <;;
  15. Kalosian

    Kalosian Never Say Forever

    Overall, I like the Hoenn starters better. I find all of them really useful, both for in-game battles and more serious battling. As for the Kanto starters, I really like Venusaur but I don't like Charizard or Blastoise that much.
  16. Elnava

    Elnava The Successor!

    Ack, why? Why would you make me choose between two sets of my favorite starters? T.T

    Hoenn is so awesome but... Kanto. I'm not a fan of Sceptile. Swampert is really cool and all and Blaziken is a boss. However, Bulbasaur is the only Poison type starter ever. Bulbasaur is super adorable and probably my favorite starter to date. Ivysaur is super cool looking. And Venasaur is... lovable... in a "Imma warty toad lookin thing" kinda way. Charmander is the starter with the most popularity but he dwarves it the least, so that's a con. But then there's the glory of Squirtle. Adorable first form, awesome looking second form and totally badass final evo. Let's not forget the awesomeness that was the Squirtle squad either.
  17. Cutty

    Cutty Forever now

    Tis kind of difficult...

    Kanto starters, I love them all.
    Hoenn starters, I liek only mudkipzz.
    So Kanto trio = Hoenn trio
    But I voted for Hoenn. Mudkipz and Swampert rule.
  18. ☭Azimuth_055☣

    ☭Azimuth_055☣ Thou enraged?

    I think they're both equal because both have their own advantages and disadvantages.

    Even if Swampert and Blaziken are awesome, they are balanced out with qually awesome Charizard and Blastoise.
  19. Archangel Azazel

    Archangel Azazel Fallen Angel

    For water types I'll go with Swampert. Blastoise is not that appealing to me <.> I like Swamperts design.

    Fire starter... I go with the classic Charizard. Mostly because I likey dragons XD Even though Blaziken comes close to it >.>

    And Grass... I can't choose actually, I love Grass types and both Sceptile and Venusaur are my top favorite. P: ;^;
  20. Lorde

    Lorde Banned

    I prefer the Kanto Starters over the Hoenn ones. I mean I think Charizard and Blaziken are practically tied as my favorite fully-evolved Fire Starters, but I prefer Venusaur over Sceptile and Blastoise over Swampert. I'm not sure whether it's because of nostalgia, but that's just how I view the two groups of Pokemon.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page