Here's my take on each girl
Misty: Cute, but a bit volatile. Not digging the short hair, but she could be ok.
Erika: Pretty, but too girly. Not digging the perfume businuess.
Janine: Don't find her that attractive
Sabrina: Hot if she's stopped being the crazy person from the anime.
Lorelei: Sexy Librarian look does not cut it for me.
Agatha: Waaaaaaay too old
Cissy: Kinda cute and good personality.
Whitney: Super cute, but too air-headed and childish. Kinda nice though
Jasmine: Suuuuuuper cute. Shy with great personality.
Clair; Pretty, but kinda *****y in the game. She sucks personality wise.
Karen: Hot, but does not seem to be classy.
Roxanne: Lol sexy teacher. Hot, but not the hottest
Flannery: Super hot, but kinda dumb and forgetful.
Winona: One of the best! Super pretty and kind.
Pheobe: How can you argue with an almost nude Hawaiian girl?
Glacia: Too old.
Gardenia: Awesome midriff and personality. One of the best.
Maylene: Not that cute.
Fantina: Beautiful, but accent and personality get in the way
Candice: One of the best. Looks like a country club girl but acts totally regular
Bertha: Waaaaaaaaaay too old
Cynthia: Super hot, but not so great from a personality standpoint. Could stand to smile a bit more.
Lenora: Not hot
Elesa: Super pretty and seems fairly normal.
Skyla: The best. Awesome mid-riff, pilot is a cool job to have, and seems really easygoing.
Caitlin: Seems pretty, but a bit high maintenance and kind of a diva. Not bad though.
Pike Queen Lucy: Seems too goth and too cold to be hot.
Anabel: Heh, no.
Greta: I like her, good spirit and wise.
Dahlia: Totally underrated. Very revealing outfit and it seems like she'd be fun