1. We have moved to a new forum system. All your posts and data should have transferred over. Welcome, to the new Serebii Forums. Details here
    Dismiss Notice
  2. Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
    Dismiss Notice
  3. If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders
    Dismiss Notice

How do you expect the writers to go about writing the 8th gen?

Discussion in 'Pokémon Animé Discussion' started by Power Up, Apr 20, 2018.

  1. LilligantLewis

    LilligantLewis primarina donna

    How are you contradicting yourself? The fact that it was rushed is EXACTLY WHY we didn't see the rest of that battle? We both agree on the same problem?

    Ratings mean little and less in the modern era of viewing TV but some modern ratings calculations involve not just live but "live + SD" (same day) and "live + 7" which includes everybody who watches an episode within the first week.

    Essentially, ratings are the most important mostly for sports and other live events these days.
     
    mehmeh1 likes this.
  2. mehmeh1

    mehmeh1 #TEAMSOBBLE

    Not to mention that apparently they (IDK if it was OLM or TV Tokyo) said that they didn't really care much about Pokemon's ratings anyways
     
  3. Power Up

    Power Up ...

    What little worth SM has made, is overshadowed by the net major net negative it had on the anime. Going forward, the Galar region should go right back to the roots of Pokémon and cut the losses from SM.

    Refining the best regions of the anime, DP and XY, is the way for the anime to go. Whatever mold SM broke was not worth it all since in my eyes it was a utter failure in mostly all aspects. On a narrative level, SM was unable to create a strong engaging plot nor was it able to make the filler episodes funny or entertaining enough to justify the absurd amount of irrelevance much episodes amounted to with the constant padding and exposition especially apparent in battles. Writing seemed focused on comedy and attempting to craft the most mindless idiocy going into making such episodes. Recent episodes include the utter failure of that league battle with Hau.

    There’s a lack of depth in SM especially regarding their characters. Bar certain episodes and moments, on a episodes to episode basis, the characters are more used to make funny moments and jokes than to advance their respective character arcs, non withstanding that a lot of them don’t have character arcs nor are they strong enough to be satisfactory.

    Not only on a narrative level, but on a technical level, SM failed with SM with directing being utterly subpar, especially in battles.

    Going forward, Galar should try to replicate DP and XY and remove the mediocre filler in both series with DP being especially worse. The strong narrative structure apparent in both series with engaging and interesting character arcs should be refined and improved upon in Galar. Creating flair in characters should also be a priority and using aspects of OS would go a long way as well in making memorable characters. Note, flanderizing characters is not the way to go.

    An example of this done well would be the Mega Evolution Episodes and XYZ, both going long ways to develop strong characters and match that with an engaging plot.
     
    Last edited: Aug 29, 2019
  4. Humor is fine as long it doesn't hurt the plot
     
  5. Power Up

    Power Up ...

    I agree, but there's a difference between the humour in OS and SM. One has actual strong comedic dialogue and the other is a mediocre attempt at using slapstick and idiocy
     
  6. RedR

    RedR Well-Known Member

    i consider pkmn masters the game to be part of the 8th gen, so i hope the anime incorporates stuff from this game. pokemon go gets promo during the anime bumpers, so pokemon masters should too!
     
  7. UltimateNinja

    UltimateNinja ~Ice Cold~

    You mean a dating simulation about Whitney talking about her milkers Miltanks and underage gym leader praising you to be more special than her brother in the SwSh anime?

    Probably to mature for the kids but i would watch that
     
    mehmeh1 likes this.
  8. J.Agera

    J.Agera Well-Known Member

    I am not contracting myself. The league was rushed, but just being rushed dosen't make it a joke.
     
  9. Leonhart

    Leonhart Well-Known Member

    I agree. OS was good at doing a natural kind of humor that didn't feel so contrived, whereas with SM's humor you can almost see the gears turning in the writers' heads. Their efforts are just too transparent and I hope the Galar saga isn't the same as SM when it comes to comedy.
     
  10. AznKei

    AznKei Badass girls saving their boyfriends. XD

    I still think the comedy was edgy in OS and it was more tolerable for the 1990s childrens than now imo. I mean in my hometown, there's a significant difference with the society/culture between 2 decades.
     
    Gageluke and Leonhart like this.
  11. Leonhart

    Leonhart Well-Known Member

    The comedy back then was more violent than the comedy now when you realize how many times the writers got away with having Kasumi physically attack Satoshi back then for instance. I kind of miss things like that though because it was the kind of slapstick comedy that was genuinely funny to me unlike the stuff that we get now that is more reliant on face faults and references to other anime.
     
    MockingJ, Emelie, Gageluke and 2 others like this.
  12. I want the writers to confirm once and for all that beating someone in a battle doesn't automatically make you better trainer/Pokémon overall.

    It's a common misconception whenever someone wins a battle, it means he's stronger than his opponent, or at least is on their level. I believe, just like in real life sports, if you win one out of ten battles against another trainer or Pokémon, you're not stronger overall. It's just anime often doesn't have enough screentime to show those "ten" battles, but it shouldn't be used as a excuse to claim A is stronger than B just because he beat him once.

    I'd like to see it explictly stated in the anime once it happens.
     
    Gageluke and Sham like this.
  13. Bortgreen

    Bortgreen The incredible world of PokéMon!

    Well, in the games you can literally disband evil mega corporations by winning battles
     
    Emelie, Gageluke and maartjeverhoef like this.
  14. AznKei

    AznKei Badass girls saving their boyfriends. XD

    There's a thing called Battle Points (BP) in video games where the player competes against others, and which a higher BP gives you an indicator how good you are, despite not really implemented in the anime. Sure one victory doesn't automatically make you better but many consecutive victories is, unless you got extremely lucky or your opponents were told to take the fall against you.
     
    Gageluke and maartjeverhoef like this.
  15. Leonhart

    Leonhart Well-Known Member

    I dislike that sometimes Satoshi winning a battle is interpreted as him being stronger than his opponent, too. In the case of him defeating Shinji for example, as much as it had to happen to give Satoshi a long-awaited win against his greatest rival, I still think that Shinji was the better trainer since he was better at tactics and training overall. But I doubt that the Galar saga will change much regarding how wins are portrayed since the writers probably don't care about that stuff as long as they follow through with the plot.
     
  16. Blastmaster

    Blastmaster Well-Known Member

    Tbf with Pokemon, it's also a matter of literal strength along with skill. With a lot of Ash's rivals, the idea is that Ash is just outmatched in both of those things (especially strength), so by the end of the rivalry Ash has caught up and proves it by beating them. If you're comparing it to other competitive games, like say Smash Bros for instance, that game is designed to give pretty much every character a similar amount of power. Beating someone 1/10 times in Smash doesn't make you more skilled since you've always been fighting on even grounds strength-wise. With Pokemon, you can't just be skilled, you also have to be strong. With Ash, I think the idea is that he's only truly fighting on even grounds at the League.

    Like for example, Paul was actually much more strategic than Cynthia in their battle. Using positive type matchups as well as baiting her Garchomp into using Giga Impact so it'd be wide open to Torterra. But it didn't matter, since Cynthia was just so much higher in terms of sheer power. If they were fighting on even grounds, Paul should've actually won. But they weren't. It's the same idea with Ash and Paul (and Ash/Gary and Ash/Alain). He's outmatched for most of the rivalry, and needs to catch up so he can finally give them an even battle and win. (Except against Alain lol)
     
    MockingJ and J.Agera like this.
  17. Pikachu Fan Number Nine

    Pikachu Fan Number Nine Don't Mess wit Texas

    Only one of Ash's travel partners over the years has been shown to have a serious health issue. That was Clemont.

    Heavy physical activity tied him out numerous times which is likely indicative of sickle cell.

    If one of Ash's Galar companions has something wrong with them it would be great writing. It would be something for people in physical distress to rally around.
     
  18. JC317

    JC317 Well-Known Member

    I think Clemont is really just more unfit than having a freaking chronic disease.

    If anything, the only friend of Ash's that has a serious health issue is Sophocles. Obesity should not be overlooked; if Sophocles doesn't lose some weight soon, he'll be having lifelong health issues in the future.
     
    anjunajake and Redstar45 like this.
  19. Power Up

    Power Up ...

    So... This new announcement has potential for something very cool
     
    maartjeverhoef and wolf jani like this.
  20. Pokegirl Fan~

    Pokegirl Fan~ Rei Claus

    As of right now that is. I'm still expecting the worst for the new series (the Johto to XY formula with team rocket fillers and Ash losing leagues)
     

Share This Page