The first generation shall never be surpassed.
In sales or in quality? In sales, I think the fourth gen (with the help of HG/SS, I guess) has already surpassed it. In quality... well, that's subjective.
The paragraph following this line begs to disagree.
It's like the Zelda franchise; most of the games were amazing, but none of the ones after it can beat the original idea. EVER.
Subjective. You understand this, yes?
Red, Blue, and Yellow are classics. I doubt any of the new versions such as D/P/Pt, or even B/W, will ever be considered classics.
A large part of what ends up being determined as a classic has to do with... well, how new it is. Red and Blue showed up on the block, became beyond popular, and then the hype slowly died down. None of the games that came after it received so large a reception mostly because, well, people'd seen it already. It's the fad effect, you understand.
In fact, I think Pokemon deserves props for coming out of the end of its fad-phase swinging. It's still going strong, even though it's kept the same basic formula for more than a decade.
But anyhow, the combination of being a sequel and coming after the initial pick-up phase is largely going to be the reason later Pokemon games won't be referred to as classics (you never know, though, with D/P and stuffs being contemporary, after all, people may call them classics yet). They are generally great games... they're just nothing particularly groundbreaking like R/B/Y were when they were introduced.
To summarize: it's not really a matter of comparable quality, it's just the circumstances of when they showed up on the scene.
I personally think GameFreak and Nintendo should call it quits soon; the sheer number of games is overshadowing the originality of the first few gens.
Yes, when you create an ongoing franchise out of what was originally a pair of games, that original pair of games is going to become a smaller and smaller part of that franchise (One fish could be 100% of your total quantity of fish, only to become 50% when you add another).
But I don't see what the problem with that is...
Unless I'm misunderstanding what you're saying here. If so, mind clarifying?
Although I say that, I will buy practically any mainstream Pokemon game that come out. I see it as some sort of civic duty to play all of the games for at least a few hours, considering how much Pokemon has affected my childhood and adolescent life.
Good for you.