2. However, we have no idea of the other semifinalists. For all we know, they could be high-level trainers like Paul or Tyson or Alain.
XY Ash reaches at least the semifinals, but it's impossible to say if he goes further.
Kanto: top 4/8 because he will faint while using Ash Greninja and will be disqualified.
Johto: maybe the top 4 or final round.
Hoenn: I think he would make it to the finals or win it.
Sinnoh: top 8/4 because he'd either lose to Paul or Tobias if the match ups were kept the same.
Unova: he should make it to the finals at least, or most likely win it.
Lol That League was borderline trash and you good and well know it,XY Ash is around the same level as DP Ash and at that point in time he has shown that he is more than capable of winning a League.He made it all the way to the Top 2 in the Kalos League with his XY team so who is stopping him from winning at the Indigo League not named Alain?
He would probably win all of them except Sinnoh. Kanto is tough to tell because he didn't go far but he certainly could dominate with his XY team. I only see him losing to Trollbias because he probably has a team of legendaries, but I think he could take tobias down to his last two pokemon (6-4 loss).
It's almost as if you just quoted my post and blatantly ignored everything in it. Give me an actual argument other than a wild assumption.
I read all that you said and chose this particular one because it's silly to actually think Ash would lose with that XY team,I have every right to assume when it pertains to a weak showing that is the Indigo League.The battles back then were mediocre at best and mega evolutions did not exist around that time frame so don't sit here and tell me there's someone out there that's capable of taking him out because there isn't.
You do realize that 17.5 years ago there were only 150 Pokemon, and production values were way different than today. There wasn't 700+ Pokemon, Mega Evolution, more types, more moves, weather, abilities, etc. You can't even compare.
This is exactly why he would win because of these conditions,this topic is about how his XY team would fair in the other leagues he competed so there's no other way around that.
Even if you did, there is absolutely zero proof on the quality of the three other semifinals at Indigo Plateau. There could have been three Reds for all we know. So don't tell me XY Ash is an automatic winner when the only certainty is he reaches Top 4.
... XY Ash is really overrated in general, so I really don't think it is an automatic win for any of the league.
If Red from Pokemon Origins somehow transported to the animeverse alongside his E4/Champion-killing death squad of Charizard/Lapras/Scyther/Jolteon/Persian/Dodrio and was one of the three other Indigo Plateau semifinalists, then Ash certainly loses. Do you now understand why I said you can't make this assumption about the quality of the other trainers?