• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

I was thinking...

Status
Not open for further replies.
Misty should have stayed for Advanced and have done contests insted of getting May. Misty is girly so she could have done them. Jessie was her rival too in a way so that could have been perfect. I do not get why they had to bring out May who is not as great as Misty to do it. Does any other person agree here?
 
No. May was the new girl for the S/R games. And plus, it was good to see a new girl character become the Co-Star of the show.

And Misty wasn't 'girly', she was more of a tomboy. And besides, I don't see how being 'girly' makes you a more better coordinator.
 
Not another. Sorry but this thread has been done too many times before.

But I think May was a breath of fresh air.
 
No. May was the new girl for the S/R games. And plus, it was good to see a new girl character become the Co-Star of the show.

And Misty wasn't 'girly', she was more of a tomboy.

She was girly! She would think of romance and liked cute things. Go watch that precious kanto season that people here love so much and you will see.
 
she also beat people up and had an incredibly short temper

mistys character was dead after johto keeping here would have ended the anima after advanced
 
She was girly! She would think of romance and liked cute things. Go watch that precious kanto season that people here love so much and you will see.

Hey, so do I, but I'm not totally girly. Yes, Misty had the girl inside her, but her attire was more to the tomboyish side. I'm not saying boys wear shorts that short, but yeah. xD

I've watched the Kanto season so many times, and its one of my favorite seasons, if not, my favorite. I'm just saying, it was one of my favorites, but not just because of Misty. She was great in Kanto, though. But in Johto, she just became stale, which is a good thing they took her off.

Hey, I love Misty, she is one of my favorite characters, and I am sad that she isn't in the main group anymore. But if she was, she would just end up just following Ash around, not having a real role.
 
I think that would be cool, but all Misty's water appeals would get boring, and they would run out of water Pokemon for her at some point.
 
Misty should have stayed for Advanced and have done contests insted of getting May.


So Misty, a dead character should have done Contests instead of May?

HELL NO. May was one of the best written characters in the series, along with Drew and Harely, and the BEST thing the writers ever did for the show is get rid of Misty and replace her with May.

Ash/Misty/Brock completely bombed in Johto, to want that crap to actually continue in AG is pathetic.

I do not get why they had to bring out May who is not as great as Misty to do it. Does any other person agree here?


Misty was like Max, she was just a sidekick with no real point in being there aside from filling out the token female role.

May was a female heroine and introduced Contests.

There's a reason why AG was a complete success, they got rid of the dead weight which was Misty and replaced her with characters with a purpose.

The fact that you're still whining about this long after AG was done is absolutely pathetic.

Misty is GONE, GET OVER IT.
 
Last edited:
Misty would lose, you have to be feminime (May, Jessie) , gay (Harley), flaming(Drew), or highly repulsive(Salary Man, Timmy Grim) to do good in contests.
 
...............

Anyway, Misty was getting old, and Misty wasn't needed in the 3rd Gen and May was a breath a fresh air.

And Misty is too much of a ***** to be a contest person.

and to actually meet the new legends... she would suicide if she heard of kyogre,

anyway,that's my opinion,she would freak out with new pokemon other than cutencool water types,and suicide...that's why it was impossible for misty to fit in hoenn
 
Would contests have made Misty's character more interesting?

Meh, I don't really mind Misty's not doing contests since her personality pretty much left her by the end of Johto. If she couldn't really get her personality back during the Whirl Cup, I doubt she would being a coordinator.

GabsterTJC said:
She was girly! She would think of romance and liked cute things. Go watch that precious kanto season that people here love so much and you will see.

Ah, but May's girly too.

For the record (because I know someone is going to mention this), the reason why I'm not upset that May was the coordinator instead of Misty was because Misty's personality was gone and she wasn't really a major character anyway. Since Misty and Brock weren't really doing much in the cast, it was better for Misty to leave and May to do contests. I don't really mind Misty leaving as much as I do [SPOIL]May[/SPOIL], but, oh well.
 
If people didn't care about Max leaving than why did they care about Misty leaving? They're both characters who never did all that much, so why did people complain about Misty more than Max?
 
If people didn't care about Max leaving than why did they care about Misty leaving? They're both characters who never did all that much, so why did people complain about Misty more than Max?

Because people don't want to ship Max with Ash. :/

Okay, okay. I guess they found Misty to be funny during her Kanto/Orange Islands days and they remember her being the hotheaded, tomboyish redhead. They just don't really want to face the fact that she got boring during Johto. Yes, I really liked Misty, but she just didn't have a place in the show anymore. ...Brock, too, but apparently he's never going to be gone.

Honestly, Misty being a Coordinator wouldn't make sense. She just doesn't have that graceful essence that the other Coordinators seem to have. Besides, she'd only have Water Pokemon and her appeals would get repetitive pretty fast.
 
May was the new girl in the new R/S games, Misty was a gym leader from Kanto. YOU DECIDE.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Well, atleast she'd have the requirement of an Ice attack down.

Oh, yeah. That's an unwritten requirement for all the female coordinators that do/could travel with Ash.

Man, if only Misty had a Lanturn, she could have had Electric attacks for appeals. ::Sigh:: Of course, no Electric types are allowed to be in the same team with Ash and Pikachu.
 
May was the new girl in the new R/S games, Misty was a gym leader from Kanto. YOU DECIDE. Ohandshippingsucksk

I still prefer May over Misty for reasons besides advertising.
 
I find it amusing that people think Misty didn't have enough episodes.

She was here for 280 episodes and 5 movies.

By contrast May was only here for 191 episodes and 4 movies, and Hikari will probably get the same amount of time May got.

Misty got more time on the show than either of the next two girls, and they actually have the nerve to want her back, AGAIN!?

Jesus Christ. 280 episodes of Misty is ENOUGH. The fact that they are so greedy is obnoxious.
 
Hey, they put Lance in Hoenn!! The skys the limit!

Don't mention that, please, you'll get me started on that again...

Misty + contests = end of Pokemon becuase... She didn't have as much variety in her team as May did, I mean, the judges don't want to see a water type again and again, they only want to see one cute water type every once in a while... -_-
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top