J-boogie200
Well-Known Member
We all know that there was a lot of controversy over the idea of Pidgeot being released.
Because so, Pidgeot is sometimes labled as Ash's weakest bird pokemon.
But is that even fair to count it out?
Like Nando and Conway, we don't know what their strengths are because we don't see them often.
If Aaron, an Elite Four Member(who, IMO, wasn't all that impressive) and Pryce, a Gym Leader, can get back Pokemon they haven't seen in ages, what's stopping Ash and Pidgeot.
What gets me is that Ash made a promise to return, and didn't.
It was nice what it was let go for, but right now, we're pretty much aware that every single main character that has been on the show, including Team Rocket, is a good person, or pokemon in Pikachu, Piplup, Meowth's case.
With that said, I love being optimistic, so I still have hope we'll see Pidgeot and Ash again, even if for one battle.
Pidgeot was Ash's first bird pokemon, and his second capture overall. I honestly believe it shouldn't receive the same fate Butterfree did.
I feel the same way about Arbok and Weezing, however some things are better left unsaid.
I must say, when you see Falkner and May's rival Soledad with a Pidgeot and also Drew and Soledad again with a Butterfree, it kinda makes you wonder would the writers pull the same move today.
Please, I don't want this to turn into a flame war. It was rough for me to see Pidgeot never return but I'm dealing with it calmly, lol.
With that said, I won't take it personal if the mods close this.
Because so, Pidgeot is sometimes labled as Ash's weakest bird pokemon.
But is that even fair to count it out?
Like Nando and Conway, we don't know what their strengths are because we don't see them often.
If Aaron, an Elite Four Member(who, IMO, wasn't all that impressive) and Pryce, a Gym Leader, can get back Pokemon they haven't seen in ages, what's stopping Ash and Pidgeot.
What gets me is that Ash made a promise to return, and didn't.
It was nice what it was let go for, but right now, we're pretty much aware that every single main character that has been on the show, including Team Rocket, is a good person, or pokemon in Pikachu, Piplup, Meowth's case.
With that said, I love being optimistic, so I still have hope we'll see Pidgeot and Ash again, even if for one battle.
Pidgeot was Ash's first bird pokemon, and his second capture overall. I honestly believe it shouldn't receive the same fate Butterfree did.
I feel the same way about Arbok and Weezing, however some things are better left unsaid.
I must say, when you see Falkner and May's rival Soledad with a Pidgeot and also Drew and Soledad again with a Butterfree, it kinda makes you wonder would the writers pull the same move today.
Please, I don't want this to turn into a flame war. It was rough for me to see Pidgeot never return but I'm dealing with it calmly, lol.
With that said, I won't take it personal if the mods close this.
Last edited: