Is this stealing??

[shervin]

In the Cerulean Gym, you could fish up pokemon and catch them, wouldn't they, legally belong to Misty?

 

[Comis Patronus]

You can? I don't really think so since it's a gym.

 

[Gazmof]

You could use your rod on the statues in the gyms in R/B/Y. Didn't think you could do it in G/S/C, though.

 

[Ebil Plusle]

it works i tried it b4.

 

[Shadows Follower]

Its not stealing. If it was, you wouldn't be able to use Pokeballs on the Pokemon. Serves her right for putting wild Pokemon in the pool in the first place.

 

[Comis Patronus]

Are you completely sure? Can anyone else make sure(don't have Crystal anymore)?

 

[The Organizer]

It works on my silver, and know it isnt stealing cause it shouldent be able to be caught if its stealing.

 

[Serebii93]

Nice try on the lie people. I've SURFed, RODded, and many other things before, and Misty doesn't have any Pokemon in her Gym. Even if there is, by some miracle of God, it wouldn't be stealing because she's fully responsible for it.

 

[Comis Patronus]

Nice try on the lie people. I've SURFed, RODded, and many other things before, and Misty doesn't have any Pokemon in her Gym. Even if there is, by some miracle of God, it wouldn't be stealing because she's fully responsible for it.

Thanks for making this clear since I couldn't have done it.

 

[[Kingdra]]

I have caught fish in her gym and it is legal

 

[.Person.]

I didn't read all the posts. In silver,gold and crist. you can fist at the E4 in the E1 spot.

 

[Serebii93]

I didn't read all the posts. In silver,gold and crist. you can fist at the E4 in the E1 spot.

Though art SPAMming. We are talking about fishing in Misty's Gym, you idiot!
*Reports*

And no, you cannot catch anything in the E4 either.


EDIT: To all, I am sorry. I have just went to Misty's Gym and I RODded there. I caught only Krabby, though. But, You still cannot fish in the E5 Rooms.

 

[Savage X]

Why would you care if it stealing lol?

It's a game and she is a made up cartoon character.....the game wouldn't let you if it was stealing.

 

[Aptenodytes]

Maybe those are just wild Pokemon resting at her gym . I'd hardly consider it stealing if the creators intentionally put that there...

 

[Full Metal Alchemist]

If it were stealing then Misty would probaly bite your head off. When you get into a battle with one of the fished up Pokémon in the GYM it dose indicate that it is a WILD Pokémon. So in this cause I would say no you aren't stealing from Misty GYM, but you are filling the pages in your Pokédex.

 

[SuperShadow]

It is not stealing if it was then how come I've caught wild pokemon there!

 

[Megg Lavender]

It's not stealing. If it was, Misty would have to tell you, or the text would suddenly say "Stealing Pokemon is bad! Catch only WILD Pokemon!" or something like that. I fished in Misty's gym before, and nothing happened. The water in the gym is probably connected to the river or some nearby water place, so maybe that's why wild Pokemon are there.

 

[Serebii93]

I just went ahead and caught a Krabby there. At first, I never could have believed there were Pokemon in the Water, but all I've seen is a Krabby. *Catches another Krabby so I can breed a happy Krabby out of 'Em*

 

[Gazmof]

Why would you care if it stealing lol?

It's a game and she is a made up cartoon character.....the game wouldn't let you if it was stealing.

"I wasn't kidding when I said pay! Now, you'll pay the ultimate price!!"

Quoted from the Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening when you steal an item from the item shop before getting toasted by lightning.

 

[Dunsparce]

I wonder if anyone has tried it in FR/LG

in RGBY, Lorelei's Room had Water Pokemon. That's what they were talking about. In RGBY, there was only Magikarp for both :/

So this whole topic should be in General Pokemon discussion IMO.