Oh yeah, just mention the skin-deep, surface level stuff and pass that off as substantial. Just ignore the fact that major tracts of XY were retconned like with Ash-Greninja, plagued with bad animation, and just horribly executed in general.
How dishonest can people get? I'd rather have AG level fanservice then what XY got in its supposed " pandering " that actively debased fundamental parts of XY.
I'm sorry, but I don't think you get credit for flopping the execution. I already said that XY was " pandered " to in the sense that they took its body and beat in into a corpse.
The implications of how disastrous that Greninja episode was didn't fully set in with people because many were still on the cope that the retcon was some elaborate plan by the writers to hint at a Greninja reserve return which admittedly held more water after Alain was announced as a member of the PWC.
Ash-Greninja was one of the core pillars of XY/XYZ and incredibly significant. The fact that something like this was done so haphazardly is beyond me.
No, that part makes much more sense when you look at how they transposed it with Lucario. It seems like they've essentially turned the it into something resembling aura, only it doesn't make sense at all with Greninja with the way it does for Lucario.
There's one simple reason why this is all happening: Tomiyasu and the head staff, despise XY, because the XY Fans called them out over being baited, and waited years to get revenge on those accursed fans, and in doing so, effectively dismantling everything that was built up in that series.I actually don't mind Ash vs Alain not happening and never have since it something I've been expecting for a while, but even just accepting that premise, this post has nothing to do with even specifically addressing why Alain's handling/inclusion is so problematic.
From the looks of it:
- Alain is not even going to be interacting with Ash
- There's no G-Max vs MCX
- The battle is going to be incredibly rushed
- Alain's going to get his sh*t pushed in.
If you wanted to be actually respectful to Alain and actually come at his character in the correct way, he would face Steven first since they actually have a dynamic/relationship and have him win there before losing to Alain.
However, everything in your first paragraph is still fundamentally flawed when you look at it from the aspect of arguing for Ash vs Alain. There's nothing at the end of XY precluding JN from an Ash vs Alain rematch, similar to how there was nothing in Paul's character arc(given that it similarly ended) that precluded Journeys from having a battle between him and Ash and showcasing their growth. Ash and Alain promised to battle at the end of XY for f*ck's sake. Alain wanted to battle Ash again after truly earning his Mega Stone and being free from Lysandre's grasp
I can imagine a completely comprehensible narrative rematch in which the writers weren't unimaginable hacks centered around that. It's incredibly simple.
I didn't comment on it earlier, but this weird and dishonestly in how people portray Ash and Alain's relationship and their rivalry is incredibly weird to me.
This series is pandering 101, except it fails miserably at doing so majorly for some reason with XY.
But they're not just content with that, they are actively tricking the XY Fans into thinking that their series isn't the most hated by the head staff and tease things that the XY Fans like, and when we get to the episodes they go: "AH HA! YOU THOUGHT YOU GOT BAITED IN YOUR FAVOURITE SERIES?! HERE'S SOME REAL BAIT FOR YOU!"
Honestly, those last two paragraphs I wrote had more thought put into them, than the entirety of Journeys, and probably gave the staff too much credit.