Kanto or Hoenn.

[Tiisko]

Hoenn and Kanto appealled to me, I can see why FRLG had to recreate the original RBY and couldn't do much except update graphics and the computer interface and yes because they stuck close to the original plot with not many changes (such as Moltres not being encountered at the end of Victory Road) and the added extras of the islands including encountering johto pokemon.

As for Hoenn the map was original, it didn't have to live up to a generational legend of a game and it didn't need to be remastered to appeal to a younger generation and to the original generation that played its predecessor. The pokemon was original, even if the fire pokemon was limited in wild encounters. I've owned all RSE and FrLg and I like playing both games, both of them have their quirks, pros and cons. I must admit I've restarted my hoenn game more times than FrLg, the hoenn region holds my record of the quickest time to complete story mode (at 16hrs, obviously without cheats)

 

[TheUnknown]

Definantly Hoenn as the world feels more dynamic and vast compared to Kanto. They are both great regions however.

 

[Ausgirl]

Hoenn because the climate is more interesting, the rain and thunder was cool and I liked the contests etc. Fingers crossed for a remake.

 

[Archangel Azazel]

Kanto... Hoenn was too frustrating in with too much water )x I liked the climate change but I would go with Kanto since I like its music a bit more and .. less water XP

 

[Earth Wolf-Howl]

Hoenn for sure. It took me years to finally finish off FR, and as such, having started again and again, Kanto feels just boring to me. True, it is a good reigon, but I certainly prefer Hoenn.

 

[Fabulous Ampharos]

Hoenn, as the gym leaders present more of a challenge.

 

[miu miu]

I like both of them but I prefer the Hoehn region because there are more pokemon, contests, and the graphics are nicer. ^^

 

[Cutty]

As much as I like Hoenn, I'm gonna say Kanto as it is classic n has not much water area.

 

[Jaguartail]

Kanto. Despite Hoenn's longer gameplay, the Hoenn region ruined itself by taking away second-gen features such as day and night.

 

[OceanicLanturn]

Hoenn hands down, any day.

Kanto is too small of a region. Compared to sinnoh, unova or hoenn, kanto seems tiny. FRLG was a disappointment since it'd been better to me if they threw in johto as well. But noooo! They just had to add the sevii islands, which practically has no uses except adventure.

Compared to Emerald or even ruby and sapphire, FRLG has little replayability as there's nothing fun. It's sort of back to Gen 1. Honestly, FRLG was a disappointment to me... since I'm not the "nostalgic' person.

To me it's...
Sinnoh > Hoenn > Unova > Johto > Kanto

Yeah, honestly, I'm not in any way satisfied with Kanto.

 

[Nitocrys]

I have to say Hoenn.
I have Sapphire, FR and LG, but Sapphire's the funnest.

 

[Crasher]

I like both, but as Kanto was the first region (both in the franchise and in my Pokemon experience) I'll go with that.

 

[~EternalDarkness~]

I'm going with Kanto, mostly because Firered was my first game. Though Hoenn was memorable in its own right. Only downside is the amount of water...

 

[Swampert is my Homeboy]

Hoenn, because I liked how the region was more exotic and I liked the Pokemon in it better.

 

[Tuskie Tyrant Yoko Kurama]

Hoenn for me. But, I've always felt like it's hot there. :/

 

[Deadrose]

Kanto is my third favorite region, but I wasn't really a fan of Hoenn. Although, Hoenn is better than Sinnoh. A remake of R/S/E might make Hoenn more enjoyable.

 

[Plus side down side]

I'm a devoted Hoenn fan. It was my favorite region and my favorite batch of Pokemon. Kanto was awesome, but there is no competition which one is my favorite.

 

[MetalSonic]

I like Hoenn. The whole atmosphere and music that accompanied the region made it really memorable. Idk, Kanto was alright but it just didn't have all that much going for it in those departments.

 

[Durbe]

Hoenn. I love the climate for some odd reasons. Also, the towns/cities were much more interesting compared to Kanto.
I do like Kanto as well, but it's just... Not too well compared to Hoenn, imo.

 

[36squid]

I feel hoenn is better due to the diversity