All of it.
That's not love for all the 649!!!
Most of the Smogon hate comes from people that don't get that there's a difference between the in-game side of pokemon (where you can sweep anything when you're 10 levels higher) and competitive pokemon (where the pokemon are at the same level and you face a human opponent, not some computer that will never switch). It's right in their mission statement.
What Smogon says hasn't had an effect on me for using pokemon like Luxray, Ursaring, Whiscash (MVP of my recent Platinum playthrough), Swana, Cacturne, Manectric, Wailord, and Crustle on my playthroughs. But my competitive teams? Yes I will look for better pokemon than something cute or gimmicky. I try not to bring a knife to a gun fight.
many pokemon don't get love just because they aren't "good for competitive play".
I agree with this, but I personally don't go with the idea. Most of the pokemon I love aren't good for competitive play, and a lot of the ones that are (Conkeldurr, Garchomp, Magmortar, and a lot of legendaries to name a few) are some of the ones I hate more than any others. I used a Cacturne in my Emerald team, a pokemon that I've never seen in anyone else's team, and she is amazing!
Yes. Just like Arcanine or Bibarel.
never see them.
Bibarels a good baton passer, if you ask