Luigi or Tails?

[Moneyy]

Tails voice and actions annoy me, so I choose Luigi. Luigi's Mansion was also a great game.

 

[MissingNoHunter]

Tails has his own personality. Luigi is like a second Mario.

Nah, Luigi's actually got a personality, while Mario has basically no dialogue and has other characters speak for him.
Luigi has a personality, being quirky, although sometimes cowardly. Not the most HEROIC personality...but at least it exists...
Sorry, just wanted to call you on that.

 

[Weez1990]

Luigi. If you hate him you have no heart.

I like Tails too, just not modern gen Tails, only 90s era Tails.

Luigi IS Mario's younger brother.

He is Mario's younger twin brother.

 

[YaDunGoofed]

Weegee.
;D

 

[FireTheAbsolLord]

Tails. He's a 6 year old fox that can fly by using his tails. Tell me that is not awesome. He may be annoying in some games, but what about the games where he isn't? He's pretty awesome. And he's also my favorite Sonic character, while Bowser/Yoshi are my favorite Mario characters...so it's no surprise that I chose him over Luigi, really.

 

[TicoPokemonMaster]

Luigi. Because he is Mario's younger twin brother.

Fixed just for you

 

[Gelatino95]

I like 'em both, but Luigi wins by a landslide. He's just so goofy and he's far superior to Mario, mostly because Mario never says anything.

 

[Paradoxe]

Only the best wingman would travel through a haunted mansion to save his bro. Did Tails do that? I don't think so.

 

[Primavera]

Tails is cute as heck. So that's why I picked him. =P

 

[Vandslaux]

I like Luigi more, but he was always a coward in Mario and Luigi Bowser's Inside Story..

Tails has a good voice, and he (AKA Alibaba) was pretty good in Sonic and the Secret Rings.

Also I haven't played Luigi's Mansion, but I've played the level with the mansion in SMG1, and doesn't Mario save Luigi, not vice versa?

 

[Bolt the Cat]

Tails. Luigi is little more than a Mario recolor with almost no character (not that Mario has much either, but I digress). Plus Tails can fly. And build complex machinery. And as of late 2010, not sound like a 5 year old girl.

 

[Eternal Draconic]

Luigi.
Luigi. Luigi.
Luigi. Luigi. Luigi.
Luigi. Luigi. Luigi. Luigi.

Nuff said. LUIGI

 

[JacobGRocks]

Luigi = Mario Recolor

Therefore, tails is better.

 

[Rezzo]

Luigi was a Mario recolour, but since they hit Super Mario World, he does have a different build compared to Mario. And what were you guys expecting? He is Mario's twin brother.

Wait, why am I defending the character I didn't vote for

 

[Vipsoccermaster]

Tails. He's a 6 year old fox that can fly by using his tails. Tell me that is not awesome. He may be annoying in some games, but what about the games where he isn't? He's pretty awesome. And he's also my favorite Sonic character, while Bowser/Yoshi are my favorite Mario characters...so it's no surprise that I chose him over Luigi, really.

He's actually 8 years old. He's also my favorite Sonic character, too.

 

[Venomfang]

Luigi. Tails is just annoying.

 

[Moneyy]

Luigi = Mario Recolor

Therefore, tails is better.

Not in any of the games since the GC. He is taller and slightly thinner.

 

[MonkeyX]

Luigi is so much better. Tails sounds like a girl and hes actually a freaky mutant squirrel if you know where that comes from you get a cookie.

 

[Doodles]

Rofl, so sence Nintendo bought Sega, Tails is now indirectly a Nintendo character and can therefore be discussed here?

 

[gardevoir rocks]

Luigi! He isn't just a sidekick to me, no, he's a hero who's kinda overshadowed by Mario, but then Mario is cool too. Anyway, Luigi's Mansion 2 should help with that (can't wait for it to come out!) And he's the best character in Mario Kart DS at the start, his vacuum kart is sooo fast! Tails is more of a side character who gives you things to do from my knowledge, although I don't play sonic very often. Still he has a pretty girly voice, hehe.