• Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Maxie, How he began!

Naetoru & Stitch

Sending out an S.O.S
The title of my new story. It's about Maxie, but yonnger. Enjoy. I will have more, but this a preview to see how people would like it! EDITED!!!!!! #2<----Times I edtited

I removed the seconed Proluge about PBF Acadamy and I will explain it when the time comes. CHAPTER 1 IS UP ON ANOTHER POST, AND SO WILL OTHER CHAPTERS!!!

Post your Opinons!
___________________________________________________





Prologue


Maxie is a young guy who goes to school at Rubustro. He is twelve, a very good trainer,and is about to go to the Pokemon Battle Frontier (PBF) with his Pokemon: Combusken. Maxie enjoys working with Combusken, and have become great partners. His rival, Archie, is a pain against Maxie, and had already been requested go to the academy with his water Pokemon. If a trainer in Rubustro wishes to go to the academy, they must request a match with the Teacher and Gym Leader, Roxanne, in Gym battle for permission to go by beating her, and obtain the first badge. Roxanne’s specialty is rock type Pokemon, so Archie’s water Pokemon gave him a huge advantage. Hopefully, Maxie can go to PBF Academy.
 
Last edited:
N

Neko

Guest
Though it's a prologue, it could use more description... maybe some people don't know what Archie or Maxie look like. Maybe someone doesn't know what a Combusken is. You must inform the reader on some of these things. And also,

Maxie, and young guy who goes to school at Rubustro.

It should be: Maxie is a young guy who goes to school at Rustburo.

But I'm not gonna rate anymore until you post another chapter. If you're planning to have a good story, please look over it, add or take away things that do or do not need to be there.
 
Heya!

Whoo, I like the concept. It's not often that you get to see how the Team Leaders started out.

Maxie enjoys working with Combusken, and have become great partners.

I liked that bit! It makes it sound like Maxie has actually put time and effort into training his Combusken - and not just in the battle arena but in the work out and learning departments as well? ^^ That would be fun to see... a trainer actually putting WORK into teaching their pokemon how to use their moves better and keep fit...

Unfortunately, I didn't quite understand the second prologue. PBF has two sets of people to go through... to go through what? Where do Ruby, Sapphire and Emerald come in? Are they people or groups or what? Who all had the same rank? What do you choose by which Legendary you pick? I suggest you revise this section so you spoon feed the meaning to your readers because what you've got at the moment is moving very fast through important concepts and it's hard to keep up. Explain yourself slowly and simply so that everyone can follow along. ^^

And now to a few formatting issues to clear up. First of all, you're still using numbers in place of words. I suggest you use the actual words because taking short cuts makes it look like you've not put a lot of effort into writing - and that can be a big turn off to your readers. The same 'no short cuts' idea extends to using pretty much ANY symbol in place of words - so the '='s are undesirable as well. Take the time to explain in words what you mean. Although using symbols makes your job as the author easier, it also makes your work look less professional and more hurried... things that can turn readers away. You HAVE put effort into this - don't give your readers the wrong impression!

Anyway, the start you've got here is original and has a lot of potential - put it to good use! With perseverence and patience, this story could really work out. My biggest bit of advice is to take your time. Slow down and explain to your readers what you're meaning so that you're sure they'll understand. And don't rush through the writing process so you end up with a motley assortment of words, symbols and numbers. As they say (and please don't shoot me for quoting this) "If something's worth doing, it's worth doing well". If you really want to write this story, write it properly or you'll be undoing all the positives this has with pointless and easily avoided negatives. I hope this helps. Good luck and fun to you!

Piney.
;204;;324;
 

Guitar dude bill

It's here, it's near
Maxie, and young guy who goes to school at Rubustro.
That sentence makes no sense. It could be "Maxie is a young guy who goes to Rustboro." Or "Maxie and young Guy go to school at Rustboro." Or "Maxie, a young guy goes to school at Rustboro."

They don't all have the same meaning. But they all make sense unlike your original sentence. And generally when it makes no sense it confuses your readers and horribly intterupts with the flow.

And there ain't never a connective after a comma. Commas are used as substitute for connectives, using a connective after a comma is an abuse of grammar.

He is 12, and is a very good trainer.
Again, you did the grammar mistake I just pointed out.

Abbreviating numbers with digits (12 instead of twelve, 4 instead of four) is a big NO-NO. Always spell it out in full. Use no abbreviations, except mr, dr, mrs but only if you have a surname afterwards

Why was he a good trainer. Was he strategic? Did he have a powerful pokemon?

He is about to go to the Pokemon Battle Frontier (PBF) with his Pokemon, Combusken.
You began the previous sentence with the word 'he'. Always come up with a different word to begin a sentence.

Why is he going to the Pokemon Battle frontier? What is the Pokemon Battle Frontier? Explain, we don't all know.

You don't need to tell us that it's more well know as PBF. That part was pointless, cut it.

Replace the comma with a colon :)). It's a colon because you're saying what his pokemon was. When you say something about a place, a phrase, then you say what it is; it is a colon.

What is a Combusken? What do they look like. We know, but you still need to describe.

How did he get his Combusken? Who gave it to him? More detail.

Maxie enjoys working with Combusken, and have become great partners.
Why does he enjoy working with Combusken? How have they become great partners? More detail

Replace the colon with a hyphen (-). Because your kinda pausing, so it's a hyphen.

His rival, Archie, is a pain against Maxie, and had already been requested go to the academy with his water Pokemon.
Why are they rivals? Why is he a pain? Against him in what? Why has he been requested to go to the academy?

The part after the third comma can make sense without the previous set of words, should be a full stop (.).

Roxanne’s specialty is rock type Pokemon, so Archie’s water Pokemon gave him a huge advantage.
Why did that make Archie's water have a big advantage? We know, but you still need to explain to us.

Comma should be replaced with semi-colon (;) - as it is not substituting a connective. It is being used to just quickly explain a last thing in the sentence.

PBF Academy (Pokemon Battle Frontier) had 2 sets of people to go through. Ruby, Sapphire, and Emerald, and no one was the best.
We already know that it's pokemon battle frontier. No need to explain it again.

Like I mentioned earlier - don't abbreviate your numbers like that.

You mentioned three and you say there are two? o_0

First full stop should be a colon. Reason: you said something, then you said what it was.

Why was no one the best? More detail.

Overall - the concept and plot is good. But it has an insane lack of detail. And a few grammar problems. Just add more detail and it should be fine

Overall rating: 5/10
 

Naetoru & Stitch

Sending out an S.O.S
My battel frontier is the same as the game, but as 2 sets of classes, or "Dormes" as people like to say. I'll edit the proluge a little, but it's just a proluge, and I understand everything you all are saying. The thing i'm a little concered about is that this isn't going anywhere else and will stay here on Serebii, and I made FOR the Serebii website, so I'm not going to become strict when it comes to what a Combusken, and what Maxie, Archie, etc. look like. When I release my first chapter. (Which should be soon) Then you can worry majorly about errors. I understand most of your comments and I know you mean well, but this is my first story, And I will learn as I go. Also, I'm might recored the errors so may I ask.....

Read previous post first. Don't say something about a suggestion if somebody had already said it. It also makes me feel bad when it's said more then onece. With the 2 dormes, yet there's Ruby, Sapphire, and Emerald, I had Emerald planned, but later got rid of it.
Anyways, I will try to do better, but please don't push me becuse I got a few editors. PM me if you would like to be one. I already have one and I wil put your username in my Signature. Thanks Much for the information and look for my editied Proluge(s).

Master of Light

BTW, If you wrote a story, send me a messege with PM if it's in your sig, and if not, send me the link to your story. Just to get better ideas. Thanks!

Here is my first chapter.



Chapter 1: Gym Challenge



Maxie studies hard in his classes, trying to build a strategy to beat Roxanne. He trained Combusken to do attacks, and he studied battles. After several days, or even weeks, he would battle Roxanne for his permission to PBF Academy, and his first badge, which means “Beginner” in the Academy. If you got in without a badge some how, (even though it’s impossible) you would be at a lower class that beginner. He must obtain the Stone Badge. Maxie sent a request note to the office to challenge Roxanne.

The next day, during battle time, (A time where you must battle opponents, or engage into an important battle) Maxie was sent to the gym arena to battle Roxanne. She stood there waiting for Maxie to enter and take his spot.
“Are you Maxie, requesting a challenge to gain entrance to PBF?” she said.
Maxie said nervously, “Ye… Yes…Ma’am.”
Roxanne gave Maxie one bit of advice, “Don’t be nervous, you should always be exited and truthful to be in a battle, especially since YOU challenged me. Let’s go.”
Maxie took the advice, and became proud and said, “All right”

Battle: Maxie vs. Roxanne

Roxanne sent out a Geodude, a rock-type Pokemon, while Maxie sent out his fire-type Pokemon, Combusken.
“Okay Geodude, start off with tackle!” commanded Roxanne.
Maxie said automatically, “Dodge Combusken!”
Combusken quickly jumped to the right, and Geodude just missed by an inch.
“Go Combusken, use Fire Blast!” said Maxie.
Combusken used Fire Blast in a long strip of fire as it came toward Geodude. As it hit Geodude without even trying to dodge, the fire blasted away from Geodude, and cooled off, canceling the attack.
“No!” cried Maxie, “The attack didn’t affect Geodude.
Roxanne commanded, “Geodude, use…. Rock Tomb!”
Maxie gasped, that was one of the most powerful rock attacks that Roxanne used. There was no chance of Combusken escaping the attack.
“Stop! I surrender! Stop your attack!” Maxie begged.
“Geodude, cancel command.” Said Roxanne immediately. “Not to be mean, but you have to defeat me in order to get to the academy. Students there are stronger then me. Practice up some more and you will get there. I promise that you will, I trust you, but my trust won’t get you there. Class will start soon. You should get to your next class. Bye”

Later that day…

Maxie was lying on top of his bed, thinking about his battle. Having a flash back he asked him self, “What did I do wrong. Combusken’s fire blast didn’t affect Geodude. That is a very powerful attack.” Maxie got up, and got a handbook from his desk, and started reading it. It shows the average attacks a certain Pokemon could learn, and he looked up Combusken. Searching, he found 3 attacks that could also be bought as a TM. He planned to go to the Devon Corporation the next day.

Let me see your opions and edting problems!
 
Last edited:

Naetoru & Stitch

Sending out an S.O.S
Everyone, including editors, this is the end of Chapter 1 if you didn't know. I'm already on the long chaper 2, so post your opions and edting!

Also, do you want me to post it on the bored, or make it an attachment? Which would be better for the people to read it???
 
Master of Light said:
Chapter 1: Gym Challenge



Maxie studies hard in his classes, trying to build a strategy to beat Roxanne. (I'd expand on this section - perhaps show the strategies he's been debating between? It would help to demonstrate the way Maxie's battling mind works and revealing character's thoughts can be a powerful way to open their personality up to the reader.) He trained Combusken to do attacks, and he studied battles (Again, I'd expand on this. Mebbe give examples of the attacks and the way he trained Combusken to perform them. Same with the battles. Which battles did he study (through books/videos/lectures?) and what did he gain from studying them? These are big points and can really be fleshed out. Whilst I like the quick pace you've got here, you can afford to slow down a bit.). After several days, or even weeks (Mmm, I'd reword this - it's a bit awkward. Perhaps 'Sometime soon, be it weeks or days from now'. For some reason, what you've got now is seeming like a bit of a list of things to do. 'Blah happened, and after that, blah...'. I feel that highlighting the uncertainty here would help - it makes his future that little bit less assured - and thus a little bit more real.), he would battle Roxanne for his permission to PBF Academy, and his first badge, which means “Beginner” in the Academy. If you got in without a badge some how, (even though it’s impossible) you would be at a lower class that beginner (If it's impossible to get in without a badge, how come there's procedures for people who don't have badges? Mebbe just delete this sentence as the logic of it is a bit tangled.). He must obtain the Stone Badge. Maxie sent a request note to the office to challenge Roxanne (I thought he wanted to battle after he'd had a bit more time to prepare? If time has passed, then I suggest you show it more clearly. This is in the same paragraph as where you said he would battle her in the future and thus it seems that it's in the same day/timeframe that Maxie was wanting the extra time. My advice is to separate this - perhaps into another paragraph where you show how Maxie has improved over time and now feels ready to make his challenge.).

The next day, during battle time, (A time where you must battle opponents, or engage into an important battle) (I'd avoid using brackets to explain things. It kinda rushes the story a bit. Try getting rid of the brackets and then taking the time in a proper paragraph to explain a bit about what 'battle time' is.) Maxie was sent to the gym arena to battle Roxanne. She stood there waiting for Maxie to enter and take his spot After reading through your story before editing, I can see how 'in control' you shape Roxanne to be. As such, perhaps you could make this section a bit more dramatic and intimidating? Not necessary, but it would add a bit of flare...).
“Are you, Maxie, requesting a challenge to gain entrance to PBF? (I wouldn't use the abbreviation here - this is a formal battle challenge, the results of which will affect legal/administrative requirements. In a way, it's like filling in an official form - and those things tend to use full names for things.)” she said.
Maxie said nervously, “Ye… Yes…Ma’am.”
Roxanne gave Maxie one bit of advice, “Don’t be nervous, you should always be excited and truthful ('truthful'? That doesn't fit. And although 'excited' works, I'd suspect that an adult trainer would advise a newbie to be confident in battle and 'true to their heart' when they decide if they will battle or not. Or something to that effect.)to be in a battle, especially since YOU challenged me. Let’s go.” (Despite the 'excited' and 'truthful' bit, I like this part. ^^ It's realistic and satisfying to see the predictably nervous trainer get told to get over it.)
Maxie took the advice, and became proud and said, “All right”

Battle: Maxie vs. Roxanne (Uh, this is bit annoys me - it's dividing the story up into little sections where it might just flow smoothly. It's also distracting your readers from the actual content. I'd cut it and simply use paragraphs.)

Roxanne sent out a Geodude, a rock-type Pokemon, while Maxie sent out his fire-type Pokemon (I wouldn't use 'a rock-type Pokemon' followed by 'fire-type Pokemon'. While there's a lot to be said for repetition, it doesn't belong here. Just 'sent out his fire-type' will do. And since you've already introduced his Combusken, you could probably just have 'while Maxie sent out Combusken'.), Combusken.
“Okay, Geodude, start off with tackle!” commanded Roxanne (I don't like 'commanded' here. It does convey the meaning and help to show Roxanne's confidence, but it's too long. If you're going to make it long, I recommend making it properly long and describing way she commanded it - with power and confidence or whatever you pick.).
Maxie said, automatically (Since the comma has to go there (I think), I'd make it 'Automatically, Maxie said'.), “Dodge, Combusken!”
Combusken quickly jumped to the right, and Geodude just missed by an inch.
“Go, Combusken, use Fire Blast!” said Maxie.
Combusken used Fire Blast in a long strip of fire as it came toward Geodude (As Combusken came towards Geodude or as the fire came towards Geodude? Clarify here.). As it hit Geodude without even trying to dodge, the fire blasted away from Geodude, and cooled off, canceling the attack. (Again, jumping in the use of 'it'. Be very clear about what you're meaning here - it's a dramatic point in the story so you don't want your readers confused.)
“No!” cried Maxie, “The attack didn’t affect Geodude.” (And I'd advise putting either an exclamation mark after 'Geodude' instead of a full stop (to make it sounds more forceful) or putting '...' after 'Geodude' to make it sound like Maxie simply trailed off.)
Roxanne commanded, “Geodude, use…. Rock Tomb!”
Maxie gasped - ('-' or '...' cause I don't think a comma belongs here. Either complete the sentence with a full stop or make it trail properly into the next one.) that was one of the most powerful rock attacks that Roxanne used. There was no chance of Combusken escaping the attack. (Aren't Combusken's incredibly fast compared to Geodude's? If there was time for Maxie to gasp and realise that Combusken couldn't escape and time for Roxanne to then call off the attack, surely Combusken could have dodged in that time?)
“Stop! I surrender! Stop your attack!” Maxie begged.
“Geodude, cancel command,said Roxanne immediately. “Not to be mean, but you have to defeat me in order to get to the academy. Students there are stronger then me. Practice up some more and you will get there. I promise that you will, I trust you, but my trust won’t get you there (Again, I don't think that 'trust' is quite the right word here. 'Believe in' sounds cornier, but it fits better. Eh, whatever you pick, I suggest you change it.). Class will start soon. You should get to your next class. Bye. (Since Roxanne's so fond of formal language (ie: 'cancel command' instead of 'stop' or 'hold it' or something) I more imagine her saying 'Goodbye instead of simply 'bye. It's just a bit more in keeping with her character and mannerisms.)

Later that day…

Maxie was lying on top of his bed, thinking about his battle. Having a flash back he asked himself, “What did I do wrong? Combusken’s fire blast didn’t affect Geodude. That is a very powerful attack. Whoah, awkward wording. 'That is a very powerful attack' doesn't sound natural.. it's too formal. Maxie's just thinking to himself - surely he thinks casually?)

Maxie got up, and got a handbook from his desk, and started reading it. It shows the average attacks a certain Pokemon could learn, and he looked up Combusken. Searching, he found 3 (As always, use words instead of numbers. 'three', not '3'.) attacks that could also be bought as a TM. He planned to go to the Devon Corporation the next day. (Now here's a VERY tasty serve of originality. In my experience, it's rare that TMs are used at all in stories... and I can't remember ever coming across their use to help make a come-back after losing - EXTEMELY well done here. This is fresh and interesting... though how's Maxie gonna be able to afford TMs? Eh, find out next chappie, I suppose.)

That helps, I hope. Just so you know, this should really be done BEFORE a chapter is posted - otherwise, there's not much point to having editors.

As for the content of this chapter, I was impressed that you had the maturity to let your character lose on the first try. I'm also impressed with the novelty of Maxie's solution to Combusken's loss to Geodude. TMs are so often ignored by writers - it's fun and refreshing to see someone use them! (Though I wonder if Maxie realises that Combuskens learn Double Kick (a Fighting move and thus super effective against Rock types) as soon as they reach the Combusken stage?)

Just pay a bit more attention to how your characters react and behave. Speaking is a big part of a person's character - it reflects their manner and feelings, so be sure to keep that in character. If people talk formally, keep them talking that way (unless to show a disturbance in their character) and the same goes for casual (although, obviously, situation will have an impact on this).

With next chapter, just post it as you've done chapter one. It's easier and what people are used to. (And you might wanna send it to your editors before putting it up so you don't get reviews that are simply corrections.)

PM if you've got any questions. ^^ Good luck and fun to you!

Piney.
;204;;324;
 
Top