• Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Minorities in Pokemon?

Status
Not open for further replies.
F

Finite Joy

Guest
Is it just me, or has anyone else noticed its only white people inhabiting Kanto, Orre, Johto, and Hoenn? This goes for the anime and the games. Always thought that was kind of weird.

No wonder people have labelled Pokemon as unwittingly being racist, considering that the only attempt to represent another cultural group besides whites was Jynx...
 

CyberCubed

Yeah, ok!
The show and game are made for a Japanese audience. The characters are all "really" supossed to be Japanese, hence not a lot of different racial groups.
 

absol attacker

go, my army!
the only thing i don't get is the eyes. many anime character eyes are too large to be human eyes, let alone Asian. and that's ignoring the hair and female assets.
 

Yamato-san

I own the 5th gen
you gotta remember that Japan is a pretty homogenous. The native population (which makes up a huge percentage) is all asians with black hair. I hear that the reason anime has all these unnatural hair colors and such is because artists want to express variety in their work that they can't get in real life, thus such a style has become a norm (or it could be because the artists are reflecting the people who dye their hair, also to seem independant and varied.... don't know which became popular first). As for the caucasian skin, it's either because the anime style descended from early American cartoons, or as I've heard someone on the thread mention, it's because that skin color's easy to mix (and thus cost-effective) in paints, and even with computer technology now, that has become a norm. Either way, anime tends to showcase characters as they are, not focusing on such trivial issues as their race (their race usually being considered a fictional varient of Japanese people despite looking caucasian). The few times race variety does become an issue in anime is when the storyline involves foreigners (like with war stories and their foreign affairs), the storyline takes place in America or some country with more cultural variety, or on an even rarer occasion, a black foreigner's plopped in as a background character in order to be realistic.
 

PDL

disenchanted
the reason why anime characters generally have huge eyes is because huge eyes are some of the characteristics that people consider "cute" (thus why babies, human or animal are considered adorable by people)

that, and Disney used to use it on their characters, early Japanese animators merely copied the style for their characters...
 
Z

ZadokRox

Guest
I would like to see some minorities in the Pokemon games, just as long as they don't follow negative stereotypes.
 

Amadeus

Landshark
I remember reading that Betty Boop was a big influence for the creator of Astro boy- a likely origin of the trend, as he's the Freud of anime. I mean... as an innovator, not a different way...

I don't really think of their world as ours. Maybe the lack of other apparent races would be that because of Pokemon, they've never been isolated. Surf makes it to where oceans are no boundary, and mountains can be transversed with pokemon with Fly and the like. The only reason humans in our world have different races is isolation from each other, fostering the chance for development of distinct characteristics.
 

zonic the hedgehog

HUR HUR USER TITLE
In the anime, I believe they showed a Mexican guy that had a Ludicolo (or maybe he just acted like that... oO), and Juan (a.k.a. Adan)
is also Hispanic. Now I know someone is going to say, "NO HE'S NOT!"

Umm, yes he is. Adan and Juan are both Hispanic names given to people with Hispanic origin. Not to mention he looks Hispanic (you don't have to have dark skin to be Hispanic).

Oh, and I believe they showed a black person who had a hitmonlee during the Hoenn League as well.
 

Cipher

Nothing to be done
The large eyes in anime are there for two reasons.

1) Due to the influence early American cartoons.

2) Because eyes represent a person's nature. Good characters tend to have larger eyes, so you can relate to them more, they seem more approachable. More often than not evil characters have small squinty eyes or something to cover them, like glasses, showing that they are hiding who they really are, or that we don't know much about them.
 

Gravy

Contaminated KFC
zonic the hedgehog said:

Oh, and I believe they showed a black person who had a hitmonlee during the Hoenn League as well.
Jump? He wasn't black, but he looked like he should have been.
 

Pokemaníaco Desesperado

Normal Coordinator
zonic the hedgehog said:
In the anime, I believe they showed a Mexican guy that had a Ludicolo (or maybe he just acted like that... oO), and Juan (a.k.a. Adan)
is also Hispanic. Now I know someone is going to say, "NO HE'S NOT!"

Umm, yes he is. Adan and Juan are both Hispanic names given to people with Hispanic origin. Not to mention he looks Hispanic (you don't have to have dark skin to be Hispanic).

Oh, and I believe they showed a black person who had a hitmonlee during the Hoenn League as well.
And don't forget Phoebe and that nurse Joy at Orange islands.
 
Z

ZadokRox

Guest
That one Nurse Joy (the one that can paddle at warp speed) wasn't a Latina. Just tanned from be out and about so much (the other Nurse Joys normally stay indoors, thus their pale complexion).
 

Auraninja

I withdraw reluctantly.
Finite Joy said:
Is it just me, or has anyone else noticed its only white people inhabiting Kanto, Orre, Johto, and Hoenn? This goes for the anime and the games. Always thought that was kind of weird.

No wonder people have labelled Pokemon as unwittingly being racist, considering that the only attempt to represent another cultural group besides whites was Jynx...

I'm afraid Jynx isn't black, and if we have black people in the game, CBW will get all upset.
Oddly enough, there were people looking like Mr. T in Earthbound.

Sorry about the cut off.

Edit: Jynx, I believe, is more like an ice witch.
 
Last edited:

Naraku_Diabolos

DNC20/NIN10
Amadeus said:
I don't really think of their world as ours. Maybe the lack of other apparent races would be that because of Pokemon, they've never been isolated. Surf makes it to where oceans are no boundary, and mountains can be transversed with pokemon with Fly and the like. The only reason humans in our world have different races is isolation from each other, fostering the chance for development of distinct characteristics.

That's what I was thinking. Don't forget that DBZ had a lot of people of different backgrounds too.

I didn't hear anyone comment on Brock, yet lol ;) Brock could be Indian or Hispanic, or Chinese due to his eyes looking as if they're closed shut.
 

Pokemaníaco Desesperado

Normal Coordinator
ZadokRox said:
That one Nurse Joy (the one that can paddle at warp speed) wasn't a Latina. Just tanned from be out and about so much (the other Nurse Joys normally stay indoors, thus their pale complexion).
CyberCubed said:
Isn't Pheobe supossed to be Hawaiian or something?
I meant that they are from different races than white people, just that ^_^U
 

Saxx

< Owns You.
I was watching Pokemon:the first movie today and when mewtwo "picks up" all the Tauros one of the Rocket grunts throwing balls is black

Saxx
 
C

Clockwork Ninja

Guest
Naraku_Diabolos said:
I didn't hear anyone comment on Brock, yet lol ;) Brock could be Indian or Hispanic, or Chinese due to his eyes looking as if they're closed shut.

... well his Dad looks Chinese and his Mum looks Japanese (she doesn't have those closed eyes) so I guess Brock is Chinese and Japanese.
 

Charizard_Fire_God

*tiwts widdw head*
True, tch, but then again that's tha case with just 'bout every anime. o.=.O
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top