1. We have moved to a new forum system. All your posts and data should have transferred over. Welcome, to the new Serebii Forums. Details here
    Dismiss Notice
  2. We have received legal notice about the sharing of certain images for Pokémon Sword & Shield. Due to this, we have a new rule. If you post said images, you will be removed from the forums until 15:00 UTC on November 14th 2019. We have also killed the leak discussion threads for the time being. Thank you for your patience during this. If you have any queries, use the contact form
  3. Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
    Dismiss Notice
  4. If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders
    Dismiss Notice

Most Polarizing Character in Anime

Discussion in 'Alternate Animé & Manga Discussion' started by Draco Malfoy, Nov 17, 2010.

?

Most Polarizing Character in Anime (from this list)

  1. Haruhi Suzumiya (Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya)

    4.8%
  2. Light Yagami (Death Note)

    61.9%
  3. Flay Allster (Gundam SEED)

    9.5%
  4. Shinn Asuka (Gundam SEED Destiny)

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  5. Sekai Saionji (School Days)

    9.5%
  6. Lucy (Elfen Lied)

    4.8%
  7. Shinji Ikari (Neon Genesis Evangelion)

    9.5%
  8. Treize Khushrenda (Gundam Wing)

    4.8%
  9. Sasuke Uchiha (Naruto)

    38.1%
  10. Suzaku Kururugi (Code Geass)

    14.3%
Multiple votes are allowed.
  1. Draco Malfoy

    Draco Malfoy -REaction

    By polarizing character, I mean a character who doesn't necessarily create a lot of hate and love but rather creates a plethora of VASTLY diverging, alternative character interpretations. So not Naruto (some may love him, some may hate him, but most of us agree that he is a homoerotic airhead with hidden depths) but more among the lines of Shinji Ikari (a courageous Chaste Hero who genuinely cares about humanity but is too wracked with psychological trauma to do anything about it V.S. a selfish, closet-pervert who is apathetic and/or cowardly).

    Actually, Shinji is not that great an example. Light Yagami or Flay Allster might be better examples. >.>;;

    I've created a poll with the ones I can think of right now, but I probably forgot many of the ones you personally consider polarizing in their fandoms, creating broken bases.


    Try to limit the bashing - we're trying to observe/note an interesting phenomenon of polarization, not butcher a character.
     
  2. Eloi

    Eloi Well-Known Member

    Shinji is not a good example, but Gendo is. As is Asuka. And Rei. And almost every single character in Evangelion aside from Shinji.
     
  3. Draco Malfoy

    Draco Malfoy -REaction

    With Gendo and Rei, most Evangelion fans I encounter agree with the former is a manipulative ******* (even with his Yui obsession) and the latter is the standard Emotionless Girl. Asuka is more polarising, I guess. I just put Shinji up there because he is the most visible character in Evangelion, and most people seem to have differing opinions on him.

    You're right, though. Most of Evangelion's cast would demand an entry. XD
     
  4. ironknight42

    ironknight42 Well-Known Member

    When I read this I though Code Geass, and what do you know I see Suzaku on there. Now with out blatant spoilers by the end Suzaku can either be called the hero of the world or an vengeful angsty japanese person who is punishing himself so yeah. Just as the story progresses though at some points you just want to say wow he's a complete *******. My point is the reactions change, to be fair though I only know half those characters. Hey are we going to start using TV Troupes terms such as Emotionless Girl?
     
  5. Draco Malfoy

    Draco Malfoy -REaction

    Emotionless girl sums up Rei very well. Even if the term doesn't refer to the trope, it would be the way many would describe her.

    Be grateful you don't know who Sekai is and that you've never, EVER watched School Days...
     
  6. Dattebayo

    Dattebayo Banned

    Sasuke without a doubt, he should've turned good again after hearing the truth about Itachi, but no, he decided to destroy the Hidden Leaf Village.
     
  7. arceus7

    arceus7 Arcane Of The Wild

    Am I the only one who can clearly see the ****ing guys mindset perfectly?

    He was a ignorant little child, he walked into his house and he realizes that he brother who he idolized and envied had killed his family, his family who had just started focusing on him, his world collapses This same brother started telling him to focalize his hatread so he could kill his dying brother being non the wiser to the truth that would break him forever, so he spent many years of his life on wasted hatread to hone his strenght via hatred, after he finally suceeds he realizes that all was not as he believed, Madara told him the truth and he felt empty then he realized the flaw lies in the leaf village, having a new scapegoat for his hatread he realizes the leaf isn't his home anymore and just wants it gone so he can feel satisfaction for all he worked hard for and madara plans on using this. It isn't a matter of just hopping on different sides of scale, that is utterly fake, you don't change sides just because of a lack of knowledge
    Sasuke isn't the same person as before he killed Itachi, Madara painted sasuke's canvas gray when he told him the truth about itachi
     
  8. Angelique

    Angelique transcending love~

    "I stab-stab Karin!"

    Anyway, the point of this thread, methinks, is not to argue why a character is so hated or to advance a particular character interpretation. We should focus, instead, on noting some characters who polarize and perhaps discuss why they produce such conflicting perspectives, not start a flame war~

    I'm voting for Fllay Allstar (crazy wh*re versus poor princess). Anyone who is familiar with Gundam SEED should know why. Sasuke is an obvious vote, and Suzaku. I can already sense the Kallen fans girding their loins to toast the poor boy. XD
     
  9. Vernikova

    Vernikova Champion

    I chose Light since I sympathize with what he was trying to do by killing off all of the bad people in the world. I guess he just got a little too crazy for his own good and tried to kill off the police.
     
  10. Lorde

    Lorde Banned

    I think Sasuke had always been "good" though, at least before the conclusion of the Itachi fight. He left his village in pursuit of power, but at that point, he still wasn't totally submerged in darkness (as we saw during his fight with Naruto). I never considered him to be evil until recently, and I'm still not sure he's "unsavable" as most people would have you believe.

    I've always wanted to document the exact moment Light started losing his mind, but I haven't had much luck. I did sympathize with his mission at first, but then he just sort of lost it all at some point and all he wanted to do was chase after those he thought were evil (basically, anyone who disagreed with him). I do feel sorry for him though.
     
  11. arceus7

    arceus7 Arcane Of The Wild

    Death Note's alternative ending is awesome it completely redeemed light.
     
  12. Vernikova

    Vernikova Champion

    From memory, I would place it when L asked Kira to kill him on television and he failed to do it. Now I have to go find out what the alternate ending is so I can found out how he was redeemed.
     
  13. arceus7

    arceus7 Arcane Of The Wild

  14. Eloi

    Eloi Well-Known Member

    When L died, probablly. In other words: starting at 1:57 of this clip http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tX1_K-mUH94. He lost his intellectual opponent and his mind collapsed due to the hole. My theory, anyway.
     
  15. Lorde

    Lorde Banned

    I guess that makes sense, seeing as how Light was left without someone to compete against for quite a few years. However, Light seemed to be slipping up a bit earlier, as Rebecca R. said. I think things started going downhill for Light the moment he met L since he started getting desperate and started making mistakes which L used to his advantage. Just my theory. I haven't watched the anime or read the manga in so long, so I'm a bit rusty. I still feel sorry for him though.
     
  16. weirdamanda

    weirdamanda What a drama llama.

    I'd agree with you. It became more and more of a game, and less and less for his goal. Even if his goal itself was a bit...insane. Becoming the king of a new world created through death is a bit of a jump from cleaning the world of evil human beings, which he said he wanted to do in the beginning.
     

Share This Page