Mystery Dungeon. Is it sequel worthy?

[42]

Do you beleive that after Diamond and Pearl and Battle Revolution that there should be an MD sequel. I say yes. Ita far more good that the crap called Colloseum, and it got a sequel. Perhaps this should have Shinou Pokemon, a different plot, and having Pokemon use more items, like swords.

 

[Lalonde]

it would be cool if you somehow got transported into the future and then turn into a pokemon, then you have to save a sneasel for a weavile or something like that.

 

[Paint_Palette]

Well I haven't played the first one yet, so I really can't answer that. But it may be kinda cool. But if Pokemon had swords and stuff, what would be the point of their attacks?

 

[water types rule]

I don't have MD yet because it hasn't come out yet, but it looks good, and might be sequal-worthy. I wouldn't say Colosseum is crap, but atleast it's sequal XD is alot better,way better graphics,more shadow moves, more shadow Pokemon, battle CDs,Battle Bingo no stupid girl following you everywhere.

But if the sequal had the same battle change as in D/P, then I'd rather it never be made, no matter how good MD is.

 

[Neji Hyuuga]

Wow! Cool idea Toge-oge! Even though I don't even have the first one, a second one would be cool. Maybe they could find a way to link with D/P or the old MD. That would be cool.

 

[Shadow Tyranitar]

the best thing would be if your pokemon from md could be traded to r/s/fr/lg/e,and when they were traded,the stats would go back to regular since it is known that the pokemon's stats aren't as good as the pokemon in r/s/fr/lg/e.Also you could could get celebi,mew,and deoxys this way.But that won't happen because that would defeat the purpose of going to a nintendo event or buying ar/gs for those pokmon anymore.If pokemon used swords,it game rating would go from e to teen or mature because the pokemon would chop eachother up and cut off their arms and legs.BUt yeah,they should have new items that can be traded to r/s/fr/lg/e.

 

[Rayn]

Maybe if they made another MD they could make it so you could be a human and do stuff (like buy stuff that humans make) and be a Pokemon and do the dungeons. It might screw up the story if you could be a human though, but I still think it would be cool.

 

[Yamato-san]

But if the sequal had the same battle change as in D/P, then I'd rather it never be made, no matter how good MD is.

why should that bother you? About the only confirmed major change to the battles in DP is assigning individual attacks to physical or special status, and that shouldn't matter anyway considering 1) It's very easy to raise stats in Mysterious Dungeon (hell, there's a limit of 999 on every stat. You're unrestricted on the amount of vitamins you can give, neither), and it's not like you have to be at an insane level to get through the game. 2) Mysterious Dungeon doesn't have competitive play.

Given, when you take into account those dungeons that temporarily reduce you to level 1 (a feature that I think exists in several Mysterious Dungeon games), the first two points I made can be null and void. However, that doesn't matter either when we get to #3) Pokemon have different level-up stats in Mysterious Dungeon than the main RPGs anyway. A Pokemon such as Tsubotsubo could actually attack worth a damn in a game like this, and evolution is, for the most part, little more than for aesthetic purposes. Why not check out these guides on Gamefaqs (particularly "Level Up Stats" and "Rescue Team Pokedex") for a good idea of what kinda (natural) stats each Pokemon has in this game. It's very much different from the main RPGs, for example, the Casey line actually has a considerable amount of physical attack power, the Wanrikii line has a lot of special attack power. Meganium will seem greatly overpowered compared to the other starters (except maybe Jukain), some unevolved Pokemon will be stronger than their evolved forms, several legendaries will seem greatly underpowered, Dokucale will be more offensive than Agehunt at level 100, etc. Basically, it takes everything you know about Pokemon stats, throws them out the window, and rewrites them completely.

 

[C.J. Ray]

That sounds like a Pokemon game for Ash Ketchum! (Gets fanfic idea and runs off to write it.)

Anyways, I'd love to see a sequel to this using the new Diamond/Pearl Pokemon. Of course, they'd have to make the statues different, but that's a small matter.

 

[Arahabaki]

hmm yes its genius,more RPG-ish(not the ash thing the sequel)