Mystery Dungeon or Pokemon Ranger?

[Meowth! That's right!]

Which is better? Mystery Dungeon or Pokemon Ranger? I might get one of them for christmas...

 

[Ophie]

Well, Ranger got consistently higher reviews than Mystery Dungeon. I've played neither though, so I don't have an opinion.

 

[pokefan]

aww, why isn't there a both option . i love them both and am finding it really hard to choose

 

[Crystal Mewtwo]

I played Pokemon Dungeon and you know, better don't buy it. Its a wasting of money. First game is interesting but later it gets boring, very boring. I think, Pokemon Ranger is better.

 

[DSDude]

i got pokemon ranger,(AWESOME by the way) but i played pokemon dungon in EB games, didn't really seem fun in any form or fashion. I say Get pokemon ranger...(you get manifi)

 

[DSlite]

Dungeon. Ranger sucks like crap.

Even the people in the polls agree.

 

[Crystal Mewtwo]

Dungeon. Ranger sucks like crap.

Even the people in the polls agree.

Because probably they have never played Ranger

 

[Pokemaníaco Desesperado]

Amen. I was going to vote MD just because of that =P

 

[Munchlax3000]

I haven't played ranger yet, but dungeon owns balls!

 

[Haruka]

Mysterious Dungeon.

Ranger is short and boring.

MD is fun and long.=)

 

[jackjack]

I've heard ranger is really short something like 8 hours.
I have Md and i think it is good and long

 

[BlazikenGurl]

I haven't played Ranger yet but I might get that and a DS Lite for Christmas. But I have Mystery Dungeon, it's very repetitive and long, but it's very fun!

 

[Strawberry.]

I haven't tried Ranger yet, but I did order it a couple of days ago. Mystery Dungeon is an awesome game, sure, nothing too extraordinary or groundbreaking, but it's long and never ends.

 

[shiney mew]

I haven't played Ranger yet, but I guess it depends on your opinion. Which would you rather do, be a Pokemon or borrow a Pokemon for temporary use (which actually could be kind of interesting, because you'd have to think about how to use each Pokemon and stuff... kinda sounds like a puzzle)?

 

[Dramatic Melody]

I like Mystery Dungeon. Although I'm not yet done with Ranger, MD puts a new edge in pokemon battle, adventure and capture.

(Plus, being your fave starter rocks!)

 

[Atomic Boo]

i got pokemon ranger,(AWESOME by the way) but i played pokemon dungon in EB games, didn't really seem fun in any form or fashion. I say Get pokemon ranger...(you get manifi)

You don't need Ranger to get Manafi in US and EUR Diamond and Pearl games.

Haven't played either, but i'll end up getting them both eventually.

 

[DarkBlazikenEX]

Get Dungen unless you like circles

 

[Sneasel]

You should get Mystery Dungeon. I like it better since you can actually get to play as the pokemon themselves.

 

[Tejaswi]

I haven't played pokemon ranger but I have played mystery dungeon in Toys 'R' Us. I thought it was boring but that might have been because I didn't know the controls

 

[epic mew]

Mystery dungeon owns, It not only is great and challenging but has a very sad ending.