• Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Naruto vs Inuyasha vs Dragon Ball (Z/GT) vs Full Metal Alchemist vs HunterxHunter

What is your favourite Shounen Anime?

  • Naruto

    Votes: 14 35.9%
  • Inuyasha

    Votes: 3 7.7%
  • Dragon Ball (Z/GT)

    Votes: 5 12.8%
  • Full Metal Alchemist

    Votes: 6 15.4%
  • Hunter x Hunter

    Votes: 2 5.1%
  • Pokemon

    Votes: 2 5.1%
  • Digimon

    Votes: 2 5.1%
  • Neon Genesis Evangelion

    Votes: 2 5.1%
  • Gundam Seed

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Dectective Connan/ Case Closed

    Votes: 3 7.7%

  • Total voters
    39
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

Draco Malfoy

-REaction
This thread is about which shonen anime you like best. As the title suggests, you must vote the most favourable anime from the list. You must vote in the poll and also give one good reason why you like it. You must also choose one favourite character from your chosen anime and explain why you like that character. Noobs are NOT allowed. Note the poll closes in 62 days time. This thread will be locked when the poll has stopped. Here is the list:

Naruto
Inuyasha
Dragon Ball (Z/GT)
Full Metal Alchemist
Hunter x Hunter
Pokemon
Digimon
Neon Genesis Evangelion
Gundam Seed
Detective Connan/ Case Closed
 
Last edited:

Chris

Old Coot
Pokémon and Digimon aren't shonen anime. They're targeted towards both genders. o_O
 
Neither is Evangelion. It a mecha series. It also aim for both girl and boys.
 

Haruka's Swimsuit

Bomberhead 18-kin!
That Scary Clefairy said:
Neither is Evangelion. It a mecha series. It also aim for both girl and boys.

Especially if they like boobs.
Personally, I'm a fan of all things involving Asuka and/or Germans, so I guess I'm in the target audience.
 
If you like thing involving Germans, check out Hellsing manga and soon OVA cause they have nazi in them.
 

HK

Radiance of Shadows
That Scary Clefairy said:
Neither is Evangelion. It a mecha series. It also aim for both girl and boys.

Lol, "Kaworu and Shinji = lurv." But that's besides the point, and the point is that Evangelion is a shounen anime, considering the amount of fan service and... fan boy-ism (I hate moronic Rei fan boys after looking into the fandom... ugh). Not exactly a typical one, but a shounen series nonetheless (mecha series also seem to be synonymous with shounen series), albeit few of the teenage boys watching it would understand it without it being explained to them.

About the thread itself, you don't have One Piece or Trigun up there, and yet Digimon and Pokemon? I weep.
 

Haruka's Swimsuit

Bomberhead 18-kin!
That Scary Clefairy said:
If you like thing involving Germans, check out Hellsing manga and soon OVA cause they have nazi in them.

Well, I already own the first three volumes. No Nationalists yet (well, at least not German ones), but I do a recall a crazed Scotsman... or was he Irish?

EDIT: And I didn't mean the Nationalist Socialists when I said "all things involving... Germans." Being of German descent myself, I enjoy seeing and reading about things regarding Deustchland and its people.



HellKorn said:
Lol, "Kaworu and Shinji = lurv." But that's besides the point, and the point is that Evangelion is a shounen anime, considering the amount of fan service and... fan boy-ism (I hate moronic Rei fan boys after looking into the fandom... ugh). Not exactly a typical one, but a shounen series nonetheless (mecha series also seem to be synonymous with shounen series), albeit few of the teenage boys watching it would understand it without it being explained to them.

I'm curious about something, is Gundam/Eva really typical of giant mecha series? I've only seen one or two non-Gundam series, but I'm curious; is the male protagonist with too much angst/mental problems usually a theme in giant mecha series or have Gundam and Eva done that on their own?
 
Last edited:

Skiks

MUCH RESPECT
Anyways it's obvious I picked Hunter X Hunter. Now the reason why I like this series is simple. The hunter exam intrigued me a lot. That is what got me hooked. Then I was like how could they make it more interesting after the hunters exam. Well with the introduction of nen I got my answer. With nen any character can win a battle with the right ability and tactics used. You don't have to level up your aura to win. (Although it's preferred that you do) In this anime the fights aren't that long but they are very entertaining to watch. Can anyone replace digimon and pokemon to something like One Piece and Trigun. o.o;
 

Dogasu

Frustrated Elf
Haruka's Swimsuit said:
I'm curious about something, is Gundam/Eva really typical of giant mecha series? I've only seen one or two non-Gundam series, but I'm curious; is the male protagonist with too much angst/mental problems usually a theme in giant mecha series or have Gundam and Eva done that on their own?

The protagonists of the various Macross aren't all angsty teenagers. They're just pilots who always find themselves caught up in a love triangle between an older woman and a young singer.
 

HK

Radiance of Shadows
Haruka's Swimsuit said:
Well, I already own the first three volumes. No Nationalists yet (well, at least not German ones), but I do a recall a crazed Scotsman... or was he Irish?

You're talking about the television series. The OVA that is being put out follows the manga much more closely and will put the television series to shame once it is done. Oh, and the man that you're referring to is Alexander Anderson.

EDIT: And I didn't mean the Nationalist Socialists when I said "all things involving... Germans." Being of German descent myself, I enjoy seeing and reading about things regarding Deustchland and its people.

Meh, I feel the same way since I'm damn near about fifty percent German.

I'm curious about something, is Gundam/Eva really typical of giant mecha series? I've only seen one or two non-Gundam series, but I'm curious; is the male protagonist with too much angst/mental problems usually a theme in giant mecha series or have Gundam and Eva done that on their own?

Dogasu's already pointed Macross out, but I might as well comment on Gundam and Evangelion.

Well, consider that the Gundam series first came out in the late seventies (or possibly a few years before that... my memory is foggy here), and then a few decades later we see other mecha anime that is a bit more distinctive than Gundam, the most popular one being Evangelion. Evangelion itself takes a lot of things from previous Gundam series (and no, not just angsty, teenage pilots, either. I'm talking about some aspects of plot) and expands itself on that while invoking some psychology in it (in a way still keeping with the whole 'angst' theme). Then, as years go by, we see anime that are similar in the flow, story, and characters that Evangelion put out -- i.e. RahXephon and Fafner, to name a few.

To sum it all up, blame it on the Gundam series for establishing the archetype, and Evangelion for further enforcing it. Then again, I truly appreciate Evangelion mostly for the fact that it deals so much with psychology and pays homage to Freud and Jung (although, I've never heard any interviews stating that Anno specifically said any of that...) rather than what came before it (originality is a delusion, people).

Oh, I didn't mention my choice the first time around, did I? Well, I would hope that it would be obvious that Neon Genesis Evangelion is my favorite out of the ones listed (including One Piece and Trigun, ftw). I love psychology and Evangelion deals with it amazingly (despite the fact that the Freudian style of self-realization became monotonous at times), and the characters themselves are potrayed in a way that I can't helped but be fascinated by. The ending of the series (The End of Evangelion is the official ending due to the fact that the script for the final two episodes were the basis for the movie, so I'm going by that) was simply stunning to me. The only other series that comes to my mind that gave me such a satisfying ending was when I read Monster, and both of them are at the top of my list for anime and manga (Monster for manga, and Neon Genesis Evangelion for anime).

... I tend to ramble on a lot, so if you have read my entire post, know that you can say that you have real patience.
 

Chris

Old Coot
I believe the Gundam series to blame for all the teenage, mellowdramatic angst would be Gundam Wing. >_> Blame Gundam SEED for pushing it even further. :s
 

HK

Radiance of Shadows
Nope, try going back even further. Try going back before both myself and you, Chris, were even born.

The original Mobile Suit Gundam is what I blame for that, and also considering that a fair share of plot points from that series were used in Evangelion... well, I think you have your winner. Sure, it doesn't mean that others had to copy that style and approach, but it started the phenomenon.

... On the topic itself, I wonder how many are going to choose Naruto and Dragon Ball... ugh. -___-

Yes, I'm mad at the fact that there are very few fans of Hunter X Hunter and Neon Genesis Evangelion here. Ah well, can't expect too much from a Pokemon forum, eh?
 
HellKorn said:
Lol, "Kaworu and Shinji = lurv." But that's besides the point, and the point is that Evangelion is a shounen anime, considering the amount of fan service and... fan boy-ism (I hate moronic Rei fan boys after looking into the fandom... ugh). Not exactly a typical one, but a shounen series nonetheless (mecha series also seem to be synonymous with shounen series), albeit few of the teenage boys watching it would understand it without it being explained to them.

Understandable. Just Eva,despite it crazy fandom, never came across to me as shounen for some reason. :/

HellKorn said:
About the thread itself, you don't have One Piece or Trigun up there, and yet Digimon and Pokemon? I weep.
Unless you're refering to the manga verison, then yes Trigun ANIME is shounan. The manga is actually bordering near seinan. Then again you can tell by the content and atmosphere in the latest chapters.

Haruka's SwimsuitWell said:
, I already own the first three volumes. No Nationalists yet (well, at least not German ones), but I do a recall a crazed Scotsman... or was he Irish?

EDIT: And I didn't mean the Nationalist Socialists when I said "all things involving... Germans." Being of German descent myself, I enjoy seeing and reading about things regarding Deustchland and its people.

Alexdander Anderson is Irish in the manga. In the anime he has a scottish accent. I know of a manga that may not be German but it based on Demark and the manga is called Vinland Saga, if you looking for historical accurete. HK and I are reading it now. Pretty good since it by the same creator of Planetes.

HellKorn said:
Yes, I'm mad at the fact that there are very few fans of Hunter X Hunter and Neon Genesis Evangelion here. Ah well, can't expect too much from a Pokemon forum, eh?

I know that feeling...... :p
 

Haruka's Swimsuit

Bomberhead 18-kin!
Edward Elric said:
I believe the Gundam series to blame for all the teenage, mellowdramatic angst would be Gundam Wing. >_> Blame Gundam SEED for pushing it even further. :s

Sorry, but as Hellkorn said, the original MSG set the tone. Amaro was rather angst-ridden and tended to freeze or freak out at times, but that is quite understandable. He's a young man suddenly surrounded by the death and destruction of war; the animation style of the series may have been rather bright, but the story was much darker than many of its peers at the time.




HellKorn said:
You're talking about the television series. The OVA that is being put out follows the manga much more closely and will put the television series to shame once it is done. Oh, and the man that you're referring to is Alexander Anderson.

That Scary Clefairy said:
Alexdander Anderson is Irish in the manga. In the anime he has a scottish accent. I know of a manga that may not be German but it based on Demark and the manga is called Vinland Saga, if you looking for historical accurete. HK and I are reading it now. Pretty good since it by the same creator of Planetes.

Irish, really? I haven't actually seen the anime yet, but from the way he talks in the manga... I mean, the way it looks, written- I thought it was a thick Scottish Broque.
 
Haruka's Swimsuit said:
Sorry, but as Hellkorn said, the original MSG set the tone. Amaro was rather angst-ridden and tended to freeze or freak out at times, but that is quite understandable. He's a young man suddenly surrounded by the death and destruction of war; the animation style of the series may have been rather bright, but the story was much darker than many of its peers at the time.








Irish, really? I haven't actually seen the anime yet, but from the way he talks in the manga... I mean, the way it looks, written- I thought it was a thick Scottish Broque.

It's Irish cause on DH forum, the editor of Hellsing told them it was Irish. Plus I'm part Irish and know the accent well.
 

RED1992

Well-Known Member
LOL how da hell did Pokemon get 2 votes... It's the worst anime ever. And GT doesn't even count as a part of DB. It's the second worst anime, right behind Pokemon. Pokemon's a dumb kiddy. GT sucked because it wasn't based on a manga. Same goes for Pokemon and Digimon. They both suck dicks.
 

Chris

Old Coot
RED1992 said:
LOL how da hell did Pokemon get 2 votes... It's the worst anime ever. And GT doesn't even count as a part of DB. It's the second worst anime, right behind Pokemon. Pokemon's a dumb kiddy. GT sucked because it wasn't based on a manga. Same goes for Pokemon and Digimon. They both suck dicks.
Keep it up again and I'll make sure you get a permanant ban.
 

RED1992

Well-Known Member
How do I know if I have any warnings?
 

Chris

Old Coot
The fact that I had to tell you about your posts should be enough to tell you to cut the crap out.
 

HK

Radiance of Shadows
I have come to the conclusion that RED1992 cannot even read. If he could, then he would see that Pokemon has zero votes so far.

Anyway... the top two current favorite shounen series so far in this poll? Naruto and Dragon Ball... I don't know why something as small as this is upsetting me, but it just is...

Ugh, whatever. I'll complain about it the next time that I see it go up in favor of these two again. -___-
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top