Been about Two years since I last posted on this thread but I just recently started re-watching the D&P season because I got bored one day and after watching the High Touch opening it Stoked the ol Pearlshipping fire again.
If Dawn was to return in X and Y I think it would be not as a pokemon coordinator but as a result of Buneary's modeling career. Kalos is based on Paris and pokemon fashion and this is excuse enough for Dawn to show up. She could also show up as a performer trainer and I think she'd be a hell of a good one to boot.
As for the actual meeting, I think at first it would be a lot like BW where unlike his reunions with the other companions Dawn decides to screw around with Ash, but it won't last. Serena will quickly become jealous of Dawn teasing Ash bc of her own feelings. This will naturally be played for laughs and I believe that if Dawn did come back there would also be a scene where Dawn and her pokemon cheerlead for Ash again just because it would be hilarious to see Serena's reaction. In terms of Dawn though I think that she would jealous on the inside but would actually hide it because that is simply the kind of person she is. She's energetic and determined but she is also very kind often tries to keep the peace in arguments. Though as time goes on Dawn would tease Ash just to screw with Serena because we all know that deep down Dawn can troll with the best of them when she wants to. Pokemon are often a reflection of their trainers and knowing that I direct you to this little troll:
View attachment 14875
In the end though obviously Dawn and Serena will make up and yay friendship because it's pokemon, but it would be interesting to see how Serena's crush and Ash and Dawn's special bond would play out when put next to eachother.
It's the end of Diamond and Pearl. Ash and Brock are leaving for the Kanto region but Dawn and Piplup both want to go with them to Kanto. However Dawn recieves a message from her mother saying that her Buneary has the chance to become a famous pokemon model. This time though, there is no anime company/gaming company trying to push a Generation 5 pokemon game. In your opnion, what would happen next?
I posted this one for fun and I'll be the first one to answer it. While I love the ending to D and P and think it is the best season ending save for perhaps the departure of the original trio, it also strikes me as uncharacteristic of the characters in the first place. I think what would have actually happened is that Dawn would have chosen to with Ash. The reason I think this is simply because when given every chance to leave Ash she instead decides to stay with him and Brock. For example when given the option to shadow Zoey, an accomplished pokemon coordinator, she instead turns her down saying that she needs to cheer on Ash in his upcoming battles.
Another example is when Kenny battles Ash with the condition that if he wins Dawn has to stay with him. During the fight Dawn cheers for Ash, looks sad when he loses, and afterwards decides to stay with Ash despite everything Kenny has done to make her stay. Now the one hitch to this example is that Dawn in her parting letter to Kenny says he looked kind of cute when he was fighting Ash. But the reason why I don't put much stock into her calling Kenny cute is that at the end of the journey when Ash's battles are finished and he is returning to the Kanto region She still wants to follow him. Ash has already conquered the Kanto region's gym leaders and was simply going there to relax. But Dawn still wanted to follow him there.