Give your best explanations/persuasions/arguments! Even if a choice is a bit dubious, if you come up with a good enough (or funny enough) explanation you just might convince me.
For unconventionally cute I will put down Tyrunt because look how adorable the tiny little dinosaur is, and dinosaurs aren't really supposed to be cute.
For tasty I'll put down Flaafy because lamb is the most delicious meat *licks lips*