• Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Pokemon Anime Awards 2018 - (VOTING CLOSED IN ALL CATEGORIES)

Status
Not open for further replies.

keepitsimple

What would happen if I dropped a moon stone

Genaller

Silver Soul

LilligantLewis

Bonnie stan

GarchompTheAssassin

Water starter fan
Most Informed/Intelligent Member: Dephender
Best Speculator:
Most Contributing/Active Member: shoz999
Funniest/Most Entertaining Member: keepitsimple or Akkipeddi regarding gen 7
Craziest/Most “Out There” Member: Ryu Taylor
Nicest/Friendliest Member: Power Up
Best Debater: VoltTacklingPika

Best Newcomer (joined in the last year): Ignition
Best Old Timer (joined 5 years ago or longer): Pokegirl fan
Most Missed Member (someone who has been gone for over a year):

Biggest Fan of the Original Series: TheWanderingMist
Biggest Fan of the Advanced Series: Alola Adventurer
Biggest Fan of the Diamond and Pearl Series:
Biggest Fan of the Best Wishes Series: satopi
Biggest Fan of the XY Series: Epicocity
Biggest Fan of the Sun and Moon Series: DatsRight

Best Quote/Post:
Best Thread:
Member of the Year 2018:
 
Last edited:

Ignition

World's biggest Incineroar stan
let's all vote for "Genaller/Epicocity/VoltTacklingPika/Rohanator" as best user ever
How is this arguable? Genaller/Epicocity/VoltTacklingPika/Rohanator is a revolutionary part of our community thanks to their impressive discussion skills. This individual deserves every award IMO
 

Genaller

Silver Soul
How is this arguable? Genaller/Epicocity/VoltTacklingPika/Rohanator is a revolutionary part of our community thanks to their impressive discussion skills. This individual deserves every award IMO
Nah man Satomine Night/Pokegirl Fan~/LilligantLewis/Blaze MasterX is the true savior of our community. This individual deserves the greatest adulations conceivable!
 

Genaller

Silver Soul

LilligantLewis

Bonnie stan
Y'all are weird
 

NPT

Just a member
What's with all this off-topic chatter? Well, whatever.

Best Old Timer: Sushi
Best Quote/Post:
I’m honestly not sure where this essay/rant is going to go and it probably won’t be all that structured unlike many of my other essays on this forum. For some background I’m someone who fairly recently quit having an active investment in SM and only intend to watch the episodes involving battle/power scaling feats for Ash’s Pokémon out of a sense of obligation since I have an obsession with giving all of Ash’s Pokémon battle viability ratings.

To start off with I can’t stand to look at Ash though surprisingly most of his “softer” features aren’t the problem; it’s those oversized deformed Z marks. I’m not quite sure whether it’s because they’re oversized or asymmetric, but I feel very unpleasant (like my brain is malfunctioning) every time I’m forced to look at those atrocities plastered to Ash’s face. More generally speaking the character and Pokémon designs are simpler in SM to allow for more fluid animation though frankly I find the increase in fluidity granted by this simplification to not be worth the loss of the more detailed artstyle in the slightlest.

More importantly it seems that the focus of animation has shifted from battles to slice of life making it more apparent that this isn’t my kind of series. It’s not that I inherently dislike series that don’t put focus on battles. Battles in OS Kanto would be an utter joke by modern standards though I still enjoyed that series due to its great sense of humor and character/Pokémon chemistry. On the other hand the sort of “comedy” SM offers made me groan and cringe instead of smile and laugh.

As for our major characters overall I feel quite apathetic towards them. Kiawe’s focus episodes were easily the most engaging (comparatively) though sadly he’s criminally underused. I’ll admit that I’ve grown to like Lana more than my initial impression of her where I thought she was Misty but without the tsundere and actually wouldn’t mind seeing her dream he fulfilled which seems very possible given how tied it is to Primarina’s Z-move it seems to be though sadly she’s also underused. Lillie on the other hand is someone whom I had high expectations for. I really enjoyed her character arc in the games, but this was completely butchered in the anime yet it’s clear that she’s still being pushed as the most important companion. I also had hopes that she could be the first female lead to do a gym/trial quest though it’s clear that with the time remaining coupled with the lack of focus on battles that this is never happening. Overall anime Lillie has been extremely disappointing. Mallow and Sophocles evoke so much apathy in me that I can’t even be bothered to write about my problems with them.

Now as many of you know I’m someone that is heavily invested in Ash's progression as both a trainer and person. I’m not saying that everyone needs to still be invested in this aspect of the series or even whether they should be, but know that this is and always will be the most important aspect of the Pokémon anime for me and with the premise that Ash is supposed to be gradually progressing (both trainer and character wise) throughout the show in mind, SM just like BW is objective trash. Now to be clear the problems that both these variants of Ash had are far from identical. In certain aspects SM Ash isn’t as horrendous as BW Ash (such as battle competency though he’s still pretty bad compared to DP and XY Ash) though in others (character consistency with respect to his past selves) he’s far worse than BW Ash. SM Ash even more so than BW Ash feels like a husk of flesh that the writers inject character traits into in order to fit whatever narrative they’re telling at the time.

I’m not sure which show I dislike more between SM and BW, but I will say this; while BW’s betrayal of Ash’s progression stings a lot more than SM, I could at least sense that “the spirit of Pokémon” was alive and well in BW; however, I sense nothing of the sort from SM.

If XY was the series that restored my hope in the anime, then SM is the series that fizzled most of it out again and has left me on the edge with the gen 8 series being the decisive factor with regards to what side I land on (renewed hope for the show or complete loss of hope and investment in it). Who knew that a show as light hearted as SM could induce such utter despair within me (with regards to the anime’s future) :-(.


That's all.
 
Last edited:

mockingjay

swift and lol
the clutter and spam on this thread is horrendous. what mod allowed this?

anyways my nominations

Pokémon SM anime categories:
Favorite Hero/Heroine (main character) from SM: Kiawe
Favorite Villain from SM: Cancer? How did Stoutland die?
Favorite Pokemon Of The Week from SM: Stoutland
Favorite (Pokémon) Character from SM: Stoutland
Favorite Episode from SM: Episode 21: One Journey Ends, Another Begins...
Favorite Battle from SM: Stoutland vs that fire starter thing

Overall:

Favorite Human Character in the entire anime:
Favorite Pokemon in the entire anime: Stoutland
Favorite Episode in the entire anime: Episode 21: One Journey Ends, Another Begins...
 
  • Like
Reactions: NPT
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top