1. We have moved to a new forum system. All your posts and data should have transferred over. Welcome, to the new Serebii Forums. Details here
    Dismiss Notice
  2. Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
    Dismiss Notice
  3. If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders
    Dismiss Notice

Pokemon Sword & Shield GENERAL DISCUSSION Thread [Spoiler-Prone Area]

Discussion in 'Pokémon Sword & Shield Discussion' started by Kage-Pikachu, Jun 9, 2018.

?

Does this idea seem at all plausible to you?

  1. Nah

    6.9%
  2. Yep

    10.1%
  3. I'm a kangaroo

    83.0%
  1. Mr.Munchlax

    Mr.Munchlax Thunder Trainer

    That’s fair, though I personally liked the Champion Cup since it finally gave me the chance to battle a tournament style Pokémon League similar to the anime.
     
    LilligantLewis and Ophie like this.
  2. AuraChannelerChris

    AuraChannelerChris "Oh, look. A comment."

    Except the player actually can win in about 5 days against endearing people and not wait 3 years just to be tripped by perfect one-dimensional characters they recently just met and restart all over again.
     
    Last edited: Jan 14, 2020
    LilligantLewis and Mr.Munchlax like this.
  3. Team Volt Grunt

    Team Volt Grunt Pokémon Collector

    The elite four aren't that interesting when there is no real introduction or development behind them. Just walking into a room and battling a stranger that has a really powerful team compared to everyone else without any character development doesn't impress me as much as battling characters that have improved throughout the story and have given me reasons to want to beat them beyond being a mysterious and revered character.
    I can agree about the challenge though. auto-heals between rounds and less rounds makes it much less challenging.
     
  4. Dragalge

    Dragalge Constance Rookidee

    But Alola’s Elite Four was developed considering how they were building up to the first League. Aside from Olivia, we got to see Hala, Acelora, & especially Hapu be interesting characters up until the moment where they became inducted. So Elite Four members can be developed well if done right.
     
  5. Ultra Beast Lover

    Ultra Beast Lover Well-Known Member

    I like the Champion Cup, the previous League battles were fine but usually the E4 was completely absent save for a couple appearances meaning that for us they were just strong trainers and not important people in the region. Also, over time it became a little strange how there weren't any spectators, the newer Leagues make sense but the leagues that had been around for a while should at least have a couple people watching.
     
  6. WhiteBlair

    WhiteBlair ベストチャンピオン。

    Champion Cup could've been executed much better if it wasn't only for Gym Leader rematches. That killed the opportunity for welcoming new characters and stuck us to the original 8. Interestingly, I found the post-Champion Cup much more entertaining; with the other Gym Challengers are also being participants.

    The concept of Elite Four; the mystery of new characters, their OST, the feeling of arriving the final destination are what I always look for when a new generation arrives. Johto, Hoenn, Sinnoh, Unova and Kalos nailed in that regard. If only Elite Four would be present in Galar as a part of final-round tournament, that would be excellent. I wanted that suspense for a challenger that I didn't battle before. Galar's felt a bit more like BW2's Type-Expert PWT tournament, which is my only con.

    Regardless, I feel the Champion Cup was much entertaining and the right way to end the plot. As much as I prefer it over the past concept, it needs to be revised to reach its full potential.
     
    Mr.Munchlax likes this.
  7. Emboar_Rulez

    Emboar_Rulez Pokémon Master (Kinda)

    I thought champions cup felt kinda like the anime ex wot for the fact that we didn’t get rekt by a Meowth in boots or because are Pokémon decoded it didn’t want to fight.
     
    LilligantLewis likes this.
  8. Bguy7

    Bguy7 The Dragon Lord

    I love the anime, and I typically like seeing anime influences in the games, but this is one case where it just doesn't work. A tournament setting just doesn't mean anything special in a one-player video game, as it's just a scripted sequence. Tournaments are interesting because they're all about seeing who's best, but in a one-player video game that just not how it really comes across. It should be about overcoming obstacles, and the tournament format just doesn't feel like as much of an obstacle as the Elite Four format.

    You're not wrong, but you can battle those characters you know at any point in the game. For example, we typically get a pre-Elite Four rival battle, but here we skipped that in favor of battling Hop in the tournament. So in a previous game we would have gotten both the battle against the character you care and a battle against an enigmatic trainer that's supposed to be the best of the best. My point being that we only lost something with the tournament.

    And honestly, I would argue that not knowing much about the Elite Four makes them all the more interesting. They're these revered figures that you know nothing about, and therefore you have no idea what you're about to go up against until you're there.


    And really, it's not like we couldn't have both the tournament and the Elite Four. All the tournament was was a way to determine who gets the right to challenge the Champion, and the Champion fight is completely disjointed from it. So really, we could have had the tournament to earn the right, but rather than earning the right to go straight to the Champion, it could have been to earn the right to challenge the Elite Four and Champion. Then everybody is happy.
     
    Last edited: Jan 14, 2020
  9. Pokemon Fan

    Pokemon Fan Knuckle Trainer

    To me the tournament consisting mostly of the gym leaders worked really well from a lore perspective. Namely that in Galar the gym leaders are routinely jockeying to improve their ranking among each other, keep themselves out of the minor league, and perhaps even become champion themselves. Throwing an Elite Four between them and the Champion in these organized competitions would have just further complicated things.
     
    LilligantLewis and Mr.Munchlax like this.
  10. Orphalesion

    Orphalesion Well-Known Member

    I disagree, I can't even remember the names or appearances of most of those Elite Fours from the games you named. I literally only remember Karen, Sydney, Hula Girl and Knight Man and with Knight Man I'm not even sure what type he used. I thought those characters were kinda pointless, since they just sit around in their Elite Four halls and never do anything. The only time the Elite Four worked for me was Alola, where you met most of them at various times during the plot.
    Same goes for the Gym Leaders/Kahunas/Trial Captains.

    So personally I rather have them use characters that have already been part of the story rather than throw four randos in there, just to have more opponents.

    But I do think it can work if they went the Alola route and integrated them into the plot. Like if they had built up your fellow challengers (besides Marnie and Bede) a bit more, the "Elite 4" of Galar could have been four of your fellow challengers.
     
  11. Mr.Munchlax

    Mr.Munchlax Thunder Trainer

    Well, I will say that Flint, Lance, Marshal, & Malva were handled pretty good outside of the pokémon league
     
    Ophie likes this.
  12. AuraChannelerChris

    AuraChannelerChris "Oh, look. A comment."

    To be fair, the Elite Four started to get characterization after RS.

    The fame checker thingy expanded on the Kanto Elite Four in FRLG.

    The Johto(?) Elite Four got expanded more in HGSS (except for Sydney and Karen, I think).

    The Hoenn Elite Four is perhaps the most unimpressive of the lot, though. Not much to go on.

    The Sinnoh Elite Four got some major upgrades and have been seen outside the building at the Battleground and visiting the player's mansion.

    The Unovan Elite Four was also developed. Caitlin becoming one was perhaps the most surprising and adds more to her backstory as Darach's master (what happened to him, anyway?)

    Screw the majority of the Kalos Elite Four, though. Only Malva got a lot out of it.

    The Alolan Elite Four was already made by people the player already met so it kind of doesn't count, but Kahili got the short end of the stick. We still don't get to access the damned golf course in the back of her hotel.

    Galar has no Elite Four but it still sort of uses the theme at the Champion Cup, in a game where every major character (except Sonia and Magnolia for some reason) has more info about them revealed on League Cards.
     
    Last edited: Jan 15, 2020
    LilligantLewis and Ophie like this.
  13. Bguy7

    Bguy7 The Dragon Lord

    Not the focus of your post, but I just wanted to point out that Sonia and Magnlia wouldn't have League Cards because they're not a current part of the league. Oleana doesn't have one either. Everyone you get a card from is either a gym leader, current gym challenger, champion, or the owner of the league.
     
    LilligantLewis and Ophie like this.
  14. AuraChannelerChris

    AuraChannelerChris "Oh, look. A comment."

    Oh well. In all honesty, Magnolia really got the short end of the stick compared to the rest of the cast. And the lack of spotlight is very glaring after coming from Kukui; the most involved professor of them all.
     
    Orphalesion and wolf jani like this.
  15. Bguy7

    Bguy7 The Dragon Lord

    Yeah, I agree for sure. Sonia (and Rose with the introduction) really stole all of Magnolia's chances to be meaningful.
     
    Ophie and wolf jani like this.
  16. Mr.Munchlax

    Mr.Munchlax Thunder Trainer

    Plus the Sinnoh Elite Four got the best treatment in regards to the anime. Each member had at least one episode that gave them lasting & memorable moments than most of the other regions.

    In all honesty, the anime, the Adventures manga, & Masters all do a better job at fleshing out the Elite Four than most of the mainline games do.
     
    Ophie, Ignition and wolf jani like this.
  17. AuraChannelerChris

    AuraChannelerChris "Oh, look. A comment."

    And in my fan fics.
     
  18. Orphalesion

    Orphalesion Well-Known Member

    I don't watch the anime or read the mangas, but however they might be expanded upon in other media doesn't change how they are portrayed in the games themselves.


    Wasn't Sydney from the Hoenn Elite 4? Him and Hula Girl. And possibly two others of whom I do not have a single memory.
     
    Ophie likes this.
  19. Ultra Beast Lover

    Ultra Beast Lover Well-Known Member

    I don't really remember the E4 from Kanto and Johto, I kinda remember the ones from Hoen but barely, I remember Agatha but only because people kept talking about her.
     
  20. WhiteBlair

    WhiteBlair ベストチャンピオン。

    Sure, but it creates suspense not knowing which Elite Four and type you'll face against unlike Galar's Champion Cup, which unfortunately is a recap of whom you've battled in the story. I never liked Alola personally, the group didn't give me a synergy.

    In one way, I agree having someone who has zero relevance to the (post-)story, just sitting in the hall is a boring attempt. On the other hand, I don't want GameFreak to create easily-predictable characters as E4/Champion. Sonia was a top-notch example for that; even though her grandmother was a professor, I didn't see her becoming one until the very end, at least not until the third-version/sequels. So is Caitlin from Unova (Battle Castle Owner) and Malva from Kalos (Holo Caster Newsreporter).
     
    Bguy7 likes this.

Share This Page