• Hi all. We have had reports of member's signatures being edited to include malicious content. You can rest assured this wasn't done by staff and we can find no indication that the forums themselves have been compromised.

    However, remember to keep your passwords secure. If you use similar logins on multiple sites, people and even bots may be able to access your account.

    We always recommend using unique passwords and enable two-factor authentication if possible. Make sure you are secure.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Rank the Female Companions in Battling

Strongest Female Companion?


  • Total voters
    81

1rkhachatryan

Call me Robert guys
Iris's Dragonite is stronger than May's Blaziken,Misty's Gyaridos,and Dawn's Mamoswine as it could easily sweep any of the Female's teams on this list.

In terms of powerhouses

Misty
-Gyaridos


May
-Blaziken


Dawn
-Mamoswine

Iris
-Dragonite
-Excadrill

I think that's going a bit far tbh. Yes Dragonite is strong, I'll agree with that but I don't think he could sweep a whole team, especially not May's.

Glaceon and Wartortle both had ice type moves which would help them and Blaziken isn't about to go down without a fight, especially since Dragonite only has two moves which would do neutral damage to him. I'm pretty sure May can pull a Ash in the Orange league and weaken him with her team and take him out.
 

Sprinter1988

Well-Known Member
So this is in terms of battle prowess?

1) Dawn - strong, varied team all capable of holding their own, all well developed within her time in the main cast.
2) May - mostly strong, but for the most part of her time as a main character many of her pokemon were in their weakest form (Bulbasaur, Squirtle, Eevee) and her return didn't give us enough to see how good these now are after evolving. Also Skitty was pretty bad.
3) Misty - A few reasonably strong pokemon in the form of Staryu, Corsola and Politoed - too bad Gyarados was caught after her time as a main character. Psyduck was super strong when its headache kicked in. There was pretty much no point in her owning Starmie, Horsea and Goldeen though.
4) Iris - Excadrill is a powerhouse, Emolga does alright, Axew is there until he has a gag battle where he is stupidly overpowered, with that power never turning up again, Dragonite was strong but once it started to actually listen to its trainer it didn't win a single fight.
5) Serena - Her team was just a letdown, but then you don't really need to know how to battle if all your doing is baking macaroons and playing dress up.
6) Bonnie - I can only remember Dedenne fighting once. Might have been twice. Can't recall how much of a part she playing in said battle though.
 

Frozocrone

Miraculous!
So this is in terms of battle prowess?

1) Dawn - strong, varied team all capable of holding their own, all well developed within her time in the main cast.
2) May - mostly strong, but for the most part of her time as a main character many of her pokemon were in their weakest form (Bulbasaur, Squirtle, Eevee) and her return didn't give us enough to see how good these now are after evolving. Also Skitty was pretty bad.
3) Misty - A few reasonably strong pokemon in the form of Staryu, Corsola and Politoed - too bad Gyarados was caught after her time as a main character. Psyduck was super strong when its headache kicked in. There was pretty much no point in her owning Starmie, Horsea and Goldeen though.
4) Iris - Excadrill is a powerhouse, Emolga does alright, Axew is there until he has a gag battle where he is stupidly overpowered, with that power never turning up again, Dragonite was strong but once it started to actually listen to its trainer it didn't win a single fight.
5) Serena - Her team was just a letdown, but then you don't really need to know how to battle if all your doing is baking macaroons and playing dress up.
6) Bonnie - I can only remember Dedenne fighting once. Might have been twice. Can't recall how much of a part she playing in said battle though.

If we're including Bonnie then I would put her at or near the top, she has Zygarde (and they've promised to have another journey once she's a trainer). Her Dedenne's pretty useless though.
 

DatsRight

Well-Known Member
If we're including Bonnie then I would put her at or near the top, she has Zygarde (and they've promised to have another journey once she's a trainer). Her Dedenne's pretty useless though.

That would put her no closer to the top in terms of battle skill as Dragonite would for Iris. Cheering Squishy while it godmodded the Megalith isn't really a demonstration of amazing strategy.
 

Frozocrone

Miraculous!
That would put her no closer to the top in terms of battle skill as Dragonite would for Iris. Cheering Squishy while it godmodded the Megalith isn't really a demonstration of amazing strategy.

In skill based ranking, you're right, not much in just saying 'Go Squishy!'.

But in regards to power rankings, Zygarde instantly puts Bonnie up the ladder.
 

PokemonBattleFanatic-

Hardcore Paul Fan
I think that's going a bit far tbh. Yes Dragonite is strong, I'll agree with that but I don't think he could sweep a whole team, especially not May's.

Glaceon and Wartortle both had ice type moves which would help them and Blaziken isn't about to go down without a fight, especially since Dragonite only has two moves which would do neutral damage to him. I'm pretty sure May can pull a Ash in the Orange league and weaken him with her team and take him out.

Okay but combined with all of Iris's pokemon she comes out on top against any of the girls on this list.
 

pokemon fan 132

Well-Known Member
Everyone based on what i read in here are under impression how May, Iris and Dawn powerhouses respectively. That means Blaziken, Mamoswine and Dragonite are at top discussing who is stronger between them.

But I cannot stop but to ponder why is Misty main powerhouse(in my opinion its not the only one) Gyarados so underrated?

Someone would thought that such a force which overrun most pokemon in wild(its particularly hard to catch as well). Pokemon who has excellent moveset like protect, hydropump, twsister, hyper beam, flamethrower. Who defeated three Tentacruel in Cerulean gym like they were joke and destroyed colonel Hanson Shedinja would be viewed in better light.

Most of all howcome only Gyarados is considered as strong pokemon owned by Misty???
I mean i can understand why such opinion prevails for Goldeen and Horsea?

But on what ground Politoad who received lot of development. Staryu who proved to be resilient and highly powerful being capable of taking down much larger opponents(i guess wins over Weepinbell, Tentacruel, Weezing or being equal to mirage Mantine means nothing) or Corsola as one of mot used pokemon by Misty are considered weaklings.

Same goes for Luvdisc who just because in competitive meta in games is rated lowly, doesn't mean same applies to anime. With Misty Luvdic having no problems in defeating Mightiena and Sableye. And Sootopolis gym leader Juan with his win over Growyle through Luvdisc further confirmed how anime=/=games.

Last but not the least Misty has Starmie, but pretty much everyone ignore that factor and how powerful that pokemon could be.
Or Psyduck whose confusion and psychic attacks if headache is strong enough could pretty much defeat all of other girls powerhouses in one blow.

Im just genuinely surprised that gym leader(how many of gym leaders are 10 years old to begin with?
Proving to have skills and innovation to already hold this position?
Completely revolved around training and battling trainer like Misty who has much, much more experience and knowledge about real trainer battles than May, Dawn or Serena?

Tends to be underestimated so much.

I've never seen Ash and Misty ever outsmarting each other in any of the battles they had with each other. Misty using Togepi against Pikachu is "smartness" for some people while for others it's "cowardliness". Misty didn't outsmart Ash in the whirl cup, he lost because of his obliviousness about Psyduck's headache despite being aware of it.

What people view as sign of cowardliness, other view as cunning move from Misty side. Knowing how to effectively neutralize biggest threat to her team(Pikachu). So in a way Misty did manage to outplay Ash there.

Also while Ash did won in end, it was pretty obvious how he won because of plot and directors decision that water starter Totodile goes to him(which many thought was unneeded and would be better of with water specialist like Misty having in long run more optimal conditions to grow and evolve possibly. Hence why two next battles Misty lost, despite Poliwhirl overpowering Bulbasaur in every possible way or Staryu not seeming any weaker than Chikorita leading until it was caught of guard.

Speaking of Psyduck, it was still a clear legitimate win. At end of the day Misty outsmarted Ash in sense of knowing how to act under such dire situation for her turning certain defeat in triumph. Knowing how devastating blows that duck can unleash(funny thing is Psyduck never showed even maximum of its strength given his headache never reached critical point).
While Ash made poor choice of attacks and strategy with Kingler losing deservingly.

Not like Ash deserved win anyway, since Misty against her will ended in such unpleasant situation. Wanting to use Corsola with Psyduck interrupting match. And somehow i doubt Kingler would fare any different vs Corsola whose defense techniques and offense would pose lot of problems for him.
 
Last edited:

Charizard-Fan

Star Wars fan
Not like Ash deserved win anyway, since Misty against her will ended in such unpleasant situation. Wanting to use Corsola with Psyduck interrupting match. And somehow i doubt Kingler would fare any different vs Corsola whose defense techniques and offense would pose lot of problems for him.

I agree about Ash deserving to lose, since he made such an idiotic mistake against Psyduck, I actually think that's one of the worst mistakes he has ever done. However, I have to disagree about Kingler's winning chances against Corsola. Granted, Misty's Corsola showed that it's a very strong Pokemon, I won't deny that. However, same can be definitely said against Kingler. It swept a league favourite's 3 Pokemon in Indigo League and it broke Cloyster's very tough shell. And in Whirl Cup it definitely had no trouble at all against Poliwhirl. Granted, Poliwhirl had gained some damage from Totodile but Kingler nevertheless showed extreme power in it Crabhammer attack, making huge waves on the battle field, and Poliwhirl's Bubble attack did no damage to Kingler (at least it looked like it, maybe it did some). I've recently watched Kingler vs Poliwhirl many times and I'm always very impressed by Kingler's power it has shown in it's few battles where it has fought.

Anyway, I think both Corsola and Kingler would have had a very good chance to win the battle if they had fought. Both were very strong and had good defenses. I'd like to say Kingler would probably win but since I don't remember much about Corsola's battles, I won't give a biased answer and I just say it would be 50/50.

Ash for Ash's and Misty's battle for Totodile, I think Ash won fair and square in a tough match. I also think Bulbasaur's win against Poliwhirl was a deserved one. I just watched it and it's while true that Poliwhirl's Tackle was stronger than Bulbasaur's, I think Bulbasaur had stronger range attacks. Maybe one could say that at that time Poliwhirl was stronger in physical attacks, while Bulbasaur was stronger in range attacks? I think Bulbasaur winning wasn't dem, but Bulbasaur won because it was in the end stronger and it has shown many times it's a stubborn Pokemon with a lot of endurance, so it made sense for it to endure Poliwhirl's attacks, albeit painfully.

As for my opinion about the strongest girl, well I have only watched a few XY episodes so I can't judge Serena properly, although pretty much everyone says she was the weakest. I think Iris had 2 very strong Pokemon (Excadrill and Dragonite) and Emolga was quite good, but I don't think Iris was that great trainer. She wasn't bad, but not particularly good either. She was okay in my book.

I think Dawn was a very good coordinator and a skilled battler, but because she focused on contests, it somewhat takes way from her Pokemon's strength. May and Misty were both good and skilled battlers in my opinion, with some strong Pokemon, so I think they are strongest girls in terms of battles.

However, I would have to rewatch many episodes to judge female companions better.
 

snorlax512

Well-Known Member
Everyone based on what i read in here are under impression how May, Iris and Dawn powerhouses respectively. That means Blaziken, Mamoswine and Dragonite are at top discussing who is stronger between them.

But I cannot stop but to ponder why is Misty main powerhouse(in my opinion its not the only one) Gyarados so underrated?

Someone would thought that such a force which overrun most pokemon in wild(its particularly hard to catch as well). Pokemon who has excellent moveset like protect, hydropump, twsister, hyper beam, flamethrower. Who defeated three Tentacruel in Cerulean gym like they were joke and destroyed colonel Hanson Shedinja would be viewed in better light.

Most of all howcome only Gyarados is considered as strong pokemon owned by Misty???
I mean i can understand why such opinion prevails for Goldeen and Horsea?

But on what ground Politoad who received lot of development. Staryu who proved to be resilient and highly powerful being capable of taking down much larger opponents(i guess wins over Weepinbell, Tentacruel, Weezing or being equal to mirage Mantine means nothing) or Corsola as one of mot used pokemon by Misty are considered weaklings.

Same goes for Luvdisc who just because in competitive meta in games is rated lowly, doesn't mean same applies to anime. With Misty Luvdic having no problems in defeating Mightiena and Sableye. And Sootopolis gym leader Juan with his win over Growyle through Luvdisc further confirmed how anime=/=games.

Last but not the least Misty has Starmie, but pretty much everyone ignore that factor and how powerful that pokemon could be.
Or Psyduck whose confusion and psychic attacks if headache is strong enough could pretty much defeat all of other girls powerhouses in one blow.

Im just genuinely surprised that gym leader(how many of gym leaders are 10 years old to begin with?
Proving to have skills and innovation to already hold this position?
Completely revolved around training and battling trainer like Misty who has much, much more experience and knowledge about real trainer battles than May, Dawn or Serena?

Tends to be underestimated so much.



What people view as sign of cowardliness, other view as cunning move from Misty side. Knowing how to effectively neutralize biggest threat to her team(Pikachu). So in a way Misty did manage to outplay Ash there.

Also while Ash did won in end, it was pretty obvious how he won because of plot and directors decision that water starter Totodile goes to him(which many thought was unneeded and would be better of with water specialist like Misty having in long run more optimal conditions to grow and evolve possibly. Hence why two next battles Misty lost, despite Poliwhirl overpowering Bulbasaur in every possible way or Staryu not seeming any weaker than Chikorita leading until it was caught of guard.

Speaking of Psyduck, it was still a clear legitimate win. At end of the day Misty outsmarted Ash in sense of knowing how to act under such dire situation for her turning certain defeat in triumph. Knowing how devastating blows that duck can unleash(funny thing is Psyduck never showed even maximum of its strength given his headache never reached critical point).
While Ash made poor choice of attacks and strategy with Kingler losing deservingly.

Not like Ash deserved win anyway, since Misty against her will ended in such unpleasant situation. Wanting to use Corsola with Psyduck interrupting match. And somehow i doubt Kingler would fare any different vs Corsola whose defense techniques and offense would pose lot of problems for him.

You sound very biased. Using Togepi against Pikachu is not a "cunning" move, it is a dirty tactic and shows nothing about her skill as a trainer. It is no better than the King of Pokelantis using Sceptile to hide behind the referee, which I don't think you would view as a "cunning" strategy.

How did Ash win because of plot? Chicorita was weaker but had the type advantage to defeat Staryu, and if anything the plot was on Misty's side because of Poliwhirl's deus ex evolution. It isn't stronger than Ash's bulbasaur anyways.

Of course whirl cup was a legitimate win, but it proves nothing about Misty's skill as a trainer. She won because Ash was stupid, not because she was good. Misty told Psyduck to shake himself out of Kingler's vice grip, so it was quite clear that she wasn't planning intentionally for Psyduck's headache to activate.

If Psyduck didn't come out, Ash would have won. It doesn't matter how you think his "defensive and offensive techniques" would pose problems for Kingler, who has swept a league favorite's entire team and broke through a Cloyster's defense. Poliwhirl's bubble didn't even scratch Kingler, who was shown to be clearly stronger than Poliwhirl, who was stronger than the newly caught Corsola.

As for Gyrados, it was caught after Misty left the show so it has done too little for us to pinpoint how strong it is. It defeated three random Tentacruel and Hansen's Shedninja, but I have no doubts that May's Blaiziken or Iris' dragonite would do the same. Also, being a strong species really isn't a good enough argument for me.
 
Last edited:

345ash-greninja

Auto-Memories Doll
You sound very biased. Using Togepi against Pikachu is not a "cunning" move, it is a dirty tactic and shows nothing about her skill as a trainer. It is no better than the King of Pokelantis using Sceptile to hide behind the referee, which I don't think you would view as a "cunning" strategy.

How did Ash win because of plot? Chicorita was weaker but had the type advantage to defeat Staryu, and if anything the plot was on Misty's side because of Poliwhirl's deus ex evolution. It isn't stronger than Ash's bulbasaur anyways.

Of course whirl cup was a legitimate win, but it proves nothing about Misty's skill as a trainer. She won because Ash was stupid, not because she was good. Misty told Psyduck to shake himself out of Kingler's vice grip, so it was quite clear that she wasn't planning intentionally for Psyduck's headache to activate.

If Psyduck didn't come out, Ash would have won. It doesn't matter how you think his "defensive and offensive techniques" would pose problems for Kingler, who has swept a league favorite's entire team and broke through a Cloyster's defense. Poliwhirl's bubble didn't even scratch Kingler, who was shown to be clearly stronger than Poliwhirl, who was stronger than the newly caught Corsola.

As for Gyrados, it was caught after Misty left the show so it has done too little for us to pinpoint how strong it is. It defeated three random Tentacruel and Hansen's Shedninja, but I have no doubts that May's Blaiziken or Iris' dragonite would do the same. Also, being a strong species really isn't a good enough argument for me.

Well, Hansen's Shedninja was shown to be quite powerful, so one-shotting it shows Gyarados's power. But well, May's Blaziken and Iris's Dragonite are also quite powerful as well.
 

Janovy

Banned
You know this poll is all kinds of wrong when Serena is ahead of Misty.
 

Forretress Fan

Let's Go
1. May - 1st female companion with a regional objective that was showcased in a competitive form in the anime.
2. Dawn - We got to see her character get good development, from losing a contest to making a strong comeback
3. Misty - Classic first companion
[TIE] 4. Iris - Actually had an outspoken personality, but I found belitting Ash consisting to a kid from someone of the same age is hypocritical. Also he goal was to help Axew becomes a Haxorus, he never even made it to second stage.
[TIE] 4. Serena - Pokemon's attempt of including shipping in the anime, outside of making shipper's dreams almost become a reality, I can't recall anything prominently she did in the Kalos series.
 

DankOverlord

Komodo Dragons Rule!
God tier.- Bonnie (Zygarde lulz)
1.- Dawn
2.- May
3.-Iris
4.- Misty
Ambiguous: Lana, Lillie, Mallow
Complete wimp tier.- Serena
I´d say Misty and Iris are very close in battling but Iris´s Dragonite edges out her position
 
Last edited:

Frozocrone

Miraculous!
I know, right? I really, really want to remember how strong she is, but for the life of me, I reach dead ends.

I think before Serena was beating Misty by one vote. Can't fathom how Serena is getting more votes...oh wait! Every battle she's finished she's always been on the winning side!
 

DankOverlord

Komodo Dragons Rule!
I think before Serena was beating Misty by one vote. Can't fathom how Serena is beating Misty...oh wait! Every battle she's finished she's always been on the winning side!

YAY even if her Pokemon fainted or were there in the background she definetely won .....JK even Magikarp Fishermen will stomp Serena´s weak team LMAO
 

U.N. Owen

In Brightest Day, In Blackest Night ...
How is Serena leading Misty? Seriously, I want a serious answer. I guess her effective command of Pikachu might make some difference, but I don't see it at all.
 
Last edited:
Top